Member Reviews

Great to read another instalment in this series having read all the previous ones when they first came out, a real blast from the past. Brilliant writing as always, great characters. Thank you netgalley for the advanced copy

Was this review helpful?

It is many years since I have read a Patricia Scanlan book. Still the same lovely writing and highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

This was a trip down memory lane having read the original book on the City Girls.

Patricia Scanlan writes effortlessly and this was just wonderful to catch up with those characters that I had read about so many years before.

It doesn't matter if you didn't read the original, but you may find this more enjoyable if you have done.

Was this review helpful?

I was a huge fan of the original city girls books so was so excited to receive this!! Made me feel nostalgic I loved every second of it. Patricia scanlan always hits for me

Was this review helpful?

#CityGirlsForever #NetGalley How great to catch up with the girls again!! I read the original trilogy many years ago and it was so lovely to catch up with Devlin, Maggie and Caroline all these years later. Although related to the previous trilogy it is perfectly capable of being read as a stand alone although if you haven't read the originals, please do - if you enjoyed this book you wont be disappointed. Superbly written by Patricia Scanlan, there is a perfect mix of laughter and tears. A great read.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, I remember reading and enjoying the original trilogy many years ago, so was very intrigued to see this pop up, and what a great book it was too, bringing back all the old characters, now 30 years later.

You don't need to have read the original books, but if you have it will be more enjoyable and although I haven't read them for years ( I have them on my bookshelf), I still remembered the gist of them and remember them very fondly.

City Girls Forever is a great book very well written by Patricia Scanlan - a joy to read and hear more about Devlin, Caroline and Maggie!!

Was this review helpful?

I was so looking forward to this one and it didn’t disappoint me. I reread City Girls before I started this one. It was great to catch up with the lives of Devlin, Caroline and Maggie. It is lovely that their families are great friends also. Here’s hoping there is another sequel in a few years time.

Was this review helpful?

The girls are back in town.
How great it was to catch up with Devlin, Caroline and Maggie again. Fans of Patricia Scanlon will be delighted to reacquaint themselves with the feisty ladies and to see how life has been treating them. Older yes, wiser yes, but still ready to take on the world if needs be. Having grown up with these girls it’s great to find out how life has evolved for them, the good the bad and the ugly. . I think long time fans will not be disappointed and new readers will be ordering the back catalogue to get to know these ladies better.
For me this is a 4.5 ⭐️book.
Many thanks to #NetGalley and #simonschusterUK for my ARC of this great book.

Was this review helpful?

The return of the City Girls series see Devlin, Caroline and Maggie taking on middle age. Devlin's City Girl gym and spa is turning 35, but as she prepares to party, her past returns in a shocking way. Maggie is struggling with family problems, and Caroline is facing the fact she will never have the life she wanted.

It was lovely to revisit the characters I first read about many years ago. I'll admit I struggled with working out how old everyone was supposed to be, so I had to stop thinking too hard about it at times because some things didn't make sense in my head! I enjoyed the mix of happy, sad and amusing content, in the well written and easy to read style that you expect from a Patricia Scanlan novel. A good read.

Was this review helpful?

This book was such a treat, I had read all the other books in this collection 2hen I eas a teenager. It was lov3ly to go back and see how the girls lives have changed and follow them on their next chapter. This was a beautifully written book and I can highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to get the opportunity to read City Girls Forever. I fell in love with the series over 20 years ago when my mother passed them onto me read. It was such a delight to catch up with Maggie, Caroline and Devlin.

Was this review helpful?

It was a pleasure to be back in Dublin with the City Girls again. It’s been a long time since I read them when they were published but I enjoyed being reacquainted with Maggie, Caroline and Devlin the years slipped away.
Now in their 50s the three are still firm friends.
A fantastic story which had me captured from page 1.
Just goes to prove not all family are by blood.
Thank you NetGalley for an ARC of Patricia Scanlans new book.

Was this review helpful?

It has been over 30 years since Devlin, Maggie and Caroline left an imprint on my heart. After my mother completed City Girls, I was allowed to read it, and felt very grown-up to be so engrossed in life for ladies who knew what they wanted even if they didn’t always get it. Now three decades later, the friends still adore each other – but life isn’t without its share of setbacks. Shock revelations, the impact of Covid and romantic woes can happen at any age, even if you think you’ve got your life together. It is so wonderful to have them back and see them as prepared as ever to take on life.

Was this review helpful?

What a fabulous read. I thoroughly enjoyed every word.
City Girls Forever catches up with Devlin, Caroline and Maggie, some thirty years on from when we first met them in City Girl.
This book works perfectly well as a standalone read about the lives of three lifelong friends who have seen each other through thick and thin, through heartaches and joys, supporting and loving each other unconditionally for better and for worse. That said I've just indulged in the joy of re-reading all three of the previous books, City Girl, City Woman and City Lives and the four-part binge-read has been nothing short of exquisite.
Not only is this a tale of true friendships, but it also touches on some very serious issues, while at the same time, each book shines a light on some of the pertinent real-life issues affecting Ireland in the times in which they are set. From the Civic Centre in Dublin’s Wood Quay to the site of the new children’s hospital, they provide a modern history lesson.
I now have a huge City Girl shaped hole in my life and I'm feeling bereft to have left the ladies' company.

Was this review helpful?

How I loved catching up with Caroline, Devlin, and Maggie.
This is set many years later, and the women are now settled into their careers.
I loved how we were transported into each of their lives and all the events that unfolded. How they had each other's backs and supported one another. True friendship.There was certainly plenty going on. A wedding, a funeral, and a court case while dealing with the everyday family stuff.
I really didn't want this to ever end.
I'm hoping there may be another where we see the three women in their old age. You never know
Thanks to Netgalley and Simon and Schuster UK for the ARC in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I remember 'discovering' the City Girl series in my local library at a rather young age, and being both shocked and amazed by the lives of Devlin, Caroline and Maggie. The trio were at once a source of curiosity for me and also, inspiration as they constantly thrived no matter, the trauma they faced and their friendship was a connection that brought support, love and laughter into their lives. The trilogy holds a special place in my heart, so you can imagine my excitement on hearing that 'City Girls Forever', a final novel was being released.
It's 35 years since the popular City Girl gym was created by Devlin and although still successful, the company has weathered through some difficult times with a recession and panademic, so with the an anniversary looming, Devlin decides that it is time to celebrate. Devlin is facing some personal challenges when an acquaintance reintroduces the obnoxious Colin Cantrell-king back into her life. There is an element of the 'Me too' movement with this element of the storyline and while unpleasant, brings the storyline an element of cold reality to the tale as casual sexism/abuse are all too prevalent in today's society. However, this storyline is sensitively handled and even then, has a moderately positive ending for the female characters.
Whilewise, Maggie & Caroline have also moved on with their lives and Maggie is now a successful author, with three adult children and has long divorced Terry (though the former villainess Rita Kirby is long gone!) Unfortunately, Terry does not seem to have changed very much and it's his children who bear the brunt of his former behaviour though this leads to some humorous scenes. And poor Caroline, she always seem to struggle in her love life, even when her career life and friendships are stronger than ever, but this time around, hopefully she will find that happy ending.
Whenever you return to a much loved series, there is always a fear that the original emotions will be lost, that you will not recover that original love for a tale. But I've re-read the 'City Girl trilogy' numerous times and loved the series more and more on each reading. And now, I can safely say, that City Girls Forever is a great ending to the series. Our girls have grown up with us, overcome their original battles and are stronger than ever - and reading about them, still feels like sitting down for a chat with old friends.

Was this review helpful?

This novel is a poignant and beautifully written exploration of friendship, following the lives of three women who have shared over three decades of highs and lows. From the joys of births and marriages to the challenges of divorce and grief, their enduring bond offers a heartwarming glimpse into the strength of lifelong connections. However, the book also bravely tackles heavy topics such as sexual abuse and eating disorders, making it a thoughtful but sometimes challenging read. While it forms part of the City Girl series, it stands perfectly well on its own, offering a rich and compelling narrative for both new and returning readers. A heartfelt story of resilience and friendship, but one to approach with awareness of its difficult themes.

Was this review helpful?

Patricia is a fantastic writer. I have to pace myself so often so I know I'll always have books of her to turn too. They are full of the best characters. They are full of the dreamiest descriptions so that I can picture all she describes. They are my perfect sit down with a good book read.
I admit I've never gone as far back(yet) in her back catalogue. So I haven't heard of these smashing ladies before. But I will soon. Because I loved these woman. And wanted to get to know there past jaunts too.
I love reading about older characters( or more mature compared to the norm!)
This gaggle of friends were brilliant. I loved to read about a group so tight. A group that would ultimately be there through good and bad.
All the characters are so different but I could picture them all. And it made reading them all the better imagining their personalities as I went.

Was this review helpful?

I cannot believe it is 30 years since we heard from the City Girls. I loved this series about 3 friends and the progression of their lives and friendship. This instalment brings us right up to date with the state of their lives and careers. There are many ups and downs in the lives of each of the three friends. Always knowing that the other two are there for them come what May. I loved this and I am sure you will too. If you are a follower of these friends you need to be brought up to date. I have all of Patricia Scanlon’s books. Each one an absolute joy.

Was this review helpful?

An absolutely cracking read.

This was a fabulous read. It's about three long-time friends, their lives and families, and their ups and downs.

I first heard about Patricia Scanlan many years ago-I saw a set of two of her paperbacks on special offer, (Promises, Promises, and Mirror, Mirror), snapped them up, and what a fab read! I went on to read just about all of her books. I have read the three previous 'City' titles, and I know I enjoyed them-but I don't remember much about the happenings in them, as it was ages ago. Starting this book, it didn't seem to matter if you hadn't recently read the others, as the action takes place 30+ years later. I soon got into the story without having to look back etc. This book could be enjoyed even if you hadn't read the others.

A warm, wonderful cosy read to curl up with. Wise, and well-observed. Covers issues lots of families come up against and experience. Fast-moving, the pace never lets up. It just flows, so you get through it before you realise. Her writing just has the skill to hold you to her pages. Easy to get into, and so easy to get absorbed in.

Well-written. Perfectly expressing the characters' thoughts and feelings, so you're glued to their stories. It's unpredictable, and varied. Included many of my favourite ingredients I like to read about. An absolutely cracking read.

I was delighted to have the chance to read a pre-publication copy of this book. It's quite a big book, so I thought I'd save it for an upcoming hospital stay.....not a chance! Once I had a dip in it, I just couldn't stop, and now it's finished. What a great read.

This will delight fans of Patricia Scanlan's writing. And if you've not read any of her books yet, you have a whole load to look forward to.

Was this review helpful?