Member Reviews

Read if you love:
- Enemies to lovers
- Brother's best friend
- Forced proximity

I really enjoyed this story; it grabbed my attention from the start and was a quick read. The side characters were well fleshed out, making me excited about the possibilities of their love stories in future books. However, I do wish the main characters had shown more growth throughout the book. Nina felt pretty immature at times, and I would have liked to see a stronger resolution to Tristan’s struggles with his relationship with his parents. The story leaned a bit too much on insta-love for my liking; more romantic moments between the two of them would have helped flesh out their relationship. That said, I loved how much we got to see of their lives after they got together. I hope the author writes stories about Hunter and Rowena in the future—I’d love to read them.

Thank you to NetGalley and Bollywood Books for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Looking for a holiday movie mixed with a romcom? Enter "This is Not a Holiday Romance"! Tristan and Dylan have been best friends since they were young, but Dylan's little sister, Nina, has hated Tristan for years. After being mean to her growing up, Nina has never forgiven Tristan for some of the things he has said to her and how he has treated her. Now, it's Christmastime, and Dylan just happens to invite Tristan over for their family Christmas vacation. What could go wrong...or right?

This was such a cute story. I really liked Tristan and Nina's banter, and I'm a sucker for the enemies-to-lovers trope. I will say Nina calling Tristan the "Prince of Darkness" for the first half of the book seemed a little childish, but maybe that was the intent. This was a bit of a closed door romance, but still very sweet. Thank you so much to the publisher and Netgalley for the advanced copy!

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick, fun and entertainment read! Was it a little cringy? Yes. Was it still entertaining? Also yes. I feel like a good Christmas romcom somewhat has to be cringy. So this was perfect for the occasion. The writing was easy to read and i enjoyed having the story from two pov's. I might have been a little annoyed with the fmc Nina especially in the beginning just because she was acting quite bratty and very immature. But i guess that was the point haha. I guess her way of reacting in certain situations kinda annoyed me a little. I also felt like we mostly got to explore the characters physical attraction rather than their genuine connection and it was mostly a insta-love story. Which is okay, i just would have liked to get more of their relationship on a deeper level.

I mostly feel like this was a book that focused on physical attraction and insta-love rather than building genuine connections and relationships. But like i said it was a fun holiday romcom! Perfect as a Christmas holiday read!

Was this review helpful?

I liked this novel. It made me laugh and it made me cry. Nina and Tristen were so much fun together. I loved their pranks. Their chemistry was great. I liked the characters and enjoyed the storyline. Overall a good read.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading this cute holiday romance.
The story is full of engaging, steamy moments.
Main characters, Nina and Tristan, have such great chemistry going on. Though each one will emphatically deny this!
The hilarious pranks
The witty banter
The steamy meet-ups
Oh,did I mention the chemistry between them?????
Obsoletely perfect enemies-to-lovers and brothers best friend holiday read.
Thank you NetGalley, Boldwood Books and the author for the opportunity to read this book for my honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A very cute holiday romance read. I love how hilarious Camilla's books are and this is no different. Highly recommend if you want a fun romcom read!

Thank you so much to NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Camilla Isley for the ARC of this wonderful book!

Was this review helpful?

I don’t usually like the brother’s best friend trope but throw in a festive forced proximity and enemies to lovers and I really liked it. It was fun with some hilarious pranks and banter and I liked both main characters. Nice festive romance.

Was this review helpful?

Usually I am a HUGE fan of Camilla Isley and that hasn't really changed, I just didn't love this book as much as I have her others.

Firstly, I loved the prank wars between Nina and Tristan. They were childish in the best way. However, one thing I really didn't enjoy as Tristan using Nina's looks to poke fun at her. There is a rule that I always tell my kids - if it isn't something that someone can change in 5 minutes, don't mention it. Meaning, if you think someone's ears are too big, they can't change the size of their ears in the next 5 minutes, so it doesn't need to be said. If someone has food in their teeth, they can absolutely fix that in the next 5 minutes, so go ahead and let them know. OK, so Tristan as a teenager was a bit of a dick and didn't realise the impact his comments about Nina looking like a gremlin with big ears would have. But the woman refused to wear her hair up around him for YEARS afterwards. And it was all like "Oh, I meant the cute one, lol sorry". I feel like this did not get enough page time, that Tristan made Nina feel unattractive for a looooong time.

I also didn't love the whole protective big brother shtick from Dylan. I get that it's part and parcel of the whole brother's best friend trope but it always annoys me that the brother is always immediately offended at the friend betraying him and never thinks about how his sister feels. Ever. It is ALWAYS like this with this trope.

Saying that, I am looking forward to the other books in the series, I'm assuming we will get a roommate trope for Dylan and Hunter and a marriage of convenience for Rowena.

I will say that the characters had good chemistry and the banter between them was incredible but this book had a few too many niggles to be one of my favourite Camilla Isley novels.

Tropes:
- Stuck together at Christmas
- Christmastime
- Brother's best friend
- Enemies to lovers

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a free copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.

This was another enjoyable romance by the author. The about turn to love was a little quick, but didn’t stop me enjoying the enemies to lovers trope.

Was this review helpful?

This took me back to Wattpad days—enemies to lovers, brother's best friend, the broody MC, the quirky relatable FC, the witty banter, the easygoing chemistry, the hilarious pranks, the third act breakup to make up the best ending! I'm definitely going to binge Camila's backlist now!!

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this but I just didn’t. It’s an enemies to lovers trope that develops from 0 to 60 in the course of several days. The author makes it seem as if there is long harbored love from Nina to Tristan and I feel like there was one sentence about her wanting to fit in with he and her brother when they were young and then hatred from her thereafter and a clueless guy who thought they were joking the whole time. Then she finds out he was joking and poof, they are in each other’s beds. Just would’ve liked more development of past relationship history between Tristan and Nina.

This ARC was provided in exchange for an honest review by Boldwood Books. Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank NetGalley, Camilla Isley and Boldwood Books for an ARC copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

3⭐- a cute romcom that has a enemies to lovers trope. Nina and Tristan aren't fond of each other. When Nina's brother's best friend Tristan, spends the holidays at Nina's family's - they start pranking each other.

Overall a fun read if you're looking for a cutesy holiday romcom, the characters are a little childish for my taste, but still likeable.

Was this review helpful?

“But we don’t leave,” she says firmly, still caressing my cheek. “When you love someone, you don’t leave.” Nina and Tristan's love story goes from enemies to lovers keeping their secret from her family and his best friend, Nina's older brother. They are meant to be together but can the secret destroy their new flame or will they fight for their love? Great

Was this review helpful?

This Is Not a Holiday Romance by Camilla Isley kicks off with Nina Thompson's one Christmas wish: to steer clear of her brother’s irritatingly attractive best friend, Tristan. Their relationship has always been a battlefield of escalating pranks and simmering tension, with each determined to outdo the other. But when Tristan unexpectedly crashes her family’s holiday celebrations, Nina’s plans for a peaceful Christmas are thrown out the window, leading to a snowed-in showdown that’s anything but festive.

While the premise promises the fun and excitement of a holiday romance with a twist, the execution left me wanting more. The chemistry between the characters felt a bit forced, and their banter, while sometimes charming, often lacked the depth needed to make their connection feel real and lasting.

Isley’s writing is easy to get through, and the book certainly has its moments of humor and heart. However, the plot is fairly predictable, and the story doesn’t break any new ground in the romance genre. The characters, though likeable enough, felt somewhat flat, and their development over the course of the novel was minimal, leaving the resolution feeling a bit underwhelming.

For readers looking for a simple, escapist read that doesn’t demand much emotional investment, This Is Not a Holiday Romance might hit the spot. But if you’re hoping for a romance with more substance and spark, this one might not leave a lasting impression.

Was this review helpful?

It’s never too early to dive into a book set during the Christmas season—especially when it features beloved tropes like “brother’s best friend” and “enemies-to-lovers.” When it comes to Camilla Isley’s novels, the experience is always rewarding.

In “This Is Not a Holiday Romance,” we meet Nina Thompson and Tristan Montgomery, who have spent years playing pranks on each other due to a misunderstanding that left Nina feeling insecure about her body. Tristan, as her brother’s best friend, never had the chance to explain his side of the story. With a troubled family background, he often found himself spending the holidays with the Thompsons.

Could this holiday season, spent with someone Nina considers her worst enemy, become a time of forgiveness and love for her and Tristan? You'll have to read "This Is Not a Holiday Romance" to find out!

I thoroughly enjoyed Nina and Tristan’s story. Camilla Isley has a knack for crafting books that are just the right length—long enough to become fully immersed in the narrative without feeling bogged down by page count. The playful pranks, clever banter, and undeniable chemistry between Nina and Tristan were perfectly executed, making me root for them to resolve their differences.

Initially, I found Nina to be somewhat immature for her age. She had no filter when it came to Tristan, often losing her composure whenever he was nearby. However, by the end of the story, I appreciated the growth in her character as she chose to rise above the past and forgive Tristan.

Tristan, on the other hand, evoked a sense of sympathy due to his dysfunctional family. Despite his difficult upbringing, he managed to grow into a kind and decent person, which made his character all the more endearing.

My only critique is that the pacing felt a bit rushed, especially toward the resolution. I would have liked to see Tristan given more time to express his feelings and fully convey his remorse to Nina.

I sincerely hope this is the first book in a series, as I am eager to learn more about characters like Dylan, Hunter, Rowena, and the mysterious man she married. Their stories hold great potential and would make for fantastic books. Camilla, I hope they are already in the works!

Lastly, I would like to extend my thanks to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Camilla Isley for providing early access to "This Is Not a Holiday Romance" in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This delightful story had all the right tropes for me, enemies-to-lovers and brother’s-best-friend rom-com. The perfect read to cozy up with during the festive season.

Camilla Isley never lets me down when it comes to her romcoms. I just eat them up every single time.

Nina Thompson has only one wish for Christmas: to avoid Tristan, her brother’s annoyingly attractive best friend, who has been the bane of her existence since they were teenagers.

Their relationship is one long-running prank war, and neither has ever waved the white flag. But when Tristan unexpectedly crashes her family’s Christmas, Nina’s hopes for a peaceful holiday disappear faster than mistletoe at a singles’ party.

Determined to end their rivalry once and for all, Nina braces herself for the ultimate showdown. However, the universe—or perhaps the ghost of Christmas present—has other plans. A blizzard leaves them snowed in together, and suddenly, avoiding Tristan becomes impossible. As the holiday festivities force them closer, Nina and Tristan discover that their heated exchanges have been hiding a different kind of spark all along.
Trapped in a snow globe of holiday magic, their banter takes a turn for the steamy. But they’re both adamant: this is just a holiday fling, destined to melt away with the snow.

There’s no way this could be anything more… or could it? Nina and Tristan’s journey from sworn enemies to something more had me laughing, swooning, and cheering them on from the very first page. Absolutely loved this.

This Is Not a Holiday Romance is a fun, light-hearted read with all the ingredients of a perfect Christmas rom-com: witty banter, sizzling chemistry, and a snowed-in setting that amplifies the romance.

If you’re in the mood for a festive story that combines humour, romance, and holiday spirit, this book is definitely for you! Add this to your tbr for those christmassy reads.


Thank you to the publisher Boldwood Books, The author Camilla Isley and Netgalley for a copy of this e-arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

"Gremlin"

- Brother's Best Friend
- Dual's P.O.V
- Enemies to Lovers
- Forced Proximity
- Festive Romance
- Felt Insta- Lovey- didn't feel right on Tristian's side
- Low level spice
- Pranks and Banter

Tristian is best friends with Nina's brother for years. They have never seen eye to eye. Constantly bickering or trying to get one over each other by pranking each other. Nina was hoping to have a quiet Christmas with just her family. That is until Dylan brings Tristian along. Will Nina and Tristian for once get along or will it be too much for this festive season.

I have read many Camilla Isley books. They are such easy reads and I flew through the book. 'This is Not a Holiday Romance' is perfect for a holiday read. But this one was a little bit hit and miss for me this time. It won't stop me from reading more of her books in the future. Just wasn't a favourite.

I found the connection between Nina and Tristian felt more of a physical/ sexual attraction rather than an actual connection between the two when they two people just click together. For me it was more on Tristian's when he saw Nina naked. He suddenly had feelings for her and not through the fact that you are friends with her brother and you would have surely noticed her or developed something a lot sooner. It was too insta-lovey one from couldn't get along to suddenly saying I love you within a couple of days didn't sit right.

I found Nina's character to be a lot younger than her character's age. She was very immature. It wasn't even the pranks/ jokes who doesn't like a laugh and a joke. It was how she reacted within certain situations. For example, with her mum over breaking a vase.


Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a copy of the book for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Camilla Isley books never miss for me! I was so excited to read This is not a holiday romance despite it being late August. It was a super easy feel good Christmas holiday read which I would recommend to anyone, I inhaled this book within 2 days as it’s on the shorter side my only wish is that it could have been a bit longer!

Was this review helpful?

This was a great chic flic book.
I loved the relationships between Nina and her friends, strong female relationships in a book are my favourite. I loved Nina and Dylan’s parents relationships with their adult children and each other, that felt really real. This was the perfect book to snuggle up under the duvet and would be great to read under the lights of the Christmas tree too. Perfect book. Thank you NetGalley for the arc in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A classic enemies-to-lovers romance novel set against the backdrop of a snowy Christmas holiday. The story follows Nina Thompson and her brother's best friend, Tristan, as they navigate their long-standing rivalry and unexpected attraction.

The novel cleverly employs popular tropes in the romance genre, including enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity, and holiday romance. The author sets up an engaging premise with Nina and Tristan's history of pranks and mutual animosity, creating a foundation for witty banter and entertaining conflicts.

The plot takes an interesting turn when Tristan unexpectedly joins Nina's family Christmas, leading to them being snowed in together. This setup provides ample opportunity for character development and the exploration of their changing relationship dynamics.

The transition from rivalry to romance seems well-paced, with the characters' heated exchanges gradually revealing underlying attraction. The author appears to balance humor and romantic tension effectively, likely creating an engaging read for fans of the genre.

The book's holiday setting adds a cozy, festive atmosphere that complements the romantic storyline. The "snow globe of holiday romance" imagery suggests a whimsical, almost magical quality to their developing relationship.

The characters' initial reluctance to see their fling as anything more than temporary adds a layer of conflict that likely drives the latter part of the narrative, keeping readers invested in the outcome.

Overall, this novel seems to offer a fun, light-hearted romantic read perfect for the holiday season. It likely appeals to readers who enjoy playful rivalries, sizzling chemistry, and the magic of Christmas romance.

Was this review helpful?