3.5 of 5 stars rounded to 4
https://lynns-books.com/2024/10/18/review-the-wilding-by-ian-mcdonald/
My Five Word TL:DR Review: A Little Slow to Start

I enjoyed The Wilding. The writing is really good, very evocative and the author sets the scene very well. Yes, it was a little slow to start as we get to know the characters. To be honest, on the one hand, I’m not totally sure that all the character building was totally necessary as some of these characters are about to meet a grisly end, but, on the other hand, if the author just skimmed over these characters and gave them no depth it would be immediately obvious that their roles were going to be short lived, so, for me, it’s worth taking the time to get to know these people as it definitely makes their sudden demise much more shocking.

The premise of the story is a group of rangers and young adults, going into the wild to spend a night, at one with nature. It’s an unlikely group of characters in some respects. Lisa, the MC, is longing for a new start in life at University and in fact this little wilderness trek is probably going to be her last mission. The other young adults don’t particularly come across as enthusiastic (at least not all of them) about this little jaunt into the wild and have an almost bored, are we really doing this, attitude, but they’re going to get a sudden jolt of nasty reality in fairly short order.

The author sets the scene early. There have been unexplained attacks on farm animals and other unexplained incidences. The setting feeds into the atmosphere perfectly. This is a rewilding project based deep in rural island where the locals, the project itself and nature are struggling to come to a balance and, well, ultimately failing it would seem. There’s a lovely build up of tension, I would say that at one point I was on the brink of wondering when the action would kick in but then suddenly I was in the middle of chaos. When the proverbial hits the fan things go batpoop crazy. The wilderness seems to take on a mind of its own causing confusion and driving the party deeper into the bog. There’s bad weather, marshy boglands, bugs and that awful feeling of being watched coupled with the hysteria and panic created when people are desperately trying to survive. And there are some really unusual settings where our little group find shelter.

I don’t really want to say too much more for fear of spoiling the read for others. I enjoyed this, it had a slightly slow start but I think that initial build up makes the story more dramatic. There is definite horror and blood and guts. I don’t know whether I’d call this a folk story. It’s more like nature as a whole – showing us it’s power coupled with the journey of one character in particular – Lisa – who starts the story longing to move on before going on something of a self discovery jaunt herself, becoming very protective of the young people in her charge and throwing caution to the wind as she tries to keep them alive.

I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.

My rating 3.5 of 5 stars rounded to 4 for the strange and dark appeal

The Wilding is a horror novel written by Ian McDonald, and published by Gollancz. A slow burn story that blends together elements from folk horror with a more modern terror, including a group of well-fleshed characters that are put in an extreme situation, becoming the prey of an ancient force.

Lough Carrow is a rewilding project in the depths of rural Ireland; Lisa, a Ranger that is longing to abandon this place, is taking a group of five kids and their three teachers for a sleepover night. However, after they are attacked by an unknown creature, they are forced to run deeper into the bog; progressively running into stranger manifestations, realising that the project has brought back something really ancient that is now hunting them.

In a first third of the novel, McDonald does an excellent job building the characters and preparing the atmosphere for the chaos that will be unleashed after; as a consequence, the initial part can be a bit rough in terms of pacing, but the payoff makes it worth-it. Lisa is a broken character after a traumatic event, that is alone in the world, and that however, will have to take the responsibility on this situation; a weight over her shoulders that, at many points, will logically take her to the border of collapse (I saw this novel comped with Midsommar, and I could see a bit of Danny in the character of Lisa). While the group that accompanies her is a bit secondary, I still enjoyed that, especially in the case of the children, they are fully developed, they are not just caricatures put there to die.

The atmosphere is excellently built, creating that oppressive and wild nature sensation that, when you are not in control, instils that fear of the unknown; McDonald weaves it together with folk elements to create an insuperable combination. As previously said, the pace is a bit of slow burn at the start, but once we overcome the first third, the story flows.

The Wilding is a great novel, especially if you want a modern take over folk horror; an excellent atmospherical proposal which I absolutely loved. I'm curious to see what brings McDonald in next novels!

Ian McDonald has been busy quietly becoming one of our best writers over the past couple of decades, and while a departure into horror isn’t likely to suddenly win him fawning accolades from the broadsheets, I’m happy to report that his prose is as good as ever here. There’s a little aside early on to tell you that isn’t folk horror - but it’s not exactly not folk horror either, with its parade of ancient forces rising out of the landscape (and what a landscape - the descriptions of the bog and the surrounding terrain are transportingly vivid). It doesn’t have the stately pace and low key weirdness of a lot of popular recent FH though - once everything kicks in here it goes like a train all the way to a climatic battle that is begging to be filmed. A lot of fun. Also worth noting that this is the second novel with a gerund for a title that I’ve read in the last few months. Horror’s back, baby!

Haunting and ethereal, this is a a fanastic spooky read. Ian McDonald has created a brilliant addition to the genre.

DNF. I really loved the premise of this one but unfortunately there was just something about the writing style that I wasn't personally gelling with

Lough Carrow is a rewilding project on the site of a peat bog in the depths of rural Ireland. Lisa, a ranger, is taking a group of school kids for an overnight stay in the wild, but after a sudden attack, they are forced off course, driven deeper into the bog. There, they see increasingly strange and threatening manifestations, and realise that something very ancient is on their tail. I loved Ian McDonald's The Wilding's mix of Irish folk horror plus the more modern terror of the search and rescue officer's stories from the US Forest Service, as told on r/nosleep. I hope that other readers stay with this book, because its one issue is that the first third or so is very slow; some of this is necessary to carefully build the menace and establish the atmosphere of the bog, but I do think McDonald takes too long over introducing a raft of minor characters, almost none of whom end up being especially significant. His prose is beautiful but gets in the way a little in the opening chapters. Having said that, once The Wilding does get going, it does NOT let up, and it's seriously scary. It took me right back to the utter terror of reading Roald Dahl's The Minpins as a child and imagining being in the forest hearing the sounds of the Spittler approaching. I was interested to see that McDonald, a writer I haven't read before, has written mostly science fiction in the past, and I liked how he brought that sensibility to this grounded horror novel, giving us just enough information to make the threat feel specific - the taxonomy of types of sighting! - without tying himself into complicated explanations. Perfect Halloween reading.