
Member Reviews

By the end of the book i was gripped! I initally picked this book up during a book slump and ended up getting so invested in the characters and just wanting to keep reading until everything was resolved.
While the main character made mistakes and frustrated me at times i couldn’t help but sympathise, this novel puts such a real and insightful spin on the hardships of writers block and the impact that personal life can have on the creative process. (Even though the FMC makes her life way harder than it has to be!)
Throughout the story, I found myself liking the love interest more and more, much like the main character does, despite not wanting to get close to anyone for fear of a repeat of her unsuccessful past, as well as the fear of losing the ability to write again after finally getting inspiration after months of not writing. I was a bit aprehensive at the begining when Allie met her love interest, Will, while still in a relationship with Disappointing Dom, but as the story unfolded and everything was revealed I got swept up in the emotions...even when Allie found out Will was closer to her than she realised...
And let’s not forget about the friendship!! I’m so happy that Allie’s life was about way more than just boys, and showing such an imporant and supportive friendship was just as needed. I was also pleased to note that the friendship wasn’t just there to further the story; Allie was also there for both of her friends, expressing her happiness at their good news and knowing that they had their whole lives outside of Allie helped me to get invested in the characters, even believing Allie’s assumptions about her friends.

I think I thought this was one of the other books with this title. This book was fine. I was a huge fan of the tone of the writing it took quite a bit for me to get into it and unfortunately I never really ended up getting attached to any of the characters. I feel like maybe it just felt rushed and underdeveloped? I think maybe in such an overcrowded market where like 6 different books have basically the same cover and title there are just more exciting options? I wanted to love it, I'm sorry. This just wasn't it for me.

After writing several bestselling romantic novels, Allie experiences writer's block and wonders if her relationship is rooted in her lack of romantic plots. The story's plot is multilayered and features complex characters and many humorous situations. Allie meets Martin, a once-famous older author who shares her writing impasse. Their serendipitous meeting helps and hinders them both and provides the title's plot twist. Meeting Will is lust at first sight for Allie and delivers the story's sweet, slow-burn romance. Contemporarily relevant and pacy, it's an engaging read. It does move between scenes haphazardly, but this is deliberate to mirror Allie's emotions and writing difficulties. I like the originality, the complex characters and the exploration of modern love.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book. I want to be upfront that I did DNF this book after 51% as I was expecting a more romance heavy novel versus a literary fiction/mystery novel.
Based on the cover and the blurb of the book, I was expecting a lot more romance in this book. At 51%, we had only encountered one romantic scene when I was begging for more. I loved the concept of a romance writer going through a breakup and then becoming interested in a man who is a caterer.
I felt the plot moving from the romance aspect when we focused on the crime novel writer, Martin. Once we started getting into his story and everything going on with his kids and wife, I was completely lost and couldn't continue. I really wanted to know what happened with Allie and Will but it seemed we were barely getting those scenes.
I did enjoy getting to know Allie and the publishing sides to things. I also enjoyed the friendships that were developed in this book. I think if this was marketed more as a literary fiction or a mystery, it would find the right audience.

I’ll give this book 2.5 stars, rounded up, because I DNFed it and I believe this is an “it’s me not you” situation. I may have slept on a gem here. I was far enough into the book to determine that it wasn’t for me.

The Plot Twist has a fun and refreshing concept—two writers swapping genres to overcome their creative slumps while forming an unexpected bond. Eleanor Goymer delivers an engaging, lighthearted story that blends humor, romance, and a touch of self-discovery.
The premise sets up the potential for a witty and emotionally rich romcom. The writing is charming, and fans of cozy bookish romances will still find plenty to enjoy. If you love stories about writers, genre-swapping chaos, and a mix of humor and heart, this is worth picking up. While it doesn’t fully deliver on its potential, it’s an entertaining and feel-good read.

It’s a cute story around writers block and what we use for inspiration. Just a sweet romantic read reminding you to root for the happily ever afters no matter what the age.
If you’re into books about writers, creative struggles, or just need a pick-me-up, this might just be your book. It’s predictable in the best way, like your favorite rom-com movie.
Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for the opportunity to review a temporary digital ARC in exchange for an unbiased review.

It’s a cute story around writers block and what we use for inspiration. I couldn’t get behind Allie as the main character, her inner monologue bothered me for a reason I can’t put my finger on but I really liked Martin, Jess, and Will. So I was able to continue for them.

The Plot Twist was such a cute romantic fiction. I loved that Allie was a writer working on her novel and the mentor relationship she had with Martin. I loved the backroom drama at the publishing house for the side story line. Allie was a wee bit frustrating at times with the choices she made, BUT the character growth was good and I adored Will as her lead. Just a sweet romantic read reminding you to root for the happily ever afters no matter what the age.
Thanks to #NetGalley and #HarperCollinsUK- one more chapter for the ARC.

Cute romantic comedy! This book was a lovely read and to see all the characters find their own happy endings was really sweet.
There was a lot of plot packed into the book but it was fairly well rounded and everything was wrapped up well with not too much going on to be left confused.
The characters depth was great and having your own guesses turn out to be completely wrong at some points was great fun to read.
Pacing was brilliant. Always kept wanting to turn the page and keep in going until the next chapter.
I'm not a fan of third act breakups generally so wasn't my favourite part to read but it did move plot fairly quickly and didn't drag it out which I do greatly appreciate.
The full circle sort of path it took as well was good and I enjoyed all the throwbacks to the same locations used throughout. Really make me feel like I was actually travelling around London with them.
Overall, a great read if you're after a cute romance, I shall definitely be reccommending to my friends who love this genre.
Favourite Quote - Dating etiquette could go to hell, there was nothing sexier than a man being straightforward and honest about what he wanted.
Favourite Character - Martin

The Plot Twist is a romcom whirlwind about author Allie. Allie has writer's block and a mind that travels a mile a minute. Panic ensues when she has nothing to show to her editor.
And I'm afraid this is the part of the story in which I stopped reading - around about the 7% mark. I hate to do this to a book, but I have to say it. It isn't very well-written. The prose just doesn't flow. At times, I thought I was reading a screenplay with the author moving the different characters to and fro. We have an overuse of names when refering to the characters, mindless repetition of known facts and poor use of the English language.
I couldn't get into it I'm afraid, which is a shame as the premise sounds new and exciting. Give it a good rewrite and edit and I'm sure it will score a lot higher.

The plot list had a slow start but once you get into the book it was pretty cute. I loved the relationships that the main character developed but I wish there was more of a focus on romance. I thought it was cute how it showed her downfall and then rediscover of her love of romance once she finds love. I would have loved more backstory on her character as well as Will. Pretty cute story though focusing on the world of authors.

I really liked this book. It’s the kind of cozy, feel-good rom-com you want to curl up with on a lazy Sunday. Allie, a romcom writer with major writer’s block, teams up with Martin, a grumpy crime novelist, to swap plots and get their creative juices flowing. Cue an unexpected friendship. The same night she meets Martin, Allie also runs into a cute caterer named Will who might just be Allie’s real-life leading man.
The writing is sharp and funny, and I adored the dynamic between Allie and Martin—it’s like a quirky professor-student relationship with loads of heart. The romance with Will is sweet, though I wish we got a bit more of him. Still, it’s a fun, easy read with just enough drama to keep things interesting. It's also an interesting view into the world of publishing in the UK.
If you’re into books about writers, creative struggles, or just need a pick-me-up, this might just be your book. It’s predictable in the best way, like your favorite rom-com movie. Definitely adding Eleanor Goymer to my must-read list!
Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for the opportunity to review a temporary digital ARC in exchange for an unbiased review.

When struggling with writers block and a break-up, Romance write Allie crosses paths with a well-known crime writer and they decide to help each other out. Martin is stuck in the past and struggling to write something current and Allie is struggling to write in her own field.
The premise for the story is great and the characters are likeable. Iw as able to identify with Allie at many points in the story.

Allie is going through a rough patch—battling writer's block, facing an identity crisis, and struggling with a failing relationship. To make matters worse, her publisher is demanding a manuscript, and her ruthless new boss only adds to the pressure.
Just when things seem hopeless, she meets Martin, a seasoned crime writer. With sincerity, they open up about their troubles and realize that working together might be the key to overcoming their personal and professional struggles.
Amidst the chaos, Allie finds herself unexpectedly single—only to cross paths with Will, a charming caterer who makes her question whether romance is truly dead.
The Plot Twist is a light, charming read that kept me engaged from start to finish. There's something special about books that center on writers, and this one was no exception—I enjoyed every page.

The Plot Twist by Elenore Goymer is the perfect feel-good read—the kind of rom-com you’d want to curl up with on a rainy day. It has a lighthearted charm that keeps you turning the pages, even if the concept leans toward the predictable. But honestly? That’s part of its appeal. It has that Hallmark movie feel, where you know how things will play out, yet you’re happy to go along for the ride.
The story follows a successful author struggling with writer’s block, feeling the pressure of an impending deadline. In desperation, she turns to another writer for help—someone who, compared to her, feels like a relic of the past. As they bounce ideas, share anecdotes, and swap plot twists, inspiration finally starts to spark again.
Of course, keeping this collaboration under wraps proves trickier than expected. The protagonist, Allie, insists on secrecy… only to promptly spill the truth to a few people. Her actions might seem silly, but they’re also entirely believable—I know people who would do the exact same thing in her shoes, which makes the story feel more grounded and relatable.
At its core, the book explores themes of self-doubt, self-sabotage, and the fear of ruining a good thing before it even begins. There’s an excitement and intrigue to watching it all unfold, and the writing has a modern feel without being overly heavy-handed in its messaging.
Overall, The Plot Twist is a quick, easy, and entertaining read—perfect for a holiday escape or a lazy Sunday afternoon. If you love rom-coms with witty banter, endearing characters, and a touch of chaos, this one’s worth picking up.

The premise of this book was so, so promising, but the execution, unfortunately, fell short.
There felt like too many plot lines going on for a book this short and all of the resolutions ended up feeling ridiculously rushed for completion. Additionally, there were really awkward time jumps from one chapter to the next that did not seem to have any rhyme or reason to.
I almost wish this was either a dual POV with Martin or told from the POV of Martin himself to see his love life play out.
Thank you NetGalley for a copy of this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

The Plot Twist has an instantly gripping premise - romcom author down on her luck with a terrible boyfriend meets grizzled crime novelist forced to write to save his kid from their bad decisions, and they both decide to switch narratives. Allie and Martins relationship and banter is great, and the genuine highlight of this book - both literally with their literary switch, and with the fresh perspectives they give to eachothers lives. Did not find myself particularily caring for Will, the love interest though - it felt for my personal taste their relationship went past very quickly and personally i didnt like the detail that Allie started feeling an insta attraction to him while still chronolgically with her terrible boyfriend (who then conveniently breaks up with her and is kissing 'uber drivers' lmao- way too neat and conveniently absolving for our protagonist to not be the bad guy, in my opinion!) The publishing side of the story, side characters, and again, Allie and Martins relationship definitely was the parts that ultimately resonated with me greater than the romatic relationship - martins wife, literal sweetheart Angie was a particular show stealer for me :) if you love a cozy feeling book woth romance and rebuilding relationships at the forefront, read this story!

Read If You Like:
- Romantic comedies featuring writers
- Stories about overcoming creative block
- Intergenerational friendships
- Narratives exploring the writing process
- Lighthearted romances with depth
When romcom author Allie Edwards crosses paths with bestselling crime novelist Martin Clark at a party, they discover they both have crippling writer’s block, overdue manuscripts, and precisely zero words to show to their respective editors.
With deadlines looming, Allie and Martin decide to switch plots and tell each other’s stories. In the writing process, Allie not only gains a father-figure in Martin, but also meets gorgeous events caterer Will, the answer to the leading man-shaped hole in her life and her lack of spicy material. Caught between love and her career, what could possibly go wrong?
This novel offers a delightful exploration of the creative process, the challenges of writer's block, and the unexpected connections that can change one's life. With witty dialogue, endearing characters, and a fresh perspective on storytelling, it's a must-read for fans of contemporary romance and stories about writers.
Thanks so much for my ARC!

a really good read by eleanor. I don't know what to say but this is one of the freshest things ive ever read..