Member Reviews
This is a well researched book about the Holocaust and the fate of some of the participants on both sides of events in the subsequent years, namely the 1950s.
Survivors of a concentration camp, Hannah and David decide that they will put the past behind them, at any cost. Unfortunately the cost for Hannah turns out to be a kind of emotional frigidity.
Meanwhile, having been a cruel Nazi camp guard during the war, Helma is keeping her secrets close to her chest in her new life in America, in an attempt to whitewash the past - not least for herself.
The story is interesting, but feels as though it lacks a certain emotional depth, which is strange given how emotional the subject matter is. I would recommend it for readers who are interested in World War II because it provides a different kind of insight into the events of that period.
The Nazi Housewife of Queens, New York was an interesting book to read, and it gave me very mixed feelings on how I should review it. Overall, the story was interesting. Hannah was a very sympathetic character who was strong in her own right. She made the most of her lift after experiencing hell during the Holocaust. I struggled with some of the decisions that she made throughout the book, but I thought that the ending made up for a lot of that. Helma was terrifying and very realistic. There were so many people who believed in the actions of the Nazis, and it was a little terrifying to read the chapters that were told from her point of view.
One of the positive aspects of the book include the amount of research that Stacy Kean obviously put into writing this story. I have read a lot of nonfiction and fictional books about the Holocaust, and it was very interesting to learn about a concentration camp that was not as well known as Auschwitz. It was also interesting to learn that the Stomping Mare was a real person who did go on to live in the United States.
I believe that one of the biggest struggles of the book is that is covers a long period of time for two women. It felt very shallow and not very detailed. I wanted to know more about the characters so that I could connect to their stories better. I wanted to know more about what happened in their lives and in the lives of their family members. I believe that the book would have been better if there had been more detail.
Overall, I would give this book a solid 3 stars. It was not the best book that I have ever read. However, it as interesting. I believe that it would be a good read for those who enjoy historical fiction and would like a change from the standard World War 2 fictional books that are out there.
*I would like to thank NetGalley and Level Best Books for giving me the chance to read and review this book. My opinion is strictly my own.*
This book presents a vivid picture of the way a person can allow their past to cripple them. When David and Hannah decided to never tell anyone, or even talk to each other, about their experiences in the concentration camps, Hannah practically locked herself away from love. This book explores her life and feelings (or lack thereof). It also explores Helma’s life and why she became the sadistic, feared guard at various camps—and how a person can delude themselves about their own innocence. I appreciated this exploration of what makes people into who they are. What I did not enjoy was the graphic descriptions of violence at the camps—although I know it was real. It is not pleasant to read about—but probably good to see at times. I also noticed a number of instances of language I don’t like. For a secular book, I found this one fairly clean, with only veiled references to marital intimacy—and one near-affair.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from NetGalley, and these are my honest thoughts about it.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
The author Stacy Kean doesn't glorify or vilify the characters, she instead presents their struggles with empathy and real depth showing us the horrors of the war didn't end when it did.
This book is a testament to Stacy Kean's careful research, thought-provoking and empathetic writing.
Given the subject of this book & the title, you know that you're entering a dark chapter in history and the fact the book is drawn from actual events can make it feel quite unsettling and rather uncomfortable.
Powerful storytelling full of raw emotions; guilt, fear, confusion, shame. Of the scars left not only on the world but individual lives too.
A sobering, emotional read that I don't think will leave me.
Proving the impossibility of outrunning your past while showing us humanity's ability to carry on despite the weight of history. A history we will never forget.
The Nazi Housewife of Queens, New York is not just a historical account, but a moving reflection on identity, morality, and the lasting impact of war.
It is tense and it is shocking but it is also deeply moving.
There are a lot of painful/uncomfortable realities to confront in this book about the lasting consequences of hatred, complicity and ideaology.
Hard to write this review but Stacy Kean did such a wonderful job writing this.
Thank you to NetGalley, Level Best Books and Stacy Kean for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
I wanted so much more from this book. There was too much tell and not enough show in the writing. I did not enjoy the characterization of the Nazi guard. I never want to read fiction about Nazis that is apologetic or dismissive of what they did, but I wanted more depth in the character. She really just came across as a shallow, pathetic human incapable of looking beyond her own petty wants. Perhaps that was true of some of the Nazi perpetrators, but I wanted more in a fictional story.
The Nazi Housewife of Queens, New York: a novel” by Stacy Kean, is a historical women’s-fiction about Helma, a vicious female Nazi camp guard turned NY Housewife, and Hannah, a holocaust survivor who lost her entire family, later seeking justice as an adult.
The title is shocking and jarring and I think the author intended it as so, just as the NY Times paper shocked the world with a similar headline.
This historical women’s fiction story is told over six decades, in dual POV of a Nazi camp guard and of a holocaust survivor — an intriguing mixed story-world that intersected several times. Over the course of the book, the reader experiences the fear and shock of what Hannah endured, and admittedly it’s tough at times to read. The reader witnesses Helma’s hatred of Jewish people, stoked by Hitler, and her willingness to “do her job” to feel accepted and worthy by her father and country.
I really felt for Hannah. Seeing her growth over several decades was a unique experience. I liked seeing her life before she went into hiding, before the light of the world dimmed and her family (like many others) were caught up in an unimaginable nightmare. Her perspective of the atrocities that happened at the camp was extremely disturbing, especially against Helma’s indifferent POV at the same time. The juxtaposition was eye-opening and there were several frightening parallels to current society, not limited to the “lying press” (“fake news”) and vile hatred of a group/groups stoked by a leader. With many countries in conflict across the globe, it’s worrisome to think that history could repeat itself. Stacy Kean reminds the reader to never forget, nor become complacent.
Later, Hannah is incredibly brave and a bit of an amateur sleuth in her search for justice, when once again, her and Helma cross paths, leading the reader on a rollercoaster journey of highs and lows. The conclusion was extremely satisfying — even though it made my heart race!
Overall, I found the story to be well-researched and thought-provoking. The book is authentic in its emotional rawness, evoking feelings of sorrow and empathy. This book touches on extremely sensitive subject matter but can still be a powerful resource as a teaching tool.
5 stars.
MANY THANKS to Netgalley and the Author
Thoughtful variation on the usual WWII Nazi trope and the fact that it is loosely based on a true story added to the allure.
I appreciated the dual narration and clear delineation of who's chapter it was and the time frame covered. Furthermore, the realistic portrayal of Hannah's family life added to the validity. In the moment, I found both husbands almost too good to be true, especially Helma's American GI, but learning this was based on fact it softened my views on the husbands to some degree.
I am compelled to add a few lines about the writing quality/style - simplistic? Choppy? I struggle to find the right adjectives but something was "off" and I found myself going back and re-reading every now and again. The repeated use of the nickname Stomping Mare got to be annoying, at some point I found myself thinking "I get it, enough." More than the content, I think the writing makes this a 2.5 rounded to 3 star read.
The story spanned many decades and ultimately closed the loops related to both Hannah and Helma - what are the chances that they would end up just blocks apart in Queens! It was enlightening to be shown a glimpse into how some people did/still justify what was done in the camps and then have these glimpses countered by the Jewish perspective.
I had to read this book when I saw the cover. It is based on a true story and I couldn’t believe that a real Nazi lived in Queens. I don’t know if that shocked me or the fact that she wasn’t sorry about anything she did. This is based on a true story.
Many thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for a complimentary copy of the book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
I enjoyed all the twists and turns of this story. It’s based on a true story of two women in America after WWII. And oh what a story they have! Great read.
I really enjoyed the beginning of this book but this is a DNF for me.
The chapters are very long & cover a HUGE time period - in every single chapter there are many time jumps which is fine but it’s very randomly placed. I feel it could have been better to either make it a new chapter or do a page break. In chapter 12 alone within 3 pages there’s “over the next few months” “a few months in” and “over the next few months” again. There is no variety of language used.
The writing and vocabulary is extremely simple to the point I thought it’s written for children but then the content & tragedy within the book is very explicit that is doesn’t match up with the writing style. Chapter 8 where it says “Helma you don’t look very good.” this segment feels like I’m reading a child’s work at school.
Such a shame as it started out well and I love historical fiction but a real disappointment.
Hannah, a Jewish Holocaust survivor living with her husband and children in Queens, sees news article about a former female Nazi concentration camp guard who is also living in Queens. This is the guard who was exceptionally cruel and killed Hannah's older sister in the camp. The book then goes back in time to the early decades of the 20th century and alternates between the stories of Hannah and the guard, Helma. Once it becomes known that Helma is living in the US, Hannah is persuaded to testify against her in an extradition trial. This decision causes a rift between her and her husband, also a survivor, who is determined to keep the past in the past and not let it intrude on their lives in the US.
This novel covers a lot of ground, moving through most of the 20th century but focusing a lot on the trial in the US and then later in Germany. As such, most of the book reads almost like a lengthy magazine feature instead of a novel. The writing isn't the book's overall strength. It's the story that is most engaging, especially since it's based on a real Nazi housewife found living in the US in the 1960s.
It was a challenge to fill in Helma's story, explaining why she turned out as she did, but not making her a sympathetic character. The author succeeds in this regard.
I recommend the book based on the strength of the story, which is compelling.
I was provided an ARC by the publisher via NetGalley.
This is a disturbing novel, based on a real story about two women. One is a young Jewish girl whose family is obliterated by the Nazis in a concentration camp and the other, a full blown believer, whose cruelty and sadism set her apart from all the other cruelty and sadism that was so rampant. The first part of the book covers the early years leading up to and including the war. That Hannah survived is in itself a miracle. So few did but little did she expect to discover was her tormentor and the murderer of her beloved sister was blithely living the good life in her own neighbourhood in New York. It beggared belief that such a travesty could occur after all the horror but when the light is shone on The Stomping Mare, Hannah has a chance to obtain some small degree of justice.
The book covers the first trial which leads to the deportation back to Germany where she will stand trial for war crimes. Despite the hardships, Hannah has the courage to come forward and testify with other survivors. At no time throughout the book does Helma, the guard, ever consider anything she has done to be wrong nor does accept any blame. She would do it again in a heartbeat and still harbours the same evil beliefs that permeated her life.
Hannah travels to Germany to testify with other friends and survivors. She is a most admirable and strong woman but she is haunted by Helma. And it is not until the end of the book when she sees her nemesis for what she has become that Hannah finally is free. I would defy the reader to not feel admiration for the journey Hannah has taken- and satisfaction that in the end, she triumphed. Five purrs and two paws up.
The Nazi Housewife of Queens, New York is loosely based on a real female prison guard from a women's concentration camp, and I thought it brought something new to the Holocaust literature genre. Initially I had a bit of a tough time getting through the book as I felt like the writing style was somewhat simplistic, and I had a really tough time with Helma's background. It almost seemed as if the author was excusing her cold-heartedness by giving her such an awful father and meek mother to explain how she could become such a monster. I did feel that Hannah was a well-drawn character, although I think the author glossed over the heartache it must have caused her to have such a strained relationship with her daughter. I thought the author did an excellent job portraying the sometimes hidden and often overt anti-Semitism expressed by many Americans in the decades covered in this novel including the group the Silent Help, probably unknown to many readers. I also thought her portrayal of the way many Holocaust survivors chose to bury the past while at the same time were unable to put it completely behind them in the form of creating stockpiles of food and valuables or other PTSD behaviors was highly true to life. The latter parts of the book were highly moving, and I felt the writing evolved as the book progressed. This would make an excellent book for a book group with many weighty topics to discuss.
The premise of this one was intriguing; a Holocaust survivor discovers that the concentration camp guard that murdered her sister is alive, well, and living close by in Queens, New York. It becomes her life goal to make sure that the “Stomping Mare” is punished for her war crimes, after decades of the woman living a charmed life in America.
I was disappointed in the quality of this novel. The writing was choppy, there were endless run-on sentences, and many grammar and spelling mistakes. As well, the story line was difficult to follow, because single paragraphs sometimes covered periods of years of time passing, with little explanation.
*I received a digital copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are strictly my own.*
As a Jewish reader, it is only very recently that I've been able to get past my own emotions and carefully delve into Holocaust historical fiction. I'm very leery of anything that tries to exploit the Holocaust, of course. The title and cover of this book immediately caught my attention, as it is meant to do. Reading that it was based on "actual" events, I thought it would be worth reading. I should have paid more attention to the buzz words like "astonishing" and the use of "shocking" not once, but twice in the description.
Reading it was one of the most horrifying experiences I've ever had with a book. But as I continued reading and reached the end of the book, I started to wonder who the author is and why she is telling this story. Is it her story to tell? It seems not. She has simply exploited a discovery of a Jewish reporter and capitalized on that. Why did she choose to write about it?
Many will be intrigued by the cover and the title. And, let's face it. We all have a voyeuristic pull towards tragedy porn. For those readers, this will certainly be a shocking revelation and introduction to the Holocaust. We Jewish readers may have a different response. It hurts. It actually hurts.
“The Nazi Housewife of Queens, New York” is a debut historical fiction novel by Stacy Kean. This book is inspired by true life events. This book is told by two people in alternating timelines. We meet Helma, the eventual prison guard, as her upbringing, time as a guard in WWII, migration to the US, and eventual trials. My one complaint about Helma’s depiction is that for a long time, she appears very flat and one-dimensional. As the story progresses past WWII and Helma’s first imprisonment, while her burning anger is simmering below the surface, she becomes a slightly softer person, but why or how seemed missing (was it because she found someone who loved her - maybe?). But Ms. Kean makes it very clear that when Helma is uncovered as a former Nazi guard that people are shocked - and it’s understandable, though from the title the reader knows Helma will be discovered and put on trial. The other timeline follows Hannah - a woman who ends up testifying against Helma after the atrocities she witnessed. Hannah’s story is more moving with greater depth - making me wonder if Hannah’s story was more fictional (there wasn’t an Author’s Note, so I don’t know if Hannah was also based upon someone or a collection of people). I thought that Ms. Kean did a great job with Hannah’s life once in the US - the dependency upon pills (so often prescribed for nerves back then), the hiding of the horrors she and her husband experienced yet how Hannah was haunted by them, and even Hannah’s awkwardness with motherhood. I found the pacing of this book to be a bit slow and I really wish there had been an Author’s Note with information. But, in the end, I think if a reader wants a well researched book about WWII from both the perspective of a guard and a prisoner, this book does a good job presenting both sides.
The Nazi Housewife of Queens, New York by Stacy Kean transports readers to a tumultuous era in world history, telling the life story of two women whose lives first intersected in a Jewish concentration camp. Kean superbly blends historical facts with fictional storytelling. Each chapter explores a period in the lives of Hannah and Helma from their point of view.
I confess being attracted to the book because of the vintage style book cover, not understanding that there was a real Nazi Housewife in Queens New York (My own state). Unfortunately, I am sure that there were more.
This book is a treat for fans of historical fiction and World War II enthusiasts who relish exploring the hidden stories of the past. Trigger warning the book contains graphic violence and torture against humanity.
Hannah's time in the Nazi concentration camp is filled with unimaginable hardships and loss; the constant threat of violence, abject conditions, and the pervasive atmosphere of fear formed Hannah's grim reality. Her mother, father and sister are sent to the gas chamber upon arrival at the camp. One of her sisters survived about a year, only to be stomped to death by Helma, the Nazi prison guard.
As the narrative unfolds, Hannah's life experience is further compounded by the devastating loss of her family in the concentration camps. She marries a wonder man, has children and tries her best to live a wonderful life in America. Why does it not make her happy? Why can’t the past be the past like her husband says?
Hannah's mental health struggles are key throughout the book. She struggles in most social situations, wanting the past to be the past, and self-medicates with nicotine and cigarettes. You cannot blame her. The emotional scars from the concentration camps followed her throughout her life. The behavior of hoarding food in the basement confounds her children who do not know she was a survivor. Honestly, it all breaks my heart.
Helma's journey to becoming a Nazi prison guard at a concentration camp was shaped by the turbulent socio-political climate of the time and her personal circumstances. Her father dominated her mother and beat her often.
The rise of the Nazi regime presented a chance for women like Helma to secure employment and financial stability, albeit in one of the most heinous capacities. Indoctrination played a crucial role, as the pervasive Nazi propaganda infiltrated every aspect of life, painting the regime's actions as a duty to the nation. Helma, like many, was swept up in the nationalistic fervor and the promise of belonging to a cause larger than herself. She finally fit in.
As Helma took up the uniform, and never looked back. Helma never took responsibility for any of her actions.
In the book, the narratives of Hannah and Helma unfold through alternating chapters that vividly depict each woman's life journey and the historical context surrounding them. The intertwining of their stories is cleverly constructed, allowing readers to witness the stark contrasts of their experiences and choices. Hannah's life is one of survival and rediscovery in the aftermath of unimaginable loss, while Helma's journey reflects a descent into complicity and moral denial.
Who Should or Should Not Read the Book? If you are a fan of historical fiction or have an interest in the nuanced narratives of World War II, this novel should be on your reading list. However, if you prefer light-hearted reads or avoid books with themes of violence and profound sadness, this might not be for you.
I really loved reading this book. It was fast paced but, yet so sad. I recommend this book to anyone but have the tissues ready. And, unfortunately, it did not completely answer my question that I always have when reading books about survivors of the Holocaust; why did this happen?
How does it all turn out? If you dare to read the book, you will find out.
Thank you to Netgalley and Level Best Books for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for a fair and honest review. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Very touchy, controversial undertones, but such a good story line. It is a topic that I am sure was fairly common back in those times though. The fact that it is based on a true story is even more crazy.
3.5 ⭐ rounded up
This story is inspired by a Queen’s housewife whose notorious past as a Nazi camp guard, the Stomping Mare, was discovered and action was eventually taken to have her extradited and face trial in Germany.
Shocking is a word I’d use to describe this story. Author Stacy Kean has harnessed this emotion to get our attention focused on the atrocities of the Holocaust and the unforeseen outcomes of Operation Paperclip.
Buckle up, Helma Braun’s days are numbered. Justice will be served.
I was gifted this copy by Level Best Books and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.
This was a really well done historical mystery genre, it had that overall feel that I was looking for and enjoyed the time-period being used. The plot has that element that I was looking for and was glad it worked overall. Stacy Kean wrote this perfectly and am excited for more like this.