Member Reviews

So I loved the mentions of different artists and bands plus I enjoyed how the timeline was laid out! Overall I enjoyed the storyline but in parts it felt a little like a YA novel!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to HarperCollins and Netgalley for a review copy of this book. The novel’s opening would have grabbed me even if I hadn’t already been prepared to dive into this book with its promise of music and a relationship that included music collaboration. The opening had the type of banter you wished you could have had back in college or high school to impress the angsty cool guys. At least for me it was, with its sharp insights about iconic songs and their composers. And this story is peppered with these interesting and thought provoking insights on songs but it also delves into relationships in general by exploring the line where friendship become romantic and where does it become? When it involves a deep connection of the mind does involving the body would one damage the other or enhance it? There are different kinds of relationships in Deep Cuts including the relationship a person has with a song and with music. The story centres around Percy, a young college woman trying to find her place in the music world when she has no instrument to play and believes her only role can be as an observer. When she meets Joe, a musician and songwriter she is instantly mesmerized by his talent and his insights. Though he has a girlfriend Percy finds she can find a place for both in her life and works hard to make a place in their life because she finds she needs it in a way that affirms who she is as a person of music. But Joe also needs her, at least her mind and her valuable input into his songwriting. She makes his songs better. They feed off of each other in a way that is at once exciting and painfully addictive. Following the development of this relationship takes the reader on a compelling and at times heart breaking journey over the years.

The structure isn’t always conventional with article inserts and opinion pieces Percy writes that illustrate aspects of who she is as well as her backstory. But it works in the overall novel and gives a sense of the times, the music as well as the meaning Percy takes from certain songs as they place in her life.

There is a bit of Normal People with a dash of Daisy Jones and the Six, but it stands on its own as an incredible debut novel. It is wonderfully compelling and will sit with me for a good while, giving me a deeper perspective as I work with my own music. This book isn’t just for musicians or those who obsess over lyrics, the novel’s merit is found in the deeper exploration of relationships as well as the impact music has in our lives. Recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Powerful toxic love story, a will they won’t they carved out of an NME magazine. Mesmerising writing, believable characters. Loathed Joey. Percy too good for him!!

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited when I got the email to say that I'd been approved for this ARC, as from the synopsis this sounded like a book I'd absolutely adore, so I dived straight in. However, it pains me to say this, but I did really struggle with this book, and had it not been an ARC, I probably wouldn't have finished.

Initially, it started off so strong and I was just warming up to the characters and the unique dynamic between them, and was excited to see where this went. I initially found Percy to be such a strong force and was excited to get to know her character. However, I wasn't prepared for how heavily prominent music and the talk of music would be in this novel. I did find this concept to be incredibly unique, however, I unfortunately tired of this very quickly with regards to all of the technical musical conversations and references, and unfortunately found myself growing bored and getting frustrated with the characters and therefore not connecting or liking any of them.

It devastates me to write this as I had such high hopes going in, but unfortunately I really struggled with the way it was written and therefore that really effected my overall enjoyment, meaning I didn't connect with the narrative of the characters at all.

If you are someone who is very musical and enjoys metaphorical conversations and references to musical language then I think this book would be excellent for you, but sadly I could not relate to any of this and did not realise how prominent this would be in the story, so unfortunately found this a struggle.

Thank you so much to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

A slow burning but moving story about love, friendship, and music. Spanning a decade from college life to the indie music scene, the book follows Percy, a music lover, and Joe, an aspiring musician.

This is a brilliant read for music lovers and anyone who loves character driven stories.

Was this review helpful?

I adored this! Platonic creative partnerships are one of my favourite genres of love story, and Holly Brickley has written a beautiful one. The music references are so specific in a way which elevates this beyond a lot of music-focused books, and the friendship between Percy and Zoe, a love story in it's own right, was also a real highlight. Huge fan!

Was this review helpful?

This books was great with shades of ‘One Day’ and ‘Daisy Jones and the Six’. I liked how although the book is centred around a romance, it felt like a subplot at times. The main story was how we think we know it all when we are young, we grow up a little and soon realise that we definitely don’t know it all, we get lost along the way but we can always find our way with perseverance and maturity. I also liked how the mcs weren’t romanticised and felt like they could be real people, it made their story ring more true to real life (albeit, outside of their professions). Also, the music references were so cleverly interwoven into the story to shape the mood of the scene and the characters, I really liked this aspect. Would definitely recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

Percy is a nerdy loner music lover and writer who is adopted by student and budding singer Joey and his girlfriend Zoe. Deep Cuts spans years of their relationship with music and with each other, an ode to love, friendship, and some really great songs.

I loved this book, it was clever, witty, well-written introduced me to some great new music, and felt like a familiar voice in my head!

Set to be released in February 2025, I recommend this debit novel to anyone who has obsessed over song lyrics, or played a song over and over because it hurt just right. You need to add this to your TBR.

Thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins UK, HarperFiction | The Borough Press for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely adored Percy who was brimming with vulnerability and longing for Joe.

Such a gorgeous slow burn romance that melted my heart and kept me turning pages to see what would happen between them.

The thene of pop songs and music was wonderful and deeply immersive - I often had to Google YouTube to play each song.

Beautiful. Tender and romantic - its a perfect imperfect love story.

Was this review helpful?

This was a slow burner for me. Percy’s character development was fantastic and I liked how she finally stood up for herself as the book went on. Joe comes across selfish and he is portrayed as your ‘typical famous musician.’ What I liked about this book was the clear passion about music and that Percy finds her creative power. It wasn’t my normal kind of book and although I started to enjoy it as it progressed, it took a while for me to get into.

Was this review helpful?

From reading the synopsis, this is not the book that I was expecting to read. To me, this seemed like it was going to be a hallmark movie type novel of the popular music star gaining all the plaudits with his female sidekick always making him better but never getting the limelight, but eventually he sees what was there all along.

This was not that novel. For one, it was a lot grittier than that. This is not a straightforward love story but a complex look at what real relationships can be like - right person, wrong place, wrong time - and the nature of ambition , greed, selfishness, jealousy and a million different emotions.

It is also a love letter to music. Not for those who listen to the radio or a few albums on Spotify. But to those (like me) who dissect each song, looking for the deeper meaning in every word, and look at each note, bridge and chorus could be improved.

I adored this book and anyone interested in music will too.

Thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins UK, HarperFiction | The Borough Press for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Deep Cuts by Holly Brickley is a compelling exploration of creativity, ambition, and the complexities of collaboration. Set in the fall of 2000, the novel opens with Percy Marks, a university student with an incessant need to analyze music. As Hall and Oates blare from the jukebox, Percy, with her sharp opinions and lack of musical talent, is drawn into a conversation with Joe Morrow, a fellow student and a talented songwriter. This casual meeting sparks a partnership that will shape both their lives in profound ways.

What starts as a discussion about music evolves into a deep and complicated creative collaboration. Percy, who has always viewed music through a critical, analytical lens, finds herself drawn to Joe’s raw talent and passion. As they begin working together, the pair develops a bond that oscillates between inspiration and tension. Joe’s songs inspire Percy, but her own creative output remains stifled, caught in the shadow of Joe’s success and their intense collaboration.

Brickley explores the impact of obsession on creativity, asking whether the desire to create and be heard can sometimes hinder personal growth. The relationship between Percy and Joe is fraught with competition, jealousy, and self-doubt as they struggle to navigate their evolving connection. Their partnership brings out the best and worst in them, as they push each other to new heights of artistic achievement while also confronting the toll their obsession with music takes on their personal lives.

As the book shifts from Brooklyn bars to the dance floors of San Francisco, Deep Cuts delves into themes of belonging, the search for identity, and the sacrifices made in the name of art. Brickley’s writing is sharp and introspective, capturing the heady mix of ambition and vulnerability that comes with trying to make a mark in the music world. Through Percy and Joe’s journey, readers are given an intimate look at the highs and lows of artistic pursuit, and the ways in which our relationships, both personal and professional, shape our creative processes.

The book’s strength lies in its authentic portrayal of the struggle between finding one’s voice and being subsumed by someone else’s success. Percy’s journey of self-discovery—her struggle to break free from the shadow of her partnership with Joe—provides a poignant reflection on the costs of artistic collaboration. Is their partnership worth its price, or is it holding her back from discovering her true potential? The tension between these questions drives the novel, making it a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant read.

Deep Cuts is an absorbing tale of music, creativity, and the quest for identity. It raises questions about what it means to truly be heard and whether we must sometimes lose ourselves in order to find our voice. With vivid character development and a gripping narrative, Holly Brickley crafts a novel that will resonate with anyone who has ever struggled to balance personal ambition with the complexities of collaboration.

Read more at The Secret Book Review.

Was this review helpful?

Firstly, thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book.
I’ll give credit where credit is due- I did want to keep reading this in spite of my many reasons for disliking this book, however I found it incredibly boring for the most part.

In all honesty I don’t understand why it’s being compared to Daisy Jones and the six or Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow because to me it felt miles away from either of those books.

In the aftermath of reading I cannot think of a single likeable character in this entire piece of writing. Every single one of them was incredibly narcissistic and lacked any sort of emotional complexity- Joe was a stereotypical self absorbed male musician which was to be expected but Percy was equally insufferable in her own way. It felt like the book kept trying to make random points of social/political commentary for the most part through Zoe, (I think that was her name, I’ve already forgotten), at the weirdest moments which didn’t make sense in the context of the scenes and conversations happening at the time, and began to get on my nerves as the book progressed.
Although some details were provided about Joe’s life and backstory, I felt like I knew nothing about our narrator and main character Percy which caused a big disconnect while reading. In spite of this, both of the main characters were incredibly dull and didn’t feel fleshed out in the slightest, I simply couldn’t connect to either, especially when their yearning for one another caused such constant conflict and wasn’t enjoyable to read.

After being so excited to read this book due to its really intriguing sounding description, in all honesty, I really regret this being my first read of 2025 as I was unfortunately bitterly disappointed. The single redeeming factor in this book for me was the references to Stevie Nicks and Joni Mitchell so I thank the author for that, but I just don’t think this delivered what it promised in my opinion.

Was this review helpful?

I read Deep Cuts in a single day over the new year period and thoroughly enjoyed it. It's a real love letter to indie music of the naughts. Beautifully written and superb characters. I already have at least two friends in mind who will be receiving it as birthday gifts next year.

Was this review helpful?

It's better than normal people but not quite as good as tomorrow tomorrow tomorrow it failed down her win between am not a love story type of gal but I did the the realism of this tho I don't understand why people in books create drama and turmoil from nothings it becomes anything to read the fact this book had quite an unique setting and background saved it for me and I liked the music references not sure I'd be in a hurry to read anything from the wetter again despite it well written it wasn't really for me

Was this review helpful?

I recently received an ARC for an honest review of "Deep Cuts" by Holly Brickley, and I was truly captivated by the intricate love story portrayed in the book. The narrative follows two individuals who are not only connected by their shared passion for music but also torn apart by the very same force that unites them. Brickley's writing skillfully weaves together themes of love, loss, and the power of music, creating a story that is both heart-wrenching and beautiful. The characters are well-developed, and the emotional depth of their journey resonates with the reader long after the final page. Overall, "Deep Cuts" is a must-read for anyone who appreciates a powerful and poignant love story intertwined with the magic of music.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful “sort of love” story between main characters Percy and Joe, centered around their passion for music, as they navigate growing up, songwriting, fame, heartbreak and their need for each other.

Plenty of music references throughout which will create a fab playlist!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers for my ARC.

I wanted to read this because I saw that Coco Mellors had blurbed it, and she is one of my favourite authors. But unfortunately I just didn’t like this. It fell completely flat. I didn’t like the characters, I didn’t like the plot, and I couldn’t get into it no matter how hard I tried. The writing was fine, that wasn’t the issue, and I can see why others are raving about this book, but for me it just felt dull and lacklustre. I didn’t care about the characters at all nor did I find the main protagonist’s interesting or feel any chemistry or tension between them. Sorry.

Was this review helpful?

This was a love letter to music and the early to mid 2000s. The companion playlist was a wonderful addition and I found myself playing it around the house when I was doing odd jobs, just to immerse myself in the world of the story. The book is tender, showing the complex and evolving relationships we develop with those we care for in our early to mid 20s. It is clear that the author has an incredible knowledge and understanding of the music I grew up with and id love to hear her talk about the music that inspired her in person. It is such a moving and relatable story that drags you into the world of Percy and Joe. It took me a long time to finish this one because it would remind me of a song, I’d go to listen to it and fall down a music rabbit hole.

Was this review helpful?

Deep Cuts is a stunning debut full of love, heartbreak and music. Percy is an English major at Berkeley in the late 90s/early 2000s. She’s struggled a fair bit with romantic and platonic relationships until she meets Joe, an aspiring musician and political science major with a punk girlfriend Zoe. While Percy insists she has no musical talent of her own, she is great at giving productive criticism, and so Joe and Percy write music together. The three of them become a close trio. Over time, their relationships to one another evolve, Joe fully commits to the music while Percy finds herself in an MFA programme where she’s still struggles to find her voice. Zoe meanwhile is off being an activist. They encounter heartbreak, both platonic and romantic, betrayal and lots and lots of music.

I must admit that some of the music references passed me by, but even though I didn’t know each and every song, Deep Cuts stands out as Percy’s POV makes you feel the music. Music is a great tool within the novel, it extends beyond the fact that Joe becomes a musician. Percy explains her own feelings with music and it makes for a very moving book. This book is being compared to Daisy Jones & the Six, but I think they use music in very distinct ways. Nevertheless, if you liked Daisy Jones & the Six you’ll probably like this and I would recommend picking it up. I’d also prepare for some deep cutting (see what i did there) emotions, maybe a couple of tears. It’s also a slightly… unfinished book? It obviously finished, but it leaves a lot out in the open. We’re not entirely sure how their lives will continue and clearly our characters emotional baggage hasn’t been fixed. I like that, it feels realistic to some extent.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?