Member Reviews

DNF - This book just didn't work for me, it was different than what I was hoping for, in all manner of the word.

Was this review helpful?

'Stories are all we become in the end.'

After the genteel ‘The Thing About Alice’, Swanepoel’s follow-up is like a bolt of lightning to the senses. I really enjoyed it; though I must say I read it at a gallop to see what happens next in the tumultuous and self-destructive relationship between Leon and David.

Though a slim novel, there is a lot packed in. I am sure I missed numerous allusions on the first read; this is one of those books where you need to implicitly trust the author on the journey he is taking you on, and just go with the narrative flow.

So, we have intersecting timelines, places, characters, poems, journal and novel-within-a-novel extracts, and an unreliable narrator (not a very nice guy, but fascinating nonetheless). I really felt sorry for David; the ending is heartrending.

All the elements blend seamlessly into a really thrilling read that wrongfooted me on several occasions, as it took some rather unexpected turns. Or authorial sleights of hand, I suppose is the correct term.

I didn’t realise David was so young when he and Leon meet on the beach for the first time. We get no indication of Leon’s age, but he is considerably older. That reminded me of how Christopher Isherwood (48) and Don Bachardy (18) met for the first time in 1953, on Valentine’s Day, can you believe it.

The relationship lasted until Isherwood’s death in 1986 (I remember reading that Bachardy, an artist, painted portraits of Christopher in his final days, including one after he had passed). Leon also has artistic tendencies, and Swanepoel designed his book cover himself. Life and art, truth and memory, fiction and wish fulfilment all intertwine in a dark ouroboros.

Isherwood is indeed mentioned, and David’s recipe for a successful relationship has ‘A Single Man’ inevitability to it: “I believe in finding someone you can stand to be around for long periods of time.”

Was this review helpful?

this was a very solid novel, if a bit too intense for my own liking (that’s on me, though). the writing is very solid and the character work is very well handled, although i wish it had not felt as over-the-top at times.

Was this review helpful?

The Book of David tells the story of Leon and David, told primarily through Leon's reflections of events the pair experienced, though, at times there are glimpses of David's perspective from old diary entries. The writing flips back and forth from present to past without a lot of indication of where you currently are. This was somewhat confusing at times but I think it accurately reflected the overarching themes of the relationship between Leon and David - chaotic, confusing, in search of something that might not be accurate.

David is a messy character that reflects a messy human being. Someone with complexities and a desire to figure it all out while also trying to live authentically. Readers get to experience Leon's judgements and interpretations, as well as his regrets, as he recounts the story of their relationship. "All we look for is our own reflection in someone else's eyes" is a quote from the novel that sums up David - looking to learn about himself through Leon.

Overall this was a great read and left me thinking, along with Leon, about how things could have been different had different decisions been made in certain moments. He gains some perspective through David's journal entries, though I wish these could have been flushed out a bit more to show the readers more of David's perspective. We are shown sneak peaks of his internal processes and I think the book could have been more engaging had we been shown a bit more.

Was this review helpful?

A gut-punch record of what remains when an imperfect relationship between two men comes to an abrupt and tragic end. A tender exploration of longing, memory, and regret, and ultimately of love at its messiest

Was this review helpful?

Heartwrenching meditation on grief with timelines jumping back and forth. I found myself grieving past relationships while reading this, and feeling so connected to the desperation the narrator feels towards David

Was this review helpful?

The entire vibe of this book felt so fitting. It was fleeting, it was chaotic, it was intense. 

I did feel like the jumping around in the timeline got me so confused. I loved, and hated, the characters. I'm annoyed by not finding out any "truth", but so is life. 

Overall, I'd recommend this book! It's very short but it's written really well and the characters are so well written too. 

Thank you to NetGalley for an e-ARC of this book!

Was this review helpful?

The writing in this novel was beautiful. The book really captures feelings of a relationship ending and what that means for those left in the aftermath of it and the turmoils that come with relationship. It was a short book but very impactful with the time it has with the reader.

Was this review helpful?

This is a book about co-dependency. About how relationships are not always healthy, but how they can be life-changing, full of passion, and how they can change in an instant. The characters are complex, and the more you read it the more you feel like you get to know them.

Structurally, I understand its intent, to mimic the repetitive nature of memory, of remembering, but sometimes it just doesn’t work.

As for the titular character, David is brash and mouthy, full of opinions and entirely unrelenting. As a reader it’s easy not to like him simply due to the fact that he is so childish and immature, but this is what inevitably makes him charming. His charisma is a spark that draws Leon to him, and it’s what I also think endears readers to him, as well. David is unafraid to love loudly, to kiss with erotic abandon in front of a homophobe, to care for a stranger who hurt themself on the street, to rescue a dog from a run-down jalopy. Much like Leon, we as readers learn to love David for these “little things” he does. These things might seem insignificant at first but I would argue they become the main reasons why we as readers begin to see David as more than just a hanger-on, a freeloader, but instead as a lovable person who, of course, has flaws.

I wish there was a little more substance to this story, rather than so much focus on a particular style, which included jumping back and forth in time and even some journal entries.

It could have been longer, to flesh out the plot and characters more, but I understand the choice: it reflects the length of time Leon had with David.

The writing itself was quite gorgeous in spots, and it was easy to find myself gliding through it.

Emotionally I could have been more connected. It felt all too brief. I’m glad I read it, though.

This one was good.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

When I read the description for this book, alarm bells went off in my head warning me that this would break my heart. And it did, In the most beautiful way. The prose in the book is so poetic and captivating.

Was this review helpful?

I requested and received an eARC of The Book of David by Jean-Luke Swanepoel via NetGalley. Leon Jonker first meets David Hale on a San Francisco beach. David is naked, confident, and younger than Leon. The two share a conversation and don’t meet again for six months. Once they reenter each other’s orbit they find themselves in a relationship that ends when David dies. Leon returns to his home country, South Africa, and attempts to write his way out of his grief and to make sense of the life they shared. The narrative darts between the past and the present, the story of their relationship preserved in Leon’s words and, occasionally, David’s.

Sexy and tense. Gut-wrenching and lovely and slightly infuriating. I’m somewhat at a loss trying to describe this work. The dialogue in this book is fantastic. Swanepoel’s crafts lines that at times cut like a dagger, showing us the cracks and gray areas in David and Leon’s relationship, but he is equally skilled at enticing the reader with moments of flirtation or endearment. When I wasn’t enthralled by the dialogue, I was enthralled by what wasn’t being said. The author is very clever with his prose and his use of repetition, demonstrating on the page both the infallibility of memory and the way we construct the stories of our lives and versions of people as we perceive them.

The Book of David contains many terrific references, and is a real testimony to gay relationships, art and literature. The novel is short but impactful, many scenes have lodged themselves in my mind. The work is character driven and in it Swanepoel manages to create a portrait of a relationship that is both captivating and uncomfortable. Leon is such an interesting narrator with a very distinct voice. He isn't terribly likeable and there are moments where he seems to lack some self-awareness which to me only enhanced what the author achieves in this story (a very frank dissection of relationships — sort of like Anatomy of a Fall but without the potential mariticide and subsequent legal proceedings.) Grief, resentment, and desire abound in this book and I found that I couldn’t tear myself away from the page. Swanepoel’s writing really excited me and the dynamic between Leon and David felt very real. There were moments where I didn’t know if I wanted to laugh or cry or curse at one of the characters. I was very impressed by this novel and I look forward to seeing how other readers respond to it.

Was this review helpful?

The book, however much I wanted it to, did not meet my expectations. The promise of a tragic love and what happens after a tragedy sounded perfect: I really do enjoy such stories. However, The book of David felt rather...dull.

I could not find the love between Leon and David. It seemed to me that David - after meeting Leon for the second time - simply decided he was done sleeping around and (for whatever reasons) decided to be with Leon. The sexual attraction I saw, there was plenty, but deeper feelings? No.

The story itself was rather interesting, though, I did feel like the ending was vague. I expected the tragic end of love to come up much earlier in the book, so we could see what comes after and was rather disappointed that it only happened very near the end.

I had some trouble adjusting to the constant time-skips in the text. One chapter it's present, another it's a memory, third an antry from David's journal. Also, there was a lot of repetition that seemed unnecessary.

One thing that I really enjoyed was the writing. It was emotional, deep and beautiful. Reminded me of Ocean Vuong a bit.

Was this review helpful?

The Book of David by Jean-Luke Swanepoel is a raw, poignant exploration of a tumultuous relationship. Through Leon Jonker's reflections and David Hale’s journals, Swanepoel captures the complexities of love, loss, and memory with a powerful emotional depth. The narrative’s honesty and introspection make it an unforgettable read.

Was this review helpful?

"The Thing About David" by Jean-Luke Swanepoel beautifully captures the complexities of the relationship between South African author Leon Jonker and American David Hale. The novel features Leon reminiscing and navigating his memories alongside David's journals. It portrays the highs and lows of their relationship. If you enjoyed Isherwood's "A Single Man," you'll appreciate the depth of emotions and contemplation in this novel.

Thank you for sharing the ARC!

Was this review helpful?