
Member Reviews

I do love a Christie Barlow book and this return to Puffin Island with appearances from some familiar characters from the first book did not disappoint. A historic lighthouse, a sweet romance, close friendships, a happy surprise, and secrets bubbling up from the past. What's not to love?

Set on Puffin Island this was a heartwarming and joyful read. The book has a lovely story line that is set within a community where everyone cares for each other. With lovable characters and written in a friendly style this book was a pleasure to read.

What a nice story! I didn’t realize it was part of a series, this book seems to stand alone. It’s an easy to read book that moves fairly quickly. It deals with some life issues and has a nice romance too. There were some surprises along the way too.

Two books in and I am well and truly addicted. There is just something so wholesome about tucking into a Christie Barlow novel, and in this second visit to Puffin Island, I found myself completely engaged by Dilly's story and so very happy to be back in this wonderfully supportive and positive community. That's not to say that the book isn't teaming with emotion too - it wouldn't be a Christie Barlow book without those moments that tug at the heartstrings after all. And this book is no exception, with a poignant and tragic moment occurring just moments into the story. But it is that early scene that sets us up for what is to come, and for establishing just why the Puffin Island lighthouse is so dear to Dilly's heart. I was completely and truly hooked, and just ate up what followed.
This is Delilah's, or rather Dilly's, story. The Island's resident artist, Dilly has very strong family ties to the lighthouse - her mother was born there. She has a desire to buy the landmark and create a studio space for artists, as well as making it her own home. But it's fair to say that the idea of owning the lighthouse is not the only thing setting Dilly's mind a whirl. A face from her past arrives on the island and is set to stir things up well and truly in Dilly's private life. Dilly is a wonderful person to spend time with, and a perfect centre for this book's story. She is open, engaging and the kind of character it is impossible not to like. And the chemistry between her and her former tutor, Max, is abundantly clear and just pulls you right into the story. It's not plain sailing, and some things from their past, Max's especially, serve to add that edge of conflict that you expect, if only to make it's resolution all the more satisfying.
And that is just what you'd expect from this series. An emotional journey, both romantically and nostalgically, teaming characters who hold a real appeal, and a community that the author manages to make readers feel a part of. There is something magical about the way in which Christie Barlow paints the island life, and in just a short time she has already established a cast of characters I feel completely at home with and invested in the lives of. From Dilly and Max, through to island stalwart, Betty, who has been quite central to all of the series stories so far, I am getting that really warm and welcoming vibe that made the author's Love Heart Lane series so totally addictive. And I love the setting. Based on a part of the country which holds a place in my heart, and lord knows I love a puffin, Christie Barlow has once again created a place where I just want to visit. Idyllic, tranquil and with a true community spirit, how could you not?
Pure heartwarming escapism. A story that is full of emotion, laughter, and brilliant characters. I can't wait to pay a return visit to Puffin Island to see what this wonderful bunch get up to next. Definitely recommended.

I received a free copy of, The Lighthouse Daughters of Puffin Island, by Christie Barlow, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Delilah Waters, does not need a man, right now her main focus is trying to buy, Puffin Island Lighthouse. This book has a lot going on in it, I really liked this book, Christie Barlow, is a really good author.

This novel is part of a new series by Christie Barlow, but it can easily be read and enjoyed as a standalone story. Set in a charming fictional village, the lighthouse plays a key role, adding to the book’s atmospheric appeal. The vivid descriptions of the coastal setting and the sea create an immersive reading experience that makes you wish you were there. With its heartwarming romance and engaging storytelling, this is a truly enjoyable read that I would highly recommend.

I read this in one sitting - and am already looking forward to the next instalment of this series. I can see myself sitting at the top of the lighthouse watching the flags from the other side, the writing is so good you can smell the sea air.

Oh Christie what another fabulous story! Wonderful characters so well written with their lives, together with the community of Puffin Island, flowing from the pages overflowing with love and friendship

I really wanted to like this one. I read the first book in the series, and enjoyed it, but this one...not so much.
I found the the main character confusing and frustrating, and she made choices I could not understand or support. The character would be going on about how she was definitely not going to do a thing, then within a page-she was doing the thing.
She was not particularly emotionally honest with herself or others. I really questioned some of her choices. I just could not relate to or like her. Yet-everybody surrounding her in the story was acting like she was the best (and most adorable) person on the Island.
The love interest was unconvincing, He engaged in borderline stalker behavior (instead of just calling/texting like a normal person who wants to get back in touch). After that he was a bit too good to be true, I felt that very little about the romance rang true.
The mystery at the heart of the story turned out to be a misdirection and exposed some really questionable behavior on the part of one of the other resident's of the Island. Seriously, starting to believe that Puffin Island is not a nice place at all.
Everything was neatly wrapped up in the end despite all the deceit, which also did not ring true for me.
Despite liking other work by this author, this entry is not one I can recommend.

This is the second instalment of the puffin island series. I strongly recommend you reading these books in order for the full experience.
From the first page this was an engaging read and with the way this author writes making the pages coming alive I felt like I had actually stepped inside the lighthouse and onto the beautifully described puffin island.
This instalment introduced us to the characters of Dilly and Max alongside those we had met in the previous instalment of this series like the lovely Betty.
This story takes you on an emotional yet heartwarming journey that interweaves lots of interconnecting stories and threads together to make this wonderful engaging read.
I am already looking forward to the next instalment of this series.

Thank you to Netgalley, publisher and the author for providing a free copy jn exchange for an honest review #thelighthousedaughtersofpuffinisland
Dilly Waters is the third generation to live on Puffin Island with her dad Ralph close by. She loves the scenery, the people and the freedom all of which often give her inspiration for her art! Then her old art teacher turns up on the island …. The one all the girls swooned over …. The one Dilly fancied! Will her heart remain whole and on the island ?
After reading book 2 in the series "Foxglove Farm." I have been following the author who has become one of my favourites. So far I have read all the books after and including book 2 in the love heart lane series and all in the puffin island series.
This is book 2 however you would not know this when reading it and this book makes a great stand alone. Something I think this author has got down to a fine art. Although I can guarantee you'll get so much out of the characters if you read it as a series.
This book is a great romance read. Although their are some emotional subjects included in this book such as death, romance scammers, miscarriage and feuds amongst other things. I do not feel this takes away from the romantic feel of the book but has you heart growing fonder of the struggles each character faces. This book really shows how inclusive 21st century living can be providing really subtle life lessons alongside the romance fiction and escapism this book provides..
This book also has twists and turns that really throw you off the scent. You have an idea on where this is going in your head a.
I Cannot wait to read the next book as always.

Thank you so much to netgalley and publishers for an advanced copy of this book for my review. Thank you Christie Barlow for another exceptional story that had me gripped from the start. Set on the wonderful sounding Puffin Island, this book follows the life of artist Dilly who has always had a fascination with the nearby lighthouse and her families connection to it. So when an opportunity to buy the lighthouse comes about, Dilly wonders if fate is on her side. There are a few twists, turns and surprises woven into the story, which will keep you turning the pages to find out more. Fabulous setting, lovely friendships, family and community feel with added romance and touch of mystery, all make this an absolute must read.

The Lighthouse Daughters of Puffin Island was a heartwarming feel-good story focussing on Dilly, her quest to purchase the lighthouse and her feelings for her old Art teacher, Max Harrington.
I particularly enjoyed the dynamics between the residents of Puffin Island. The story beautifully captures the strong sense of community, highlighted by Dilly's close relationships with her best friends, her father, and the ever-charming Betty.
Max was a standout character—kind, compassionate, and relatable. Both he and Dilly grapple with unresolved wounds from their pasts, but their journey of healing together is refreshingly free of unnecessary angst, adding depth to their romance.
This story offers a delightful mix of mystery, history, romance, and unexpected surprises.
Although it’s the second book in the series, it would work perfectly as a standalone (although the first book is worth reading so I sugget you do). Many thanks to NetGalley and One More Chapter for providing an advanced copy for review!

The Lighthouse Daughters of Puffin Island by Christie Barlow is one of those cozy, feel-good reads that makes you want to curl up with a cup of tea and a blanket. Set on this beautiful, windswept island, the story pulls you in with its mix of family drama, romance, and a touch of mystery.
The characters are what really drew me in. There’s something really relatable about them—especially the women trying to navigate their pasts and figure out where they belong. The lighthouse itself kind of becomes a character, too, guiding them (and us) through the ups and downs of life. I loved how the setting is so atmospheric, with the island feeling both charming and a little isolated, which fits the characters' journeys.
It’s definitely a romance, but it’s also about personal growth, healing, and figuring out your place in the world. That part felt really real, especially with how the characters face challenges and learn to open up to one another. If you’re into stories where characters find love and redemption (even if it’s a bit predictable at times), this one will hit the spot.
That said, it’s not exactly groundbreaking—some parts of the plot felt a little familiar, and if you’ve read other books like this, you’ll probably guess where things are headed. But honestly, that didn’t bother me too much. Sometimes, you just want that heartwarming story where everything falls into place.
If you're a fan of romantic, small-town (or small-island!) vibes with a dash of family drama and healing, this book is definitely worth picking up. It’s the kind of book you want to read when you need a little escape to a beautiful, peaceful place.

I just loved this book so much that once I started reading it, I just couldn’t put it down. I just loved Puffin Island and I wish it was real as the characters are just amazing people. It’s an amazing community that I would love to be part off, as they have each other’s back. The story was amazing too I just love Dilly and Max.
I would highly recommend reading this book and the first book in the series too as they are so heartwarming I just love them and I can’t wait until the next one in the series.
I would like to thank One More Chapter and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book early.

How cool would it be to own a lighthouse! Especially knowing your family history in it? That would be way cool!
I enjoyed it so much that I didn't want it to end! I loved making friends with these wonderful characters especially Dilly. I really enjoyed in getting to know her. She's delightful and gullible all at the same time.
Oh and impulsive too but that's what I liked about her.
Max I didn't like so much. I thought he was a little shady.
I finished this book in one evening. I didn't think I'd like it but I actually did.
Well written with rounded out characters what more could a girl want? I didn't want this to end.
5 stars for great entertainment and especially for the art classes. Dilly did a great job with that lol. She did make me grin on that one
I highly recommend this cute novel. I'll be buying it to add to my shelf
My thanks for a copy of this wonderful book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.

What a wonderful story with such a fantastic feel good factor. This was a book that I could not put down, well written, great characters and a beautiful setting. Thoroughly recommended.

A cosy read, written about the life of an artist living on the remote Puffin Island. Having been traumatised by being taken in by a romance scam, Dilly puts the experience behind her. Her resilience to forge ahead and aim for her dreams is compulsive reading. And then, enter the man she had been holding in her thoughts for many a year, her college art teacher - and no guessing the ending! The setting, individual characters and story line were well crafted, and the novel flows seamlessly to the conclusion. A relaxed style of romance, with a smattering of obstacles to hold the reader’s interest.
My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers HarperCollins One More Chapter for the opportunity to read and review this ARC

This was my first book in the series and I can’t wait to chomp my way through all of the rest. This was an excellent book that looked with tenderness at relationships both those that worked and those that didn’t as well as deep deep friendships. Relationship betrayal is covered in depth and well as is the difficulty of building a life after things go wrong. All of this is set against the beautiful backdrop of puffin Island and especially the gorgeousness of the lighthouse. The whole book is a romantic tale of relationships, families and an amazing backdrop on the island.

I never thought I would get over the loss of the Love Heart Lane series, but I am delighted the author has a great new series set in Puffin island.
Fear not people Christie has blown me away, great cast of characters and beautiful scenery.
This one features Dilly, who is desperate t9 own the lighthouse that has been in her family and where her mother was born.
This will be another smashing series and I already see book 3 is not far away.