Member Reviews

Simple, but cute. I feel like it could have leaned a bit more into the Queen Esther story. However, I loved the ending and I think this was a nice book for kids. The additional crown coloring page was lovely as well.

Was this review helpful?

This is such a cute and sweet read about a little trans girl who comes out to her mum.
I love that this book exists, and I hope many little trans kids find joy in it.

Was this review helpful?

Just Like Queen Esther is about a young transgirl's experience finding comfort in a traditional Jewish story. A compassionate tale that encourages a friendly relationship between the LGBTQ+ and Jewish communities, I recommend this story for Jewish families with LGBTQ+ youth, or liberal classrooms that want to increase diversity in their curriculum. This book has a reading level for children ages 5-8, but could be read aloud to younger children. Lastly, this book can establish a safe environment for a young child to feel comfortable telling an adult parent or teacher that they identify as a different gender.

The illustrations of this story celebrate round shapes such as curls, noses, and tutus, with a cartoonish art style that gives extra love to fun childhood fashions, like tutus, crowns, and costume jewelry. Atara is more than just a child who likes to dress as girl - she plays basketball, acts in the school play, and spends time with her mother reading and doing chores, and all these 3-dimensional details are illustrated to emphasize the well-roundedness of the protagonist.

Some sections of this book have a lengthy chunk of text that causes an abrupt shift in pacing. I wish these portions had more illustrations to help reduce the abruptness of the pacing shift. A young reader may reach these full-page portions of text and lose motivation.

Thanks to Ari Moffic, Kerry Olitzky, and Jessica Kingsley Publishers for a free ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I LOVE THIS BOOK!!! In all honesty, this book reminds me of Drama, but for younger readers. This book is utterly perfect for kids that can or cannot relate to Atara, and my genuine hope is that all kids read this book and adore it as much as I do. Additionally, I love how accepting each character in this book was. It is so wildly important for young and impressionable readers to see characters such as these so that they can mirror them. Lastly (because I have literally nothing bad to say about this book), the illustrations captured the elegance, joy, and beauty of Atara and her story.
Bravo!!!

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful story tackling several tough topics at a level appropriate for any child. This story was sweet and skillfully written.

Was this review helpful?

This is a sweet story of child realizing who they are after reading the story of Queen Ester. It is short but sweet and perfect for small children.

Was this review helpful?

That was so adorable!!! Atara is the sweetest and cutest, and I love the way she believed in herself and her mom did too! Also I always love when there's a book in a book haha!

Was this review helpful?

I love this. It's such a great lesson about being yourself and knowing who you are. I especially loved how she used the crown at first to get confidence until she realized she didn't need it anymore.
Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this

Was this review helpful?

This is a really cute book. I think with all the differences going on in our world in this day and age that this would be a good addition to any kids library! The graphics were super cute and the writing was easy to follow

Was this review helpful?

A sweet story about a trans girl learning to feel confident being herself, while taking inspiration from Queen Esther and the story of Purim. This story is needed, and it includes lessons to be learned both by kids and adults. I hope it will be read widely by Jewish (and non-Jewish) kids and their adults!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for an ARC of this book! I am honored to review it.

I was very intrigued by this book, as the main character Atara is a transgender child in a religiously themed book. I was not disappointed!

To start off, the readers are told right away that Atara has named herself. Atara’s mom is very supportive of her daughter, and the way she plays dress up to model Queen Esther, from the Jewish folklore and the Christian Bible. Atara questions if anyone knew Esther’s secret Jewish identity before she revealed herself, and was able to reflect about wether or not her parents knew she was a girl before she revealed herself.

I felt a bit confused as to where the plot was going, and what the takeaways were going to be. I felt like this book could have been edited to be more concise, but I liked how the book ended. Atara was able to go to school without her crown, but people still recognized her as Atara anyway.

Overall, this was a good read.

Was this review helpful?

This adorable story centers a trans girl as she learns about Purim and Queen Esther. It is story of the importance of self-confidence and believing in yourself.

It was nice how the fact that the main character is trans was not the center of the story and was just a fact that related well to the rest of the story.

I think this would resonate well with all sorts of children.

Thank you to Net Galley and Jessica Kingsley Publishers for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

Loved the illustrations and the character becoming who she is without her crown. The connection to Queen Esther is not one I would have made, and I appreciated the linking of religion and trans acceptance. This book could encourage kids to learn more about both subjects - always a good thing! Thanks for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

Not everyone is who they seem, and sometimes how you dress can make you feel more like who you know that you are. Atara knows that she is a girl who looks like a boy, but others only see who she is when she dresses up and wears a lovely crown everywhere she goes. Especially when she is Queen Esther in the play at drama class!
The illustrations by Rena Yehuda Newman are delightful, colorful, and fun!
Well suited for reading WITH someone of ANY age including ESL, and great for gifting to anyone, but especially to a school or your local public library!
I requested and received a temporary e-book on Adobe Digital Editions provided by Jessica Kingsley Publishers via NetGalley. Thank you! Avail Jan 21, 2025
@RenaYehuda @JKPBooks #QueenEsther #Purim #GenderDysphoria #AriMofficAuthor #KerryOlitzkyAuthor #JewishHero #BiblicalHero

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely book not only about the Jewish holiday of Purim, but the experience of a trans child. Even I feel like I learned something!

Was this review helpful?

What a lovely book not only about the Jewish holiday of Purim, but the experience of a trans child. This story really encapsulates the feeling of queer joy, and finding your truth.

An interesting read for any child!

Was this review helpful?

This book would appeal to a very specific group of young children. As a mother to three small children, I think it's important to have representation of all children. I think this book would appeal to very young elementary aged children but I think the topics discussed in this book are a little too hard for young elementary aged children to comprehend. I do think the illustrations in this book are beautiful.


Thank you so much, NetGalley, for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Great inclusive book dealing with gender identity. Utilized the story of Queen Ester and patterned across Atara’s realization she hid something too—that she was a girl.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a lovely introduction to most children about a little Jewish Trans girl.
I love the fact that in the story her transition wasn't spoken about as if it was a big deal, and she was genuinely just herself and accepted by others.
She also accepted herself and realised she didn't need a crown for others to know she was a girl - she just had to be herself.
Very cute little illustrations

Was this review helpful?

Just Like Queen Esther is a picture book about a young Jewish trans girl, Atara, who always wears her crown to feel confident and remind people that she is a girl. She is empowered by the story of Queen Esther, a Jewish heroine who also wore her crown all the time.

I really liked the mention of the meaning of Atara's name, and how she chose the name for herself. I feel like the story of Queen Esther was very simplified even for a children's book, and maybe there could have been a couple more sentences, but that's my only complaint. The illustrations are colorful and cheerful, and Atara learns to be even more confident in herself.

Was this review helpful?