Member Reviews

Ok. Can we talk about this cover for a sec? Because it’s stunning 🤩 Sometimes YAs can read a bit young, and the MCs can get a little whiny & annoying. While this still reads young, it’s definitely an older YA, and I really enjoyed the MCs. I love that this is a fantasy that has a real world element where the MC is thrown into a supernatural world that she didn’t know existed. This one is in the same vein as Harry Potter, Percy Jackson and it reminded me a lot of the TV show Legacies (a spin off of The Originals/Vampire Diaries). I will recommend this to those who like a fantasy that is low on the spice with a dark academia element to it. Overall great debut!

I’m working on my Instagram review right now. It’ll be scheduled for Tuesday 8/6 on @booktrovertnextdoor. I posted a star review on my Goodreads.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 ⭐️ rounded up.

I really struggled to get into this book and connect with the characters but about halfway through the plot and pacing picked up and I found myself really interested in what would happen next.

The characters thought process and romance feels age appropriate which is actually a little refreshing, but it does make the book read more on the Teen side of the Teen/YA spectrum. Just something to be aware of if that’s not your scene.

While I would say that this book in particular was kind of just okay for me, it cultivated enough interest for my by the end that I would be interested in reading a sequel which is why I rounded up.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Very unique story and charaters.I was very intrigued.
Highly recommend for everyone.
Couldn't put I down.

Was this review helpful?

ARC Review

A beautifully written story which hooked me from the first chapter!

The story follows a dual POV of both Tempest and Jet.
Following the death of her parents Tempest has been struggling with her grief and no longer feels like she fits in. A chance encounter at a residential camp reveals a whole new preternatural world to her and exposes that not all her feelings of disassociation were down to her grief.
As a trainee protection officer, tasked with keeping the preternatural world secret from humans, Jet's world is turned upside down from the same encounter.

I loved this book from the get go and the dual POV is really well done. Such wonderful character development and story line which took me through the whole range of emotions. I really appreciated the exploration of the characters mental health and emotions throughout the story. Can't wait to find out how the story ends in the sequel.

I think this book would suit anyone who likes YA fantasy & specifically paranormal fiction exploring shifters, other worldly beings etc.

I do feel the book could be improved with some further development. Especially following the big event in chapter 33, as I feel the story tapered off after this and did a disservice to Andre.

Triggers: death/death of parents
Romance tropes: Slow burn
0/5 🌶️ rating

Favourite Quotes:
The obvious answer to my illness is the same as it always is: anxiety.

Isaac lumbers away from me and back towards his friends with his tail between his legs - figuratively, thank the Universe.

I wish, for the millionth time since starting high school, that I possessed the ability to act normally in social situations. But no, show me a hot guy by a quiet lake and my instinct is to act like an absolute freak.

"Just because someone isn't looking for something doesn't mean you should leave it to be found. Knowledge is power, Tempest. It's our job to protect the balance of power."

"She's cute for an abomination."

My bad nights are plagued by racing thoughts. My worst nights are plagued by silence.

Tempest wrinkles her nose but there's amusement in her eyes. "So, he was nerd-famous. I bet he loved that."

It seems so novel for a dad to be reading the newspaper at breakfast, but I suppose that social media and cable television is out of the question for sharing news about the preternatural.

"You're at Versi now, chica. You need to get used to the unexpected."

"I'm not of the belief that there are coincidences in this world. The Universe has a plan for all of us. All we can do is rise to the occasion."

"I'm supposed to believe that you would find after-school study sessions fun?" Andre stammers back with a gasp, dramatically clutching at his heart. "You doubt my scholastic prowess!" he accuses, his tone dripping with melodrama.

"Great Universe," I say, shaking my head. I'm watching Tempest with fresh eyes. "I can't believe I didn't see it before." "See what?" she demands. That fire that I've grown accustomed to is kindling again. "You're a nerd."

"The whole preternatural thing is complicated enough without bringing science fiction into it. Please tell me we can't time travel because then I'm really done."

"All I've ever wanted is to be a hero, Tempest. Thank you for letting me be yours."

Grief is always devastating, but there's something particularly horrifying about it happening when it's not meant to. Death is something that should only come for the old and the sickly, and pain should only ever be felt by those who have inflicted it.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a wild ride and I loved the dual POV which pushed the story along very well. The plot feels familiar but the writing style kept it fresh. I loved Tempest's character and hope to see her in future books.

Was this review helpful?

“A Trace of Something Stranger” by Allison Giordano is a pretty cool YA fantasy read. It’s about Tempest, who gets thrown into a wild supernatural world. She teams up with Jet, to navigate all the craziness and avoid a dangerous group that’s after her. The dual POVs between Tempest and Jet keep things interesting and really help you get to know both characters.

The worldbuilding is great and really pulls you in, but I wish there was more about Tempest and how she’s adapting to this secret world. The romance is well done, and if you like a mix of action and love, you’ll enjoy it. Overall, it’s a solid start to a series with a lot of potential, especially if you’re into shapeshifters and high-stakes drama.

Thank you NetGalley and Sungrazer Publishing for sending this book for review consideration. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Review links:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/6684981830
https://www.instagram.com/p/C90veLHS6x5/

Review text:

A TRACE OF SOMETHING STRANGER - ALLISON GIORDANO

As someone completely new to NetGalley, I was delighted to be granted access to A Trace of Something Stranger, which immediately caught my attention due to its beautiful cover and description. And I'm very happy to say that my expectations were NOT disappointed. Here's a quick synopsis:

Tempest thought losing her parents would be the worst thing to ever happen to her - until Jet, a young officer with an enforcement agency in charge of protecting a supernatural world Tempest had no idea existed, reveals to her that her parents were actual murderers, and that a fanatical splinter group of this secret world Jet has sworn to protect won’t rest until Tempest is dead.

Yes, the plot is pretty high stakes and there are some real moments of tension when I was truly anxious for the characters. I'm not always the biggest fan of dual POVs, but I felt like alternating between Tempest and Jet helped to move the story forward effectively, as well as helped to explore their personal journeys.

Giordano's writing is descriptive and clear, where her worldbuilding is not only memorable but also rich enough to keep the reader interested throughout. It definitely feels like A Trace of Something Stranger is the start of a much bigger storyline, which I'm looking forward to following in the future.

There was one area of the plot that I felt was lacking, where I would have loved to hear more about Tempest's actual classes and learnings once the story felt like it was heading into a dark academia route. Instead, the storyline very much focuses on the League of Protectors. I think adding a little more about Tempest's experiences of being thrown into this new world and schooling would've created a little more balance to the plot.

Would I recommend it? Yes! It's an excellent start to what feels like a promising young adult series, and the shapeshifting alone makes this a fascinating read.

Review score: 4/5

Release date: September 2024

TW: parent death, injury, death, grief, mental health

Was this review helpful?

• YA fantasy with some romance, shapeshifters, dual POV, succubi, secrets, mystery, found family, dark academia.•

It has been awhile since l've read a YA fantasy novel that actually felt YA. I absolutely adored this book! The novel follow Tempest's who after her parents were murdered she lives with her "overprotective" aunt. Tempest takes a risk to go on her senior camp trip for the weekend by lying to her aunt about the camp. A quick turn of events happens at the senior camp weekend trip and Tempest is brought into the world of preternatural.... Make sure to pick this book up by @allison_giordano when it's released this September to find out about the preternatural and why Tempest's aunt is s00000 protective of her....0000

**Side note: I love when an author ends a chapter with a little" cliff hanger" and this book did that.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for proving me and ARC for this book

Phew so, I’m really disappointed I had to rate this book low, because realistically it was good.

The writing was good, the plot was good, and it was a true YA book which I really appreciated. The MMC was respectful, the relationship wasn’t overly toxic, and it dealt with issues of grief that I appreciated.

However the issue arose with a specific piece of culture that was used that is of the Diné (Navajo). Im not Native American myself, hell I’m not even American, but when it came up I felt a little off about it, and so I checked up on it. I researched myself, and also reached out to members of the Diné community and was met with a resounding answer that my gut feeling was correct. There are some parts of cultures, especially those that have been oppressed and attempted to be wiped out entirely, that aren’t there for everyone to use and write into stories.

This creature in particular that was used is one of those things, and it took me 5 minutes of research to discover that, and another 5 minutes of reaching out to members of the community to ask directly.

Now granted, I don’t know if the author is Diné, and if she is I will gladly revise my rating, but from everything I could find online, I don’t think that is the case. I also don’t know the range of opinions within the community about this matter, but it was a little off putting to me and to those I spoke to, and it’s not something I can just ignore.

It is a shame, because i enjoyed it up until that point, but using closed parts of a culture isn’t cool or fun and we gotta listen to own voices here

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

This book has potential.
Now I read an ARC of this book, so there's room for a lot of the grammatical and typographical errors to be cleaned up before publication, so I am not going to focus on that (there were more than your average ARC though.)

I've been in a bit of a reading slump lately, with not much catching my attention, so when I picked this one up and was drawn in right away, I got excited.

Unfortunately, this feels like a draft with a lot of potential (maybe a second or third draft). But not a finished product.

The first third of the book is great. Interesting characters, action, etc. But once that first arc is complete and we move to the next, everything falls apart a bit. There's a lot of telling instead of showing, big info dumps and not much movement plotwise.

It picks up again a bit for the last 7-8 chapters, but by then, I had lost my enthusiasm for the story.

I think the author shows a lot of promise, and I will definitely try her work again. This one just needs some more polishing.

Was this review helpful?

I think I’m going to have to give this one 3.5 stars, rounded up. It’s got potential, but ultimately, my interest waned the further I read. This is kind of like a Harry Potter meets Percy Jackson story. Tempest finds out she has a very unusual background and that there are others willing to kill her for it. She then moves to a private compound where there are many similar people, and she learns more about where she came from. Add some pining and romance, and you’ve got “A Trace of Something Stranger.”

Now, I’m not a sweeping romance kind of person, but I don’t mind some sprinkled into a story. This one was over the top, for me. I’m paraphrasing, but stuff like “He couldn’t control his protective urges and didn’t know why” just makes me annoyed. You just met!!

I received a copy from NetGalley and Sungrazer Publishing (thank you!), and I am publishing this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

A Trace of Something Stranger: 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Having to wait for the next book: 😢

The novel begins with Tempest, an orphan, going on a senior class trip to a campground. She has a conversation with a recently-graduated chaperone for another school, Jet Delancey, which kicks off a chain of events that drag her into a hidden preternatural community of shifters, magi, and other mythical beings.

It's a super easy story to get sucked into. Tempest, Jet, and the supporting characters are all well-written. The slow-burn romance is a sweet touch, and feels totally natural. What really stands out to me is the author's world-building. I like that she draws from very diverse supernatural myths--Indigenous American, Japanese, and Greek, to name three--and deftly weaves them together to form this modern preternatural world.

Any fan of YA fantasy will love this book. One of my favorite reads of the year thus far.


Posted on Goodreads on 7/20, will be posted to Instagram in September, and will be posted to Amazon upon release.

Was this review helpful?

This is a good young adult urban fantasy, set in today's time with shapeshifters and other preternatural creatures that live among us. The concept of the book is very intriguing - Tempest is a girl who finds out about the existence of a hidden community of shapeshifters and that she has closer ties to this world than she expected. The book is written in dual POV, switching between Tempest and Jet - a member of the League of Protectors who are charged with the safeguarding of preternatural beings.

The POVs are written exceptionally well, as the next chapter starts where the other character's perspective left off, meaning that the story is fast-paced and remains engaging. The world-building is unique and blends together various myths, legends and traditions to make a truly cosmopolitan lore. The characters are lovable and written in way that makes you believe these are real people. Giordano clearly has a knack for crafting and conveying deep character relationships.

The story was very riveting and easy to follow. I finished the book in 2 days but definitely could have finished it in 1 if I had the time. Having said that, the book could have been longer. It feels as if a third or half of the book is missing. The main conflict in this book was not resolved or close to a resolution. I understand that this builds a great foundation for the next books in the series, but in my opinion it would have been even better if this first book could (to an extent, of course) stand alone. Despite that, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book and would definitely recommend it to fans of young adult fantasy. I will be on the lookout for the next book.

This book is perfect for fans of Rick Riordan or Stephanie Meyer. Fans of mythical/preternatural creatures in a school setting will absolutely love this!

Review Platforms: My review was published on Goodreads and Storygraph (both on 18 July), and will be reviewed on Amazon(.nl) on release day.

Thank you for the a-ARC.

Was this review helpful?

**Book Review: A Trace of Something Stranger by Allison Giordano**

Rating: ★★★★☆

Allison Giordano's "A Trace of Something Stranger" is a compelling journey into the unknown that captivates readers with its unique blend of mystery and preternatural elements. Giordano has crafted a narrative that is both intriguing, thought-provoking, and even suspenseful at times making it a standout in the genre.

The story follows protagonist Tempest, who stumbles upon a series of inexplicable events after attending a short summer camp. As she delves deeper into the preternatural secrets, she uncovers layers of hidden truths that challenge her understanding of reality. Tempests world is flipped upside down when she uncovers the truth about herself, her parents, and the people from Versi High.

Giordano's ability to weave suspense with moments of genuine human connection is one of the novel's greatest strengths.

One of the highlights of the book is its richly developed characters. Tempest is a relatable and well-rounded protagonist whose journey of self-discovery is both compelling and inspiring. The supporting characters, each with their own quirks and backstories, add depth to the narrative and keep the reader engaged.

Giordano’s writing style is another standout feature. Her descriptive prose vividly brings to life the eerie/intriguing atmosphere of the town, making it almost a character in its own right. It really feels like the atmosphere of Forks from Twilight. The pacing is well-balanced, with just the right amount of tension to keep readers on the edge of their seats without feeling overwhelmed. (And trust me.. she had me gripping my chair a few times from the suspense! Ha-Ha)

However, the novel isn't without its flaws. I’ve noticed a few grammatical and punctuation errors here and there. I would be more than happy to provide the publisher/author with these errors upon request. I’ve also noticed a few unnecessary run on detail, almost too detailed; along with some “wandering” paragraphs.

Despite these minor issues, "A Trace of Something Stranger" is a thoroughly enjoyable read that will appeal to fans of mystery and preternatural fiction. Giordano has proven herself to be a talented storyteller with a knack for creating immersive and engaging worlds.

In conclusion, "A Trace of Something Stranger" is a strong addition to Allison Giordano's repertoire. It’s a book that entertains and intrigues, leaving readers eagerly anticipating her next work. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a gripping and atmospheric read.

*DISCLAIMER* This is NOT a paid review. This was a voluntary early access read made possible by NetGalley the Publisher and Author Allison Giordano. I want to extend a huge thank you for allowing me access to this E-Arc! I hope my review provides helpful insight.

*PLATFORMS* This review is available on Barnes & Nobles (if applicable), Amazon (If applicable), Walmart (If Applicable) , NetGalley, GoodReads & Facebook.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, Allison Giordano, and the publishers for allowing me access to the e-Arc.

4.25 stars

I really enjoyed all the vibes that this book gave. It starts with a summer camp where she meets a guy that she is drawn to. It has dark an academia and magical school vibes for the rest of the book. There are a lot of secrets that will be revealed. We follow our FMC Tempest who lost her parents years ago. Her aunt took her in and has protected her from harm. There is a slow burn romance. I thought this book was very well done.

I would definitely recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

This book was so good. I love when fantasy books have a handful of everything good on this gender of books. It's so rewarding to read a book and have that feeling in the heart that it was perfect!

Was this review helpful?