Member Reviews

A wonderful read so well written really intriguing. enjoyed from first to last page.Trying to figure out what was really unfolding.#netgalley #audition

Was this review helpful?

I must admit I was confused by the story line but it was beautifully written.

I feel that I have to re read it just so I can understand more what the author was trying to do with the plot...

Was this review helpful?

I’ll be honest, I have no idea what happened in the last 50 pages or so. This book is split into 2 parts with varying levels of truth telling and unreliable narration. The main character, an unnamed woman, is an actress who sits down for lunch with a much younger man, Xavier. He is her son, but also not her son, and the centre of her life, but also not. The plot moves incredibly slow as we are slowly drip fed information about these two.

The writing was brilliant, something I cannot fault. Each sentence was beautifully constructed and had a whimsical feel. My criticism comes with the plot itself. I love an unreliable narrator and shifting timeline, but this felt all over the place and impossible to understand towards the end. There were too many moving parts, plot wise, I wish I had an answer by the end but alas I did not.

Was this review helpful?

Audition by Katie Kitamura is a book for those who appreciate form over substance. 2.5 stars.

An unnamed actress walks into a busy NYC restaurant to meet a young man named Xavier. The conversation she’s sharing with him is cut short by her husband Tomas randomly walking in and out of the restaurant - does he think she’s cheating? What is going on? What is he doing here?

That scene jumpstarts the book that follows. The unnamed actress goes about her life and the story slowly unravels how she sees and interacts with the people around her after Xavier walked into her life like a wrecking ball. The book is told in two parts that can be sort of summarized as ‘Xavier walks into MC’s mundane uninteresting life’ and ‘Xavier is part of MC’s life,’ I guess? The last 50 pages of the second part were too much. At no point did I understand what I was reading, but the ending just really had me… frustrated? A lot was happening and I didn’t get why or what was the point.

There was an important conversation left out between Part 1 and Part 2 that I wish had been in the book. And, I do have to ask: (SPOILER-Y: What did I miss? Was Xavier her son? I thought she didn't have any kids. Was he some sort of con artist?)

The writing was beautiful, but the story made me angry and frustrated. It had nonsensical and confusing stuff that bothered me. So, yep: no effing idea what the point of this was. It’s plotless with nice writing. The only thing that kept me interested was my own theory-making about why the book is titled ‘audition.’

Was this review helpful?

Not what I was expecting but all the better for it. It was tense with a constant undertone of about something to happen it really kept me hooked. I liked the two character back and forth dynamic. It is well structured novel written with style. Really good concept and plot. Well worth reading

Was this review helpful?

Katie Kitamura is a underrated author. I adored her Intimacies for the sparse but precise prose and the way it captured half-tones of reserved human emotions. I was excited to be approved for the Audition ARC.

The premise is simple - two people, an older woman and a younger man, are having a meal in a restaurant. We do not yet know who they are and, more importantly, who they are to each other. The narration is unreliable, and new information is slow dripping, changing the reader's understanding of the situation. At first I assumed that the entire novel will be a masterclass in structure and dialogue writing, never leaving the restaurant and keeping changing our perspective of what is happening, and I was very excited at that prospect. Kitamura took the premise in quite a different direction.

Part I is very tense and full of a sense of threat. The reader is drawn into the uneasy relationship between the unnamed protagonist and the enigmatic Xavier. Kitamura's prose absolutely shines here, offering cutting metaphors and imagery to describe nuances of human emotions. Similarly to Intimacies, which focused on simultaneous interpretation at the UN, one of the major themes of the novel is craft - in this case, acting craft. Kitamura writes the intricacies of work with such precision. To be absolutely honest, even at this point I started finding the prose a bit suffocating and got desensitised to it. It read the way artisanal chocolate tastes after you've had a whole box in one go - when you've had too much of it, the craft of the chocolatier fades, leaving the basics of cocoa and sugar. However, I was still mesmerised by the narrative.

As Part I stops right before its climax, we are transported into a different reality and different novel. Without giving too much away, prepare to question what is and is not real. The unreliability of the narration (and the narrator) is crunched to the maximum. To me personally, that took all the wind out of the sails of the novel's greatest strength - the prose. What is the point of describing the nuances of interpersonal relationships if the relationships are not real? Intellectually, I think I understand what Kitamura was going for, making the reader ponder fiction, performance and liminality of conjuring unreality, inherent to any storytelling. If that's your sort of thing, the novel might work for you. Emotionally, I was not invested in Part II, and any sense of rising tension, or dread, or curiosity, which the narrative was trying to impose on me just bounced off.

As it is a literary, not a commercial novel, we never get any straight answers, and I personally might have been asking the wrong questions in deciding to try to figure what was actually going on. The novel reminded me, first and foremost, of The Specters of Algeria by Yeo Jung Hwang, although I think the The Spectres ended up doing something a bit more interesting. On a more commercial plain, there is something of Leave the World Behind and All's Well in Audition, although neither Rumaan Alam nor Mona Awad can offer Kitamura's prose or complexity.

Thank you, NetGalley and the publisher, for a review copy.

Was this review helpful?

Very cool concept and I had such a wonderful time reading this and figuring out who was what to each other. I love the entertainment aspect as well. Highly recommend this unique and vibrant novel.

Was this review helpful?