Member Reviews

I am sorry but due to the formatting of this book it’s impossible to read it on my kindle. I hope that the publisher will relist it in a readable format.

Was this review helpful?

I'm hugely disappointed that I was unable to read this first novel by Louise Minchin.

Having successfully requested it from NetGalley it was downloaded to my kindle. However the manner in which it was downloaded made it virtually illegible. Every row had a number against it and the sentence layout was super fragmented, some lines with only one word fro the sentence on it. NetHalley you have to do better.

SUPER DISAPPOINTED

Was this review helpful?

Ten well known individuals arrive on a remote Scottish Island to compete to win an alluring prize. But this will be no easy win.

As the contestants soon find out, the trials they are expected to undertake during their two week stay are downright gruelling. Still, a little physical activity never killed anyone. But a murderer amongst them might do that and more...

So, while nobody actually expects anyone to die as a result of participating in this reality TV show, they're in for a surprise!

This book takes a familiar trope of recent thrillers, but handles it a little differently. For one thing, the anticipated murder takes place quite for into the book. For another, the story line is consistently gripping, earning the book - despite some minor inconsistencies - a solid 3.5 stars

Was this review helpful?

4 stars.

What a brilliant debut by Louise Minchin.
The concept, the plot, the characters, the atmosphere, the location.
Everything was brilliant. No doubt this will be a huge success.
If you’re looking for a page turner thriller that will you have guessing and second guessing and with plenty of plot twists then this book is for you.

IT'S A PRIZE ANYONE WOULD KILL TO WIN...

Ten celebrities have arrived to take part in the most gruelling - and lucrative - reality survival show ever devised: two weeks completely alone on a remote Scottish island, in the depths of winter.

With a production team that seems incapable of keeping them safe, a gathering storm and the unrelenting gaze of hidden cameras, the contestants are stretched to the limit as they try and outshine their fellow competitors and hide their darkest secrets.

But when a contestant winds up dead, it soon becomes clear that the players are not just fighting for the prize, but for their lives.

Was this review helpful?

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6645109124

A cracking thriller, great premise as long as you are willing to suspend your disbelief, couldn't put it down. Thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This was such an interesting book from start to finish. Very "lockdown-I'm-a-celeb' feels.
Initially I thought it would be difficult to remember who each of the 10 characters were but Minchin describes them and builds them so well that remembering who's who isn't a problem!
I love a good mystery and Isolated Island is full of it! I love the development, I love the sinister feel and I was really surprised at the ending!
Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

I got a review copy of this from NetGalley and I read it very quickly as it was fast paced and easy to read. It’s not a particularly new premise - reality show gone wrong - but the characters were integrating and I wasn’t sure what was going to happen next. The behaviours of the production company seem a bit far fetched but it makes for a good story!

Was this review helpful?

Was offered the opportunity to read this ARC courtesy of Netgalley and Louise Munching. I'm not a fan of reality TV but if it were like Isolation island I might be more inclined to give it a watch!! 😂

Story definitely reminds us that people are not always what they seem and sometimes idols don't deserve the pedestals that people place them on!!

The little twists at the end leave potential for a new story so that could be interesting if the author wanted to carry on.

Glad of some decent characters in here and that provided a balance to the story and happenings.

Was this review helpful?

Title: Isolation Island

Author: Louise Minchin
Genre: Romance

Rating: ★★★★

Isolation Island by Louise Minchin plunges readers into the thrilling chaos of a high-stakes reality survival show.

Ten celebrities, each with their own secrets and ambitions, find themselves battling not just the harsh Scottish winter and the relentless scrutiny of hidden cameras, but also a mysterious killer in their midst.

What I Loved:

Gripping Plot: From the very beginning, Isolation Island grabs you by the collar and doesn’t let go. The premise of a reality survival show turned deadly is not just intriguing but executed brilliantly. The tension escalates with each chapter, keeping readers on the edge of their seats as they try to guess who the killer might be.

Complex Characters: Each contestant is richly developed, with their own backstory and motivations. As their secrets unravel, it becomes clear that everyone has something to hide. The dynamics between the characters add depth to the story, making the reader care about their fates.

Atmospheric Setting: The remote Scottish island, with its unpredictable weather and rugged terrain, is almost a character in itself. Louise Minchin’s vivid descriptions make you feel the biting cold and the growing sense of isolation, amplifying the suspense and danger.

Reality TV Satire: The book cleverly satirises the reality TV genre, highlighting the often absurd lengths to which producers will go for the sake of entertainment. The production team's incompetence and the contestants' desperation to win at all costs add a layer of dark humour to the narrative.

Twists and Turns: Just when I thought I had it all figured out, Isolation Island throws another curveball. The plot twists are well-crafted and surprising, keeping the mystery alive until the very end. The final reveal is both shocking!

Survival Elements: The survival aspect of the show is portrayed realistically, with contestants facing genuine physical and mental challenges. Their struggle for survival against nature’s wrath adds an extra layer of intensity to the story.

Isolation Island is a masterful blend of thriller, mystery, and dark humour. Louise Minchin takes readers on a rollercoaster ride through the treacherous landscape of reality TV, where the line between entertainment and survival blurs. The book’s gripping plot, complex characters, and atmospheric setting make it a must-read for fans of thrillers and reality TV satire!

If you’re looking for a page-turner that will keep you guessing until the very last page, Isolation Island is the book for you. Just be prepared to question the motives of everyone around you the next time you tune into a reality show!

Thank you to The Publisher Headline , The Author Louise Minchin & Netgalley for an advanced reader copy (ARC) in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A gripping thriller based on a gritty reality show that goes off the rails. Narrated by a contestant who is an investigative journalist, the story moves from working out how she will get her scoop to one where she is fighting to clear her name. Would pay good money to see this reality show….

Was this review helpful?

This not-so-gruesome thriller kept me turning the page with twists and turns. Diving straight into a mix of diverse characters, the story fires at a fast pace throughout and I felt the balance of character and plot was successful. Although we don’t necessarily delve too deep into backstories, the plot focuses on their present situation and character flaws, culminating in an exciting and eventful ending. The writing is easy and informal, akin to a more light-hearted genre, so it was a pleasant welcome that although the world is set in vacuous reality television, it explores something a little more dramatic. A good, soft introduction to a murder mystery for someone more likely to pick up a romantic comedy.

Was this review helpful?

Really wanted to enjoy this one and as much as I tried the firmatting on the kindle is so annoying it needs sorting so it can get a true review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a rollercoaster, I really liked the story and the mistery, it was full of twists. I wasn't expecting the end, and with this kind of misteries, that is the best part, when it's really well written.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this story which took inspiration from the current craze for reality competitions. The characters are left on a remote island and have to complete challenges to survive.
I felt this was very typical of Louise Minchin who has undertaken extreme challenge since leaving the BBC and i was interested in the book. The challenges were fairly predictable but the descriptions were written with her knowledge of extreme sport.
The story progresses as expected and develops into disaster. There is a twist at the end which i had predicted.
All in all an enjoyable read. Recommended.

Was this review helpful?

I am super sad :( ((

I was so happy when I got an ARC of this as the premise sounds amazing! I downloaded it straight away, had my cup of tea in hand and ready to settle down for the afternoon to read this. Only to be shocked to find numbers at the beginning and end most lines. It's just not readable.

So upset for Louise that the publisher has not formatted the kindle addition correctly, so no one can read it as it sounds like such a fun read

PLEASE can this be sorted and a new addition sent?? Sat here hoping and praying.....

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely brilliant debut novel from Louise Minchin! and thanks to Louise herself for gifting me a signed copy.

The concept was excellent and the setting was extremely well described I really could picture our location (this would be so great to read in a remote cabin somewhere cold). The character pool was diverse and well represented, and empowering topics were touched upon.

However, I do wish the stakes had been a little higher from these characters and we got more of an outsider looking in POV maybe from the film crew or family/friends on the outside to give it more depth. I also would have loved a few chapters after the final reveals from the characters after the main story took place.

I did guess the overall murder mystery element but I feel that's based on the volume of books I read not on the author's imagination. But I would definitely recommend and would pick up another book by this author x

Was this review helpful?

First novel from Louise Minchin and a really interesting concept. Books based on game shows abound at the moment but Minchin’s had a good start and interesting array of characters. Our immediate heroine had one purpose which seemed a bit obvious. I would have preferred the characters to be a bit more fleshed out, and if the stakes had been a little higher. Would try another book by this author

Was this review helpful?

I'm afraid the formatting is so bad ( there's a number on every line) I could read much of this. I did try but it's just too tiring and hard to follow/ Sorry as this has no bearing on the story!

it sounds really good - a game show on an island in the middle of nowhere. Killer trapped with contestants. Love this kind of thing. Will read later on for definate!

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this is the second kindle book on NetGalley that I’ve been unable to read recently due to the formatting. There are numbers throughout the text which made concentrating on the novel impossible. I read a few pages before giving up.
It’s such a shame that this happens with Netgalley proofs as it means writers are unable to receive fair reviews here.
Obviously the rating I am giving is not reflective of the quality of the novel but the formatting of it.
I hope the issue can be remedied.

Was this review helpful?

This is the fourth book I've read in the past 12 months based around the premise of a reality show gone wrong (the others being The Holy Terrors by Simon R. Green, The Escape Room by L.D. Smithson, and The Traitors by C.A. Lynch). It's a pitch that I'm really drawn to but thus far I can't say I've found an execution of it that I actually enjoyed. Isolation Island is my latest attempt to scratch this particular itch. Here's the blurb:

IT'S A PRIZE ANYONE WOULD KILL TO WIN...

Ten celebrities have arrived to take part in the most gruelling - and lucrative - reality survival show ever devised: two weeks completely alone on a remote Scottish island, in the depths of winter.

With a production team that seems incapable of keeping them safe, a gathering storm and the unrelenting gaze of hidden cameras, the contestants are stretched to the limit as they try and outshine their fellow competitors and hide their darkest secrets.

But when a contestant winds up dead, it soon becomes clear that the players are not just fighting for the prize, but for their lives.

Reviews for this book quite frequently compare it to Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None, which was one of my favourite books I read last year, and the blurb promises a thriller in which a killer is on the loose and the isolated characters have to fight for their lives. That's not really what I got.

The murder in this murder mystery doesn't occur until nearly two thirds of the way through the book, and I spent much of the time leading up to it waiting for it to happen. Had this time been spent getting to know the characters, giving them all motives for the murder yet to come, and really rooting us in the world then I would have been fine with it, but weirdly it's not until after the killing takes place and Lauren (our investigative reporter main character) starts to dig into things that we really begin to get a sense of who these people are. Because of the comparisons to And Then There Were None I was also expecting that once the killing started nobody would be safe, but it seems that the people making that comparison either didn't read this book or haven't read Christie.

Murder mysteries - and especially those trying to work in the same space as Agatha Christie, the best to ever do it - require that the writer has a very firm grip of events. Christie's characterisation is often lacking but you always know that the plot is locked down as tight as it's possible to be. Every detail matters, and if you pay enough attention you can maybe hope to piece things together. That's unfortunately not the case here. At times Minchin seems to lose track of the situation she's set up. On the night of the first proper eviction from the reality show, for example, the contestants are instructed to pack their belongings and they line up with "their bags in their hands". The problem, of course, is that we saw a member of the production crew burn everyone's clothes and belongings on the beach before they arrived at the monastery, so nobody has a bag or any possessions to pack into it. The only things they own are the robes they're wearing and wooden toothbrushes that have been given to them, and I don't know why anybody would bother to pack them up to take them home.

This lack of attention to detail also extends to our sense of the timeline of events, and how little sense we get of time passing in any meaningful way. At one point Lauren worries about how she might be blamed for the death and how she has no alibi for the time it took place, telling herself that "she had been on her own most of the day, walking along the cliff path, replaying the events of the night before". But when we see this take place a few chapters earlier it's in a sequence that lasts for barely a paragraph and gives the impression that her walk lasts for a few minutes before she heads back due to poor weather, and as we move towards the climax Lauren tells us "she was walking for around an hour". This sort of thing happens regularly, where we jump from morning to evening with no real connective tissue, so that we start to lose track of how much time has actually been spent on the island and how far removed events are from one another or how long things take. And though this seems like a small quibble, it's on these sorts of details that murder mysteries live and die. The reader needs to be able to feel like they have all the clues needed to solve the mystery to hand, and that's impossible when the facts of the case keep changing in ways that feel like mistakes rather than intentional revelations.

I'm being fairly critical here but with all of that said, I still found myself gripped and wanting to keep reading. Once the murder actually happens and the plot starts to move the book is much more impressive, and the reveal at the ending is seeded in a way that allows you to predict it a page or too earlier and feel smart about solving the mystery, despite the lack of any meaningful clues in the rest of the narrative. The writing isn't flashy or particularly impressive - it's downright clunky in places - but it's got that page-turning thriller quality to it that kept me up past midnight wanting to know what was going to happen next and where this was all going, and the ending was satisfying enough that I came away feeling that I'd enjoyed it despite being critical in the first half. This is the sort of book I'd pick up in an airport and read on the plane at the beginning of a holiday and would think that I'd got my money's worth before leaving it at the hotel book swap. Of the handful of "reality TV gone wrong" murder mysteries I've read this year this was by far the best.

Was this review helpful?