Member Reviews

Star Circle by Davis Bunn is a smart, character-driven adventure that blends science fiction with a touch of mystery and spiritual undertones. The novel offers a unique blend of action, intrigue, and philosophical musings that will appeal to readers who enjoy thoughtful, engaging stories with a bit of a mind-bending twist.

Story & Setting
The story centers around a group of explorers who are investigating a mysterious cosmic phenomenon—the Star Circle. This unexplained event is tied to ancient myths and possibly even humanity’s origins. As the characters dig deeper into the mystery, they’re forced to confront not just the potential discovery of a lifetime, but also their own beliefs, fears, and pasts.

The setting is wonderfully immersive, shifting between high-tech space stations, quiet moments of reflection, and breathtaking, otherworldly phenomena. Davis Bunn does an excellent job of creating a world that feels both futuristic and grounded, where the pursuit of knowledge and self-understanding go hand in hand. The mystery surrounding the Star Circle is compelling, and as it unravels, the book asks big questions about humanity’s place in the universe—questions that are philosophical but also deeply personal for the characters involved.

Plot & Pacing
The plot moves at a steady pace, slowly building the intrigue as more pieces of the mystery are revealed. There’s a lot of tension as the characters grapple with not just the science of what they’re discovering but also the personal stakes tied to their journey. The pacing does slow down in parts, especially when the narrative delves into deeper reflections on life and purpose, but it never drags for too long. It’s a bit like watching a slow-burn thriller where the tension is more intellectual than action-driven.

The main mystery—what exactly the Star Circle represents and what it means for humanity—is fascinating and keeps you hooked. It’s a lot more than just a “what’s out there?” question. It’s about what the discovery of the Star Circle could mean for how we understand life, existence, and even the nature of the divine.

Character Development
What really stands out in Star Circle is the character development. The novel’s strength lies in its deep exploration of the inner lives of its characters. They are all highly competent professionals in their respective fields, but they’re also grappling with personal doubts, unresolved conflicts, and the search for meaning beyond the work they do. Bunn gives these characters layers, making their struggles and growth as interesting as the plot itself.

The protagonist, Liam, is a fascinating figure—driven, but with a complexity that makes him more than just your typical heroic figure. He has doubts about the journey they’re on, and as the mysteries of the Star Circle begin to unravel, his own beliefs and motivations are tested in ways that feel real and human. The supporting cast is equally compelling, with each member bringing their own strengths and vulnerabilities to the table.

Themes
At its core, Star Circle is a book about discovery—not just of the universe but of the self. It explores themes of purpose, the search for meaning, and what it means to be human in the vast, often unfathomable cosmos. There’s also a subtle undercurrent of spirituality running through the story, as the discovery of the Star Circle pushes the characters to confront questions about life, death, and the possibility of something greater than themselves.

The book isn’t preachy or heavy-handed, but it does encourage readers to think about their own place in the world, especially when faced with something truly awe-inspiring. The personal journeys of the characters are just as important as the external plot, and that balance of internal and external discovery is part of what makes Star Circle so engaging.

Writing Style & Tone
Davis Bunn’s writing is clear, reflective, and introspective, which fits the tone of the book perfectly. He doesn’t rush through the action, but rather takes his time to explore the emotional and philosophical layers of the story. There are moments of quiet contemplation, which are balanced with bursts of excitement and wonder as the mystery deepens. The tone is thoughtful but also hopeful, making you think about the big questions without feeling overwhelmed by them.

The pacing is a little slower than some readers may expect from a typical sci-fi adventure, but it’s all in service of the deeper themes. The space exploration and scientific elements are well thought-out and detailed, but it’s the character-driven aspects and the way Bunn balances those with the larger cosmic questions that make this book stand out.

Criticism
The pacing might be an issue for some readers, particularly those who are looking for a fast-paced, action-heavy science fiction novel. There are certainly moments where the narrative slows down to reflect on deeper philosophical questions, and while that can be rewarding, it may feel like a lull if you’re hoping for more immediate excitement.

Additionally, while the character development is one of the book’s strongest points, some readers might find the philosophical and spiritual discussions a bit too introspective at times. The book doesn’t shy away from big ideas, and while this adds depth, it can sometimes overshadow the action-driven aspects of the plot.

Conclusion
Overall, Star Circle is a thought-provoking, character-driven sci-fi novel that offers much more than just space exploration. Davis Bunn has crafted a story that blends mystery, intellectual exploration, and personal growth in a way that keeps the reader engaged on multiple levels. The questions it poses about humanity, the cosmos, and our purpose in life are big ones, and while it’s not a fast-paced action thriller, the emotional and philosophical depth of the book makes it a deeply rewarding read.

If you enjoy science fiction that takes its time to explore the personal and philosophical aspects of exploration and discovery, Star Circle will certainly resonate with you. It’s a novel that lingers with you long after you’ve turned the last page.

Was this review helpful?

Spoiler free review** Recieved as an Arc and unfortunatly also didnt know this was part of a series. but after reading the book i would highly reccomend reading all books. i still really enjoyed this and plan to go back and read the other two books. its an alien based fantasy read, its got that real us and them theme that runs through that actually had me very invested, the world was fairly easy to follow considering i hadnt read the previous books. if you are interested in Alien fantasy i would highly reccomend this trilogy, i found that i was invested fairly early on and thought it was a really thought provoking read! 3.5 rounded up

Was this review helpful?

I loved to read this book so much. I rated it 5 stars because it was that good! I recommend everyone to read this book as fast as they can because it's really good.

Was this review helpful?

I received an arc of this book not realising it was part of a series and
is in fact book 3 . Understanding the worldbuilding , the characters
and their place within the ever changing world you really need to
read the previous books
That being said I did manage to work my way through this compelling
story without too much difficulty .
The storyline of aliens reaching out to Earth is not new but the manner
of the message is different to the norm - putting a new slant on the idea
of "we are not alone "
It emphasises the problem of Governments who see enemies in anyone
who does not conform to their mantras , who will stoop to any level to
demonise those who do not agree with them , silencing them if they can
...... just so that they can retain their own personal powerbases .
I loved the idea of one separating from the whole , sacrificing themselves
to get a message out , asking for help "we are dying " - this is not something
humans as a species , with noble exceptions , would normally do ....... self
preservation being paramount , fear of the unknown and change can be a terrible thing
Having read this book in one long sitting and enjoying it so much I will be reading
the previous books to fully understand the backstory and look forward to the
next book in the series ............ I hope to meet these aliens who so far appear to be benign ??

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for my e-arc!

love a good blend of science fiction, thriller, and magical realism. The book was fast paced which I enjoyed alongside being well written. Really good attention to detail with the character with a fab ending

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed reading this book! I love a good blend of science fiction, thriller, and magical realism. This book had a really fast pace, and it was very well written. I loved the way that the characters were written, and how the book ended

Thank you to NetGalley, to the author, and to the publisher for this complementary ARC in exchange for my honest review!!!

Was this review helpful?