Member Reviews

I liked this ,I have loved liane moriarty for many years bar the past couple of recent novels . This is better than her recent efforts but still not quite where we were in terms of being gripped
This is still worth a look but isn’t all that gripping
I did enjoy the initial intrigue and concept and I preferred it to the one about the retreat think called twelve strangers of something and also apples never fall far from the tree but no where near where the husbands secret was in terms of page turning events
I cdnt recall here which death went with which character and lost site of who had passed and didn’t seem that many to what initially the women predicted
If I sound muddled i am
It’s a better effort and lianne is truly talented and this shows promise we getting bk to her epic writing days but we not there yet
Ty though so v much for advanced copy though . A treat to see in my inbox

Was this review helpful?

From my past experience with this author, I knew I’d get a mix of mystery, human interest, humour, and pathos. She’s normally pretty good at getting the balance right, but not always. Which way would this one go?

We are introduced to quite a large group of characters who’ve boarded a flight between Tasmania and Sydney. A woman – Cherry – starts wondering down the aisle announcing to passengers on either side both age she expects them to die and also what the means of their death will be. Its impact is either that it's simply an amusing side-show or alternatively that it's a truly alarming experience. Certainly, a number of the passengers and crew are severely spooked by the experience.

Eventually, Cherry is persuaded to sit back down. But the damage has already been done for a number receiving Cherry’s prophesy, particularly those whose end is predicted to be sooner rather than later. From this point we’ll follow the plight of a number of these people. We’ll also learn a good deal more about Cherry and just how it came to be that she’d behave in this way on this particular day.

Moriarty is good at describing people through the conversations they have with family, friends, and others. After a series of exchanges, I normally feel that I know these people. Here, the characters now worry to a greater or lesser extent (mainly greater!) about how their futures might now play out and what they might do to mitigate against their predicted fate. Of course, some had received what might be considered good news, but it wouldn’t be any fun to focus on them, would it?

It’s actually pretty good fun to start with, but in my eyes, it did take a little too long to play out. That said, as the story moved towards its end, I found that I was increasingly feeling anxious about what would become of some of the people I feel I'd got to know and like. I was also increasingly sucked in by Cherry’s story – she being the most interesting character of them all. In the final reckoning, there are surprises – one big one, in particular – and I have to admit that as the final scene played out, I realised that I had a tear in my eye. Yes, despite a number of debatable co-incidences being revealed, the story really did have more potency than I'd expected.

Was this review helpful?

I just could not get into this book. There were too many characters which made it really hard to follow and I quite honestly find the whole prophecy scenario absurd. I gave up about 25% of the way in.

Was this review helpful?

There were aspects of this story that I enjoyed. Cherry was an interesting character with a lot of heartache to her story. The opening scenes on the plane are a little confusing, due to the multiple POV but once I got used to it I could appreciate the different characters. I did find this one a little slow though and was glad that I listened to the audio. In my opinion it was perhaps a little too long. Thought provoking and interesting, it would make a good book club pick for the discussion alone.

Was this review helpful?

On a flight from Tasmania to Sydney a woman suddenly stands up and starts to compulsively tell the other passengers their expected cause and age of death, among them a young man coming back from the funeral of his best friend, a newly married couple, a workaholic father, a mother with two young children and an older couple looking forward to their retirement.  It is through these people, and the so called ‘death lady’ that the story is told.
 
This was such a gripping read and as time went by I became more emotionally invested in the outcomes for the characters, making the story even more tense!  It was also unexpectedly humorous in places considering the ‘final destination’ style premise of the book, I especially enjoyed Cherry’s appreciation of certain young celebrities!  But what I really loved about the book was all the questions it raised … would you want to know when and how you were going to die, and what would you do with that information?!
 
I have loved many of this author’s books but I think this might be my favourite!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 - This review contains spoilers.

I do think I went into this book with the wrong expectations and that is partially on me, partially on it being semi marketed as a thriller (nothing thrilling happens and I do believe Liane Moriarty herself said that).

I started off really enjoying the premise and was excited to see where it was going, nearly every chapter ends on a suspenseful note that implies this might be the moment a death happens and, at first, that was a good way to keep me engaged with the story. However once I started to realise that none of the main characters were actually going to suspiciously die I started to lose interest and those chapter cliffhangers started to feel more annoying - don’t tease me with a good time only to not do it at all!

I didn’t know I was reading a book about how you had to live your life to the fullest no matter what but one I realised I did roll my eyes just a little and lose interest personally. I also felt this message could have been done better if the characters had spiralled more but it felt, for most of them, it was a minor anxiety at best.

While I didn’t end up loving the book, I did enjoy the writing style and I would be willing to read more of the authors work. If I had gone in with the right expectations I might have preferred this book more.

Was this review helpful?

It’s good to read a book with a more unusual narrative. There soon became too many characters to keep track of. The ending disappointed me in that it suddenly plunged into the life of Cherry – almost a separate storyline.
I found the sudden switching into different points of view very confusing. I’m not sure if it was copy or the actual edit but switching mid-paragraph was difficult.

Was this review helpful?

Here One Moment by Liane Moriarty is a story about whether you would want to know your future? Passengers on a normal domestic flight aren’t given a choice, when an elderly woman gets up and walks down the aircraft giving passengers predictions on when they will die. For some passengers the date of their date is when they are 103. For six passengers though they are given shorter time spans.
The storyline looks at their lives and whether the predictions come true. The story also looks at the life of the woman who gave the predictions and what could have caused her to act so out of character.
An interesting and unusual storyline.
Recommended

Was this review helpful?

I have read all of Liane Moriarty’s books and enjoyed them, except for Apple Never Falls, which I couldn’t even finish, so I was hoping this new novel would bring me back to her - and it did.
I just want to care about the people in the books I read and be entertained by their lives and their journeys, and that is exactly what was missing (for me) in Apples but entirely present here.
The mysterious woman on the plane when the novel begins was enough to get me hooked and it was surprising how quickly I started worrying about the characters whose deaths she predicted!
There is a lot going on here, sometimes too much. Also a lot of characters, some of whom are unnecessary. However, ultimately it was an enjoyable read and since I judge books on how much I look forward to going to bed to read, this one certainly achieved an early bedtime.

Was this review helpful?

This is a hard review to write because Liane Moriarty is one of my favourite authors so I don’t like to offer any criticism. However I must give an honest review and admit it felt a bit of a chore at times. There are always lots of characters in. Moriarty’s books but for the first time ever I struggled to sort them out and had to really think about who they were each time they made an appearance. I do wish I had gone for an audible version because the ARC format made for a lot of confusing when there was a sudden change of POV.
I stuck with it and overall I’m glad I did. There is always lots to like in a Moriarty tale and this was no exception plus it has come into my mind lots of times since I finished it so that must mean it had a message worth reading.

Was this review helpful?

A plane is delayed on a flight from Hobart to Sydney. There are a mixed bunch of passengers each reacting to the inconvenience in different ways. Eventually they are airborne. An unremarkable woman in her sixties stands up & moves down the aisle. She points to various people stating the age at which they will die & what will be the cause of death. Needless to say this really upsets the receivers of her 'prophesies'. They try to shake it off with the thought that she is obviously a disturbed woman- that is until people die as she predicted!

No-one knows who the 'Death Lady' is, but needless to say Social Media has a field day speculating about her identity. The reader knows who she is because a large part of the story is the story of her life. The rest is taken up with the passengers & what happens to them.

This book had a rather confusing start & was unlike most of Liane Moriarty's books where you get to know the characters very early on. I struggled to keep reading but I'm glad I did because it turned out to be a fascinating exploration about destiny & self determination. Thanks to Netgalley & the publisher for letting me read & review this book.

Was this review helpful?

"Later, not a single person will recall seeing the lady board the flight...Nothing about her appearance or demeanour raises a red flag or even an eyebrow."

That's how the story begins, as a random group of citizens boards a routine flight between Hobart and Sydney.

But on that flight everything changes when the seemingly innocuous woman stands, trance-like and makes her way through the aircraft, informing everyone of her unsettling predictions.

"Age of death. Cause of death."

What would you do if you'd been told when you were going to die? When your children were going to die? The cast of characters try to brush it off as a fit of insanity or old age, but when a sudden, young death occurs soon after the flight, it hits a little too close to home.

What unfolds after the flight is a fascinating exploration of human nature. Empathy, grief, love and more are all deftly dealt with in this established author's hands. Some characters make lifestyle changes in order to escape their fate, while others become determined to track down the 'death lady' and ask for a new prediction. But, can fate be fought?

There's a large cast of characters in this story, from all walks of life. From a newlywed couple to a tired, overworked father and a young flight attendant, the narrative switches between them at a swift pace. But despite the breadth and ambition of this novel, I never found the characters difficult to keep track of. Whilst I preferred some to others, they all felt engaging and authentic.

Meanwhile, the 'death lady' has her own first person narrative weaved through the story. The seemingly harmless elderly woman has an incredible story to tell, and she's perhaps the most compelling character out of the entire cast. It'll keep you hooked, questioning whether she's a clever con-artist or a misunderstood victim of circumstance and, as she unravels her complex life story for the reader, I was rooting for her along with the rest of the bold, eccentric cast. A thought-provoking book full of drama and intrigue - highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

This has taken me such a long time to read - unfortunately the story, whilst and intriguing concept, just didn't grab me. I think this was largely down to the formatting of the arc which didn't separate the chapters properly so you didn't know which character you were reading about as the paragraphs just suddenly jumped from one to the next.

Not my favourite by this author - may try again with the paperback release.

Was this review helpful?

Such a fabulous read! Very intriguing. A lady on a plane starts telling everyone when they will die! Read it to find out more!

Was this review helpful?

An interesting premise whereby a lady on a flight starts to predict fellow passengers deaths and cause of death. So what happens once the flight lands and everyone gets on with their lives. Many of those who received predictions are concerned about their futures (which is reasonable). I really enjoyed how the story unfolded.

Was this review helpful?

What an opening for a novel and what a premise. The book starts at an airport with the passengers and crew boarding a flight. The flight appears unremarkable, the cast appear unremarkable - until one particular passenger makes her way down the plane and seems to predict every passenger’s age of death and cause of death.

What follows is the aftermath of this incident and the effects it has on the passengers, the crew and their lives. We also learn about the events which lead up to ‘The Death Lady’, as she is referred to, making her startling predictions.

This book has one of the best opening chapters I’ve read; it was engaging and I was invested from the start. I had to know ‘why’ I had to know ‘what next’. I had the same questions as the passengers on the plane, who is this woman? Is she psychic? Should I believe her?

The book digs deep and poses complex questions. Would you want to know when your life will end? Would you believe someone if they told you? Is our future pre-determined or do we have the power to change it?

I was fascinated by how the different passengers reacted to their experience and how a seemingly frightening episode could ultimately have positive outcomes on some of their lives and trigger the start of new relationships. I felt for all the characters and was moved by their individual stories.

With such a dramatic opening I was unsure how it could reach a satisfactory ending and I had a fear that I was going to left heartbroken and without answers. However Liane Moriarty steers it just right; there is sadness but also reflection and hope and I felt content with the ending.

I really enjoyed this one, it’s such a thought provoking read and it would make a fantastic book club pick. I can imagine reading groups discussing this for hours.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting concept and I enjoyed getting to know the different characters. There was a lot of switching between stories however and sometimes struggled to keep up!

Was this review helpful?

This was a highly entertaining and thought-provoking read, featuring a unique and captivating storyline.

Consider this hypothetical scenario: you are informed of the precise date and cause of your demise. Would you choose to alter your life's trajectory or dismiss it as the mere musings of a charlatan?

An ordinary flight from Hobart to Sydney becomes a catalyst for profound change in the lives of all its passengers. The catalyst for this transformation is not the 92-minute delay, but rather the unassuming woman occupying seat 4D. Initially overlooked and disregarded, she astounds everyone by rising and making a series of seemingly absurd predictions. Who is this enigmatic individual known as "the Death Lady," and what compels her to feel a connection with the passengers on this flight?

We are introduced to a diverse ensemble of characters, each profoundly impacted by their encounter with "the Death Lady." The ramifications of her predictions extend not only to their own lives but also to those of their loved ones.

In addition, we follow the life journey of Cherry Lockwood, from her childhood to the present day.

There were so many characters in the book that I had a hard time keeping track of them at first, but I ended up getting really invested in all of their lives!

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House UK, Michael Joseph for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion

Was this review helpful?

Loved the idea of this book with the woman on the plane predicting how and when all the other passengers would die! It was an engrossing read seeing how the predictions affected the lives of the passengers and it got really exciting when they started dying!
Loved how the tension built, Initially I found the ending a little disappointing, BUT I’ve been thinking about it more now and am feeling fine about the ending now and feeling it’s more a message about living each day to the fullest!

Was this review helpful?

This is such a good book! The characters, even though there are a few of them, are easy to keep track of and I was invested in them right from the start. I really enjoyed finding out all about Cherry, I thought she was brilliant. Death happens to us all, and if we are lucky, we don’t spend much time thinking about our own. The book follows the lives of a few of the passengers who on one fateful flight find out their cause of death and what age they will be. It’s not all doom and gloom, it’s about living your best life. Definitely recommend this book. Thank you #netgalley

Was this review helpful?