Member Reviews

Wow, this was such an emotional and eye opening collection of poetry and the words and emotion will stay with for a long time. Although tragic, it was written beautifully and it made me feel so many emotions. I look forward to reading more by the author in the future.

Was this review helpful?

every waking moment i think of Gaza and the Palestinians displaced, fleeing death and holding onto life. thank you for publishing this book, and for giving me an e-arc.

Was this review helpful?

We are living in a time of widely broadcasted g*no*ides where I have to c*ns*r what I say in case the bots or algorithms decide this review is a problem.

Abu Toha however doesn’t hide a thing. This book is his heart and memories and existence laid open bare for the world to decide what they want to do about it.

Poems that made me go back to them again and again include:

Daughter - because it made my heart ache, the remembering through your loved ones’ eyes

What a G*z*n should do during an Is**eli air strike - because really this is what real life is about

Two watches - because your heart is always at home no matter what timezone you live in

What a G*z*n Mother Does During an I**aeli Night Air Strike - because there’s no one else like a mother

History Class - because we are living inside this history

To My Mother, Staying in an UNRWA School Shelter in the J*b*lia Camp - because I pray Allah reunites Abu Toha with his mother and his entire family Ya Rabb

After Allen Ginsberg - because this is a very sad tribute

Ramadan 2024 - because my heart hurts

Rescue Plane - because our wishes and prayers are simple and we will not give up our hope

Door on the Road - because this is the strange truth with the truest imagery reflecting the state of this world

Thank you to Mosab Abu Toha for sharing his words with the world. May Allah swt reward you in this world and the next ameen.

I received a copy of the ARC through Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

This collection is a must read in my opinion. At a time where we must pay vital attention to Palestinian voices, Forest of Noise is vivid and tender and intimate and brutal. The title poem late in caught my breath as did “After Allen Ginsberg”. Sometimes, I read collections out of order but I'm so glad I read this in the format and structure of the volume becase you are taken on a journey that makes the last few poems land in a new way.

Was this review helpful?

This book offers a brutally honest and deeply moving account of life in Gaza, chronicling the shattered lives, broken dreams, and overwhelming grief endured by the author’s family and the people of Gaza. With raw emotion, it captures the harsh realities of war and displacement, laying bare the immense loss and suffering that define everyday existence in this conflict-ridden region. Yet, amidst this heartbreaking narrative, the story shines with the resilient spirit of the Palestinian people, who, despite the relentless brutality, refuse to surrender their will to survive.

Was this review helpful?

Poetry is a vehicle for change and Mosab Abu Toha is a poet known for using his voice and words to enlighten, raise awareness and call for change. It was with heavy hearts that we awaited news of his safety after his kidnap last year. Forest of Noise now marks over a year since this event as well as a year of genocide.

While some poems reflect upon Toha's personal experience, the purpose of this collection is to write for the Gazan people. He could have easily have centred these poems on a narrative of kidnap but instead Forest of Noise ensures this collection is a universal call for a free Palestine.

The writing is raw and rightfully so - Toha's work is an example of how poetry is a tool for resistance and truth, particularly in the face of Western and Israeli propaganda. Forest of Noise is vital reading and we should be thankful that poets like Toha continue to raise their voices louder than oppression.

Was this review helpful?

I first read ‘Things You May Find Hidden in My Ear’ by Mosab Abu Toha towards the end of 2023, and it immediately became one of my favourite poetry collections ever. So, the moment I heard about the existence of ‘Forest of Noise’, I knew I had to prioritise it. Of course, it did not disappoint.

I find it nearly impossible to review poetry collections like this one because no words of mine can accurately capture how incredibly devastating, painful, and beautiful Mosab’s writing is.

I continue to believe that poetry is one of the most visceral and powerful ways to learn about and connect with experiences so vastly different from my own. The words that Mosab shares with us, both in this collection and in ‘Things You May Find Hidden in My Ear’, are incredibly raw, radical, and paradigm-shifting in nature.

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: I am eternally grateful to Palestinian poets and creatives all over the world who continue to share their pain and truth with us, even as the world continues to let them down!

If you’re looking for a place to start, or a place to continue your Palestinian reading and learning, look no further.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-arc. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for an e-ARC in exchange for my honest review.

It's been a while since I read something that profoundly moved me in this way. I'm not usually one for poetry, but something about Abu Toha's lyrical words had me glued to the pages. The poems range from heartbreaking to painfully hopeful, painting the stark reality of life in Gaza. This collection of poems is a must-read for anyone wanting to understand the realities of life under bombardment by a brutal occupying force. I was moved to tears many times while reading.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this collection in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

'Will my bones find yours after I die?'

First and foremost - the collection is beautiful. It's evocative, raw and striking. Every word and allusion is intentional - nothing is wasted. There was an allusion to warplanes as eagles in the first poem that took my breath away. So much can be inferred in that one sentence, and Mosab dilutes meaning into every. single. word.

It lays plain what many would hide away from: the atrocities the apartheid state of Israel continues to force on the people of Palestine.

It's a searing reminder of how the world has failed Palestine. Of how we need to keep witnessing, sharing, shouting about Palestine. We can't stop. Poetry is resistance, and Forest of Noise is resistant in a world that would smother Palestinian voices.

My favourite inclusions, to name a few, were: Sunrise in Palestine, My Dreams as a Child, We Are Looking for Palestine, and On Your Knees.

Mosab Abu Toha's poetry is a must-read. It gives intimate insight into life in modern-day (and even past) Palestine, and allows a deep connection with a people that have been left behind in the name of colonial expansion.

Say Palestine. Say Genocide. Witness them. 🇵🇸

Was this review helpful?

I first knew about the author from his work in the Light in Gaza anthology, which I read earlier this year and loved. When I saw that he has a new poetry book out this year, I didn't think twice before requesting.

It's obvious to me that Mosab is a brilliant author because his words here are so beautiful. I'm not a big reader of poetry so I don't know the exact way of rating a poetry collection but to me, being able to convey a message and meanings in such a concise way is such a talent, and this poetry book is proof of Mosab's ability. However, as we are now reaching a year of the genocide (saying a year is already incorrect, as it didn't start on October 7), this was truly hard to read. Grief and loss can be seen across most of Mosab's poems and it was heartbreaking to read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review! I have no words. This book was so heartbreaking and eye-opening about the struggles of the people in Palestine. I read this a little slower because I wanted to (needed to) take my time with it- to understand what the author was saying and to educate myself better. I'm grateful for this author and his work. Thank you, Mr. Mosab Abu Toha.

I highly recommend this book! and I'll be looking out for his other work.

Was this review helpful?

Mosab Abu Toha is a Palestinian poet from Gaza and this collection documents this past year of war & genocide in Gaza. But he also writes about the past 75 years of war on Palestine.

Abu Toha chronicles the bombing of his home where he lived with his wife & three young children. He was then detained and assaulted in an Israeli prison while trying to evacuate with his family. All of this makes for harrowing reading. There are sparks of beauty when the author speaks of the community he once had, the plots of land where people tended to vegetables and fruit trees, the library he shared with his neighbours. Then you are quickly reminded that none of this exists anymore.

A truly invaluable collection for a first-hand account of this ongoing atrocity.

Was this review helpful?

I'm not sure how my words can do this collection justice, but I will try. Forest of Noise is a deeply moving collection of poetry, whose words cover a truth that we all need to know and hear. Poignant and unforgettable - words that will stay with the reader for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

Forest of Noise is a powerful collection of poems. Every word is a blow to the gut. Every poem will leave you hollow. The situations are real; highlighting the horrific realities that not only the Palestinian people are currently facing, but have always faced since the 1948 Nakba.

Was this review helpful?

In one of Mosab Abu Toha's poems, "Sunrise in Palestine," clouds of smoke of bombs have covered Gaza's sky to such an extent that the sunlight is "smuggled [by fighters] through tunnels beneath [their] houses." This image is one of the most powerful metaphors of this collection because it conveys its central theme; resistance through suffering, where resistance is not just an act of survival, but a praxis of unsettling the colonial and necropolitical undertones of oppression, dehumanization, and erasure by narrating beauty, by "smuggling the sunlight."

Was this review helpful?

Forest of Noise is a collection by Palestinian poet Mosab Abu Toha, exploring life in Gaza before and after October 7th 2023. There are poems addressed to family members, poems about tiny moments, and poems twisting poetic styles and ideas into new forms that can express the daily horrors of life in Gaza. Some standout poems for me were 'Younger than War', 'What a Gazan Should Do During an Israeli Air Strike' and 'After Allen Ginsberg'. It seems obvious to call the collection 'powerful', but it is hard not to, with the poems documenting suffering but also humanity in ways that most readers will not be able to imagine. Forest of Noise confronts us with what it means to document genocide using poetry, with whimsy and beauty alongside atrocity.

Was this review helpful?