3.25 ⭐️

Thank you to NetGalley and Sydney Madison, and P.S. published for this e-ARC

A love story with complex characters, secrets, and traumatic childhoods.

Compared to magnolia parks, one tree hill and gossip girl. I would agree with one tree hill and gossip girl, but I’m not sure magnolia parks fits. Instead, I would say I got more maple hill series by Hannah Grace vibes. Just take hockey and make it basketball! 🏀

I love the mental health representation right from the get go and the love Ben had for Will, despite their upbringing.

I wanted more from the character development. The secret that was held onto by Ben and Will felt anticlimactic. But if it truly was such a big deal to Olivia, I would have liked to see some more groveling.

I’m also not a fan of love-at-first sight. Even still, I can buy into sometimes if it’s well explained. But then he left for two years right after? It didn’t fade after only meeting her one time?

For these reason the romance fell a bit flat for me.

There was some beautiful lines in this book about life, loss, and love that had my tearing up.

The perfect fall vibe book for anyone who wants it. It was so entertaining and so enjoyable. I highly recommend giving it a go

This was a really enjoyable read! I loved the similarities between Astor Hill and Gossip Girl and One tree hill. I’m a huge fan of slow burn romances and loved the forbidden romance aspect included in this story due to the brother’s girlfriend trope being present. The mental health rep was spot on and much appreciated. I felt like the characters were dynamic and it was interesting watching them grow and evolve throughout the book. I can’t wait to read more from this author duo. Thank you netgalley for sending me this arc in exchange for my honest review.

i am so happy I requested this book. This was such a thrilling romance book. It had twists and turns and betrayal and romance and I absolutely ate it up. Cannot wait for book 2. thank you PS Published and Netgalley!

˚୨୧⋆｡ 4 ☆

𝙩𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨:
- slow burn.
- brother’s girlfriend.
- boyfriends brother.
- mental health representation.
- he falls first.
- basketball romance.
- gilmore girls vibes.

So this cover for starters is absolutely gorgeous, it gives me strong fall vibes all over and I’m here for it.

This book generally wasn’t what I was expecting and that is a good and a bad thing. I generally weren’t expecting the toxicity between will and Olivia but as we’ve gotten into the book I generally love it more for the fact I will see more ben and Olivia scenes and the mental health representation was amazing. Sydney Maddison portrayed anxiety in her male character really well and it’s such a hard and tough thing to do as it can have a fall flat or it can be top-notch. She made the representation perfect and top-notch for me as I actually loved reading and I felt a strong connection with Ben. however with Olivia I didn’t feel such strong connection with her. I felt her character was a bit more complex and I feel like that her complexity wasn’t written about entirely such as with will and Lilly therefore it was hard to connect with her, but altogether she gives me Laurie Gilmore vibes.


Release Date- 7th February 2025.
thank you to NetGalley & ps published for gifting and allowing me to read an e-arc of this book in exchange for an honest rating and review.

This book centres around a unique blend of romance and mystery, creating a narrative that has intriguing potential, especially with the layers of suspense involving various characters. However, while the premise was promising, the writing style fell short, leaving the characters feeling shallow and, at times, and frustratingly one-dimensional. The lack of deeper characterisation means that, despite a compelling setup, it was hard to connect with or fully care about the people in this story. That said, there were still enjoyable and entertaining moments that kept me engaged.
2.5

Astor Hill by Sydeny Madison ✨️ arc review ✨️

So many emotions ran through me while reading this book. SO MANY!!!

Let's start with the FMC Olivia (Liv); I really love how this character was written because they made her super relatable. She is strong, smart, beautiful, and headstrong (in a good way). All while struggling with the very realbattle of shoving feelings that are so strong into a mental box in the corner of her mind just so she could continue moving forward. I truly admire her strength, and I also admire the amount of growth that she has over the course of this story.

Next onto the MMC (Ben); I love when authors write about mens mental health, especially since the topic *in my opinion* does not get talked about enough in this day and age. The basketball captain with everything, the looks, the skills, the wealthy family. How could he be anything but happy? What these authors do is show that even guys/boys/men can have a hard time under pressure, that sometimes it can be A LOT to handle.

The story these two characters have together is just magical to witness, from the witty banter and quick slightly sarcastic comebacks (mostly coming from Liv lol) to the hard moments and tear jerking scenes, this book will have you feeling so many feels you'll be sad when the book ends but happy you took the journey.

Side note there is spice, however, not too much (though there is plenty of tension 🫣), meaning you really get to know the characters outside of physical attraction, which i absolutely LOVE about books!!. I cannot wait for a second book!!!!!

First of all, thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for this ARC!🤎
This book gives gossip girl but set mainly at a University near Boston. Page turning drama, but with a good portrayal of the ways grief can affect someone. Some of the characters take some time to grow on you. In between the grief, the grandparents, family issues, there’s something for almost anyone to relate to. My only criticism is that there are a few times that I feel like there are too many luxury brands mentioned in a short period of time. Thankfully it only happens a few times, and other than that the brands names are thrown in here and there. If you like gossip girl, you’ll enjoy this too. Can’t wait for the next book! The ending pretty much had me in tears, so that also helps it’s rating lol

Astor Hill is a heart-wrenching romance novel anchored in the desire to overcome the past through new connections and pushing the boundaries that we create for ourselves.

It starts with a rush of collegiate parties and the society that comes with old money as we meet Olivia and her best friend, Lily. They are eager to start the next four years and woo the entire student body of Astor Hill. When Lily suddenly passes away, we flash forward two years and are reintroduced to Olivia, who has achieved most of what she sought after. Her vision board has come to life; the hot jock boyfriend, Will, writing for the paper… she is truly the embodiment of Rory Gilmore in season five of Gilmore Girls.
Enter Ben, Will’s older brother, returning from a two-year gap year, and desperately enamored by the girl he saw at a frat party before he left… who just so happens to be dating his brother.

The romance between these pages is everything; there is yearning, pining, and aching. Ben feels, to me, like an Andrew Garfield love interest; he is the book boyfriend of the month. A golden boy just so down bad for the girl he likes it's toe curling.
Olivia is so elusive and nonchalant, she is so clearly fighting her emotions about a variety of things, and Ben is determined to escape the reputation he’d crafted before he left.

There is so much in this book to unpack: the way it handles grief and the guilt Ben feels for pining after Olivia… it is so beautifully written, and there is such gorgeous prose in these pages. I genuinely fell in love with these characters and found myself reading slower as the book went on so I could stay in their world a bit longer.
I will say- it did drag in the middle for a bit, but I still wasn’t bored. It is a slow burn, and for good reason. But, by the end, I was smitten with their relationship; I was squealing into my pillow kicking my feet at their dialogue, and the vulnerability that they share is so heartwarming.
I definitely recommend picking this up, and I am eagerly awaiting the second installment!

𝘛𝘳𝘰𝘱𝘦𝘴:
✓slow burn
✓mental health rep
✓he falls first
✓new adult
✓boyfriend`s brother
✓secrets

I'll start by saying I loved the cover – it's amazing! But this isn't a light sports romance about college students, as you might think. There’s angst, intrigue, and secrets. The heroine is dealing with loss, and then she falls for her boyfriend's brother, who has anxiety. By the way, mental health rep is one of my favorite tropes, and I really liked Ben.
As for Olivia, her relationship with Will had a lot of toxicity, and I wish she’d left him sooner. I also would have loved more heartfelt moments in her friendship with Lily, as I didn’t feel much connection to her.
Anyway, this is a good debut novel! It gave me Gossip Girl vibes, so if you enjoy that show, this book is for you. I’ll be waiting for the sequel about Grant and Gen!

Thank you to NetGalley and PS Publishing for providing the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

3.5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Tropes:
- ex’s older brother
- Mental health
- Sports: basketball
- Grief

I enjoyed this book! Admittedly it’s really messy & at first I didn’t love how toxic some of the character relationships were. But the further I got into the story the more it just reminded me of how messy life can be & made it feel real.

I’m excited to see how the next book in the series will continue the friendships that seem to be blooming & creating a found family vibe

Thank you to NetGalley & PS Publishing for providing an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.

First off, love the cover. However, I don't know what I was expecting for the story but this wasn't it. I think this would be more of a high school book

Once I got into this, I couldn't stop until I was done. It was really well-paced and a proper cozy fall romance to curl up with.

Astor Hill is an Elite College full of the rich and well to-do, but that factor isn't overdone like in some books. It's a background feature rather than the main event which made the world easier to buy into.

Olivia, Ben and Will are all well-drawn characters and the story woven around them is easy to get lost in. There are twists which are a little easy to see coming but, overall, the web of lies which underpins the whole story got me so invested I just had to finish the book as quickly as I could.

It's a gorgeous romance which I will definitely read again and recommend to friends. Good for those who like Hannah Grace, Elsie Silver. There is a hint of spice, but again, it's handled well and not too much.

3.25 stars. This book was different from what I thought it was going to be. I thought it was going to be a cute sports romance with the fmc finding herself after the death of a friend.

But this book was very toxic. I hated Will. Could not stand how he treated Olivia. Once you get more into the book it explains why he did what he did but it still did not excuse his actions. Olivia was also really toxic, but it did show the struggle of not loving yourself and finding your way to that throughout that I really enjoyed.

I liked Ben, he is a great book boyfriend. I liked that the author showed his struggle with mental health and him actually bettering himself! But I will say him flirting with his brothers girlfriend was getting really messy.

Overall, I think it was a fun read and I am intrigued for the second book in this series.

This book immediately had me hooked!

The secrets, the relationships, THE DRAMA! It was so good. I truly enjoyed it.

I especially loved focus on mental health, and the importance of taking care of it. It’s not an easy topic but it was done very well.

Ultimately, I loved it! Cannot wait for more books in this series.

If you like the Magnolia Park series, you'll like this book! I'm looking forward to reading more from this author! This book is full of love, drama, and friendship, and it truly feels like you're right there with the characters.

4 stars ✩

➺ This was a very entertaining read. And I will be happy to read the next book in the series soon!

Astor Hill follows Olivia, a student at the prestigious college of the same name, where she’s navigating life alongside her best friend, Lily. But when an unexpected tragedy strikes, Olivia’s world is completely shattered as she faces the devastating loss of Lily.

On top of her grief, Olivia is stuck in a turbulent relationship with Will, her boyfriend of two years, who’s giving her serious mixed signals. Things get even more complicated when Ben, Will’s stepbrother, returns to campus after two years away, having taken time off to deal with his mental health. Ben’s reappearance stirs up all kinds of old family drama, especially since he’s been secretly harboring feelings for Olivia ever since he first laid eyes on her.

What follows is a tangle of emotions as Ben struggles to suppress his growing attraction to Olivia, while she begins to realize that being around Ben feels different—better—than her complicated relationship with Will. The more Olivia is around Ben, the more she feels like she can be herself without the pressure of being “Will’s girlfriend,” and the sparks between them become impossible to ignore. The slow burn between the two of them was a treat to watch unfold, and by the end, I was completely rooting for them.

*ੈ✩‧₊˚

Characters:
Ben: I really liked how Ben was written—his openness about mental health, the maturity with which he handled it, and how he challenged the stigma around therapy for men was such a breath of fresh air. He comes across as a guy who’s been through a lot but managed to face his problems head-on, which makes him feel like a really mature and well-rounded character. He was super sweet with Olivia and I adored the way, he made Olivia feel better whenever she needed reassurance.

Olivia: Olivia is both witty and intelligent, with a blend of confidence and vulnerability that I found really relatable and endearing. She’s strong in her own way but also has her sad moments which made her a really likeable persona. Her friendship with Lily, though, was a bit of a puzzle—it seemed deep, but there were layers of complexity that made me question how much they truly understood each other.

Will: Oh man, here we go. With all due respect, Will just wasn’t ready for this relationship, especially after everything that happened with Lily. He would’ve been better off focusing on getting his own life together rather than dragging Olivia into his mess. I get what he’s been through and how hard it must have been for him, but committing to a relationship that felt more like an attempt to fill the void left by Lily’s loss just wasn’t the right move. In the end, it not only made him feel hurt, but it also caused Olivia way too much.


Overall, I really enjoyed this book! It has its slow moments, but the character development and the way it deals with complex emotions like grief, love, and mental health really stood out.

.·:*¨༺ ༻¨*:·.


thank you netgalley and ps published for providing me with an e-arc of this book in exchange for an honest review!

I enjoyed this book! I loved the slow burn and the dynamics between the characters. The relationship between the brothers was so tense but you just couldn’t look away.

Will pissed me off throughout the book. He just had the audacity and he was such a dirty dog. Then Ben came in and we got everything. Forbidden love and lots of drama. I also loved how Olivia came into her own and made her own decisions. I wasn’t here the for the third act break up but it made sense.

I’m so excited for book 2 even though this book hasn’t come out yet! The cover is also pretty and it matches how good the story is. I can’t wait to grab the physical copy 🍂🍁

Thank you @Netgalley for this ARC

I went into this book expecting a novel about a girl who lost her best friend and a boy who was fighting his own demons and how they get together and conquer the world…. Yeah, not quite.

This was not my cup of tea at all. I’m not sure if it’s because I’ve been out of college for almost 7 years or if because this was not my college experience at all, but these characters sucked. I mean, a sink hole could have opened up under this school and I would only be slightly sad that Ben died. No one else.

Even from the first chapter I found the characters snotty. Lily, Olivia, and Will are just terrible. Almost reminded me of the show You’re The Worst because it felt like a competition for who was the worst human.

Grant and Ben were okay, but Ben had a thing for his brother’s girlfriend which doesn’t sit right with me. I know he doesn’t get along with Will but it’s still betrayal.

I suppose if drama, a college setting, and complex characters are your thing you may like this one. To me it just didn’t work.

I do hope the rest of this series pans out, but I probably won’t be continuing.

*An ARC was received from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Something that I look for in a romance, is characters that a fully fleshed out and feel real. The characters in Astor Hill felt real to me, they were messy and complex and deeply human. They were relatable and I was captivated from the very start!

Olivia is smart, beautiful and fierce. She's also drowning in grief at the loss of her closest friend. She's dating Will, the basketball captain and most popular guy at school. He's pretty bad for her and I'll admit I found myself frustrated at the way Liv let him treat her. As the story unfolds you'll understand why he is the way he is, and why they needed each other so much at such a dark part of both of their lives.

Enter.. Ben. Sure to be everyones new book boyfriend. Will's older step brother, his greatest rivial on court and the previous basketball captain before his mysterious disappearance. Ben takes a women's literature class, he goes to therapy, he talks through his feelings and he's incredibly self aware - I mean come ON! His POV chapters made me absolutely swoon. He had these epic declaration of love moments that I genuinely loved - as I said swoon! You'll want to underline/highlight it all. Oh.. and he's madly in love with his brothers girl..

This book is like if One Tree Hill and Gossip Girl had a baby.. in the best way. There's rich people drama, toxic relationships, sibling rivalry and secrets. It's the kind of romance you can binge over one weekend because you simply look away. The side characters were just as intriguing and I'm excited to go back to Astor Hill and find our their stories (I have some theories).

All in all, a very fun read. I really enjoyed the college setting, the basketball theme, the old money society vibes and just the absolute drama. There were parts of the writing I felt were a little clunky and some small spelling errors, but overall the story flowed well and was incredibly enjoyable.

3.5/5 stars. Thank you so much NetGalley and Sydney Madison for giving me the chance to read this one! x