Best Mistake Ever by Christy McKellen presents a classic romantic comedy setup with a charming twist, focusing on the twin switch trope. Beatrice Donovan’s decision to temporarily fill her twin sister Delilah’s shoes in a hotel management role leads to a series of entertaining and romantic entanglements. The premise of Bea navigating a new professional environment while pretending to be her sister, and simultaneously dealing with the attractive yet grumpy ex-rockstar boss, Jonah, provides a strong foundation for the narrative.

The development of the characters, particularly the dynamic between Bea and Jonah, is a key strength of the novel. Bea’s determination to maintain professionalism while grappling with her growing feelings for Jonah adds a layer of relatable conflict. The chemistry between the two is palpable, and their interactions are infused with witty banter and genuine emotional connection. The hotel setting, along with the various events and challenges Bea faces, provides an engaging backdrop for their budding relationship.

The combination of the twin switch trope, the workplace setting, and the grumpy sunshine dynamic creates a delightful and entertaining story. While some plot points might be predictable to genre enthusiasts, the charming characters and the enjoyable romantic development make this book a satisfying read for those seeking a sweet and lighthearted escape.

I have to admit, the twins’ dynamic is a make-or-break theme for me—but I still found the book fun and engaging. In my opinion, the story’s premise, where a bitter divorce at age ten splits the sisters between two very different worlds, is both intriguing and well-executed. Bea ends up with her formidable, no-nonsense workhorse father, while Dee is raised by her free-spirited mother.

When Dee hurts her ankle and convinces Bea to fill in as the hotel’s events manager, the plot really kicks into gear. I appreciated how Bea’s transformation—especially having to cut her long hair to convincingly pass as Dee—symbolizes the striking contrast between the two sisters. It left me forming a clear opinion: Bea seems like a bit of a pushover compared to Dee, who appears to play helpless to get her way. Meanwhile, Jonah, a former rockstar determined to prove himself, adds an interesting twist to the narrative with his own set of challenges.

Overall, while I have mixed feelings about the twins’ setup, the book delivered a clever mix of humor, drama, and family dynamics that kept me turning the pages.

Thank you to NetGalley for this free advanced copy. I am leaving this review voluntarily

Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the e-ARC of this title to read and review. I love a good unhinged premise to hook me into a book, so adult identical twins swapping places in the workforce and one of them starting up an office romance is an instant sign-me-up-for-the-chaos! This started off really great, when it was all about that - it felt like a plot that twin sisters might have dreamt up in elementary school, and instantly got found out for. It was fun to see the sisters Bea and Dee's different personalities come to light through the job, because they're so opposite about their interests and qualifications. And the writing is really engaging and fast-paced, with not a lot of other plot distractions competing for attention.

But somewhere along the way, this story really went off the deep end for me. Maybe mild spoilers ahead as I describe, though I won't be too specific! <spoiler> This did not feel like a forbidden workplace romance where there's a power imbalance so both leads are trying to resist their feelings -no. In this case, the boss Jonah was already weirdly close to that line with one sister in the beginning, and got super invested in the other way too quickly. It actually wasn't predatory, but it *felt* like that, because he was so intense with Bea, instantly trauma dumping on her about his family issues, his ex, how he's living in the shadows of his dad's fame and fighting off groupies... the only thing is that Bea actually loved this and felt like it was Jonah really opening up to her and being honest and showing his vulnerabilities. I'm glad she was into it, because I sure wasn't sold! He didn't bring up his ex in a wounded way, to show readers his backstory and understand his reservations to finding love again- he was obsessively bringing her up in the way Angry Men do, in almost the This Is Why You Can't Trust Women way, and no! thanks! as far as that's concerned. Joanh was also sexually aggressive in a way that wasn't hot, it was like -- vindictive and retaliative? And I cannot imagine starting any kind of relationship out on that foot OR continuing on with it and pretending it was 1) okay and 2) justified! </spoiler>

I do like author Christy McKellen's overall writing style and have other books from her to check out next, so I hope this is just a major dislike for Jonah and how he was presented that kept me for being fully invested here!

Best Mistake Ever is a cute, light-hearted read following the lives of twin sisters who make the decision to swap places!

Throughout this, they learn a lot about themselves, and each other too. All in all, it was a fun read.

*Thank you to Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this book in return for my honest review.*

I enjoyed the beginning of this book, but found it quite difficult to get into as it all felt very unrealistic and rushed to me which put me off. I did finish the read and didn’t hate it, but equally wasn’t desperate to finish and finding it hard to put down!

This book started out well and I liked the premise - Bea stepping in for her twin sister at her job. Things were going well. Bea was getting close with her sister's boss. But then I felt like it went off the rails. This progressed more quickly than I thought was realistic. I also felt the characters make unrealistic choices. But - if you like a light, fluffy romance without a lot of depth, this may be for you.

This was really cute. I liked the plot - this is definitely my first romance read wherein the twins switch places so I thought that was a fun concept.

The thing that I didn’t like as much was the storyline. I didn’t mind that it was fast-paced as I’ve read romance books that were the same. However, this was fast-paced in a way that it all felt so rushed, but at the same time nothing really happened in that timeline - basically, there was very little going on but it all happened so quickly.

For the characters, I wasn’t a fan of anyone. They all had their flaws, and unfortunately, I couldn’t really connect with anyone because they were just frustrating for me. I do like the pairing between Beatrice and Jonah, but I’m not a fan of them individually.

Overall, this was just a lighthearted read for me; something to pass the time. Given that I finished this in only a couple of hours, I’d say it was an easy read.

Thank you to the author, publisher, and NetGalley for allowing me to share my honest review on this ARC.

For some reason, I just couldn't get into this book. I tried really really hard, but I just could not push through so I have to dnf at about 15%. This wasn't on the book, it was most likely a not in the right mindset when I tried to read it kind of thing. I am looking forward to buying this book soon though and reading it then.

Overall this book was cute but in the end I didn’t think the couple would actually last. Not my favorite but a great palette cleanser.

This book was so funny. When twin sisters need to switch places, they find out what they really do want, uncover some unfortunate personal truths, and come out the way that life was supposed to be -- not at all what they thought it'd look like. Nothing wildly new but the mix of tropes were a bit different so it kept it light and entertaining. I kind of want a companion book of the sister and business partner and their trip abroad. There seems like there'd be quite the story there too!

#netgalley
#arc
#bestmistakeever

Best Mistake Ever by Christy McKellen is a story about identical twins who have different personalities. one responsible, namely Bea, and the other irresponsible, whose name is Dee. Dee is about to lose yet another job, and Bea decides to step in to help. That's where she meets Jonah, a very strict but handsome boss, who is undergoing his own personal problems and is also under pressure to make this hotel business work. Bea, unlike Dee, is very good at her job, and now she also feels attached not only to the job but also to her boss, and the feeling is mutual since her boss is starting to feel the same. But then Bea knows that that is a mistake she's not ready to make, although the feelings within her are stronger than her reasoning. To find out what will happen in the end, read this book Best Mistake Ever by Christy McKellen.

I like characters in the book; they seem easy to relate with. The author's writing style is also very good; it is simple and direct. Additionally, I like the consistency between the chapters, there are no gaps, hence the story has a smooth flow.

In my opinion, the theme of the book does not fit very well.

I rate this book Best Mistake Ever by Christy McKellen 5 out of 5 stars. The plot is captivating, with the twists and turns taking the book to another level.

I recommend the book to readers who love romance books, with a great deal of twists and turns, not to mention, the intriguing story the author has put together.

Best Mistake Ever is a workplace romance with elements of deception. Bea has to switch places with her twin sister Dee to help her keep her job, but the boss Jonah is a complication. I liked the story and read it super fast. There is an inevitable complication but doesnt drag on too long and everything gets resolved appropriately. I think I am more interested though in the story hinted at on the side with Dee which sounds like will involve fake dating, travel and enemies to lovers.

I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

It took me a few chapters to get into this book, but it ended up being a really fun book!

* I want to start by thanking the author and publisher for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book. Cute!

"Best Mistake Ever" is a witty and flirtatious romance book that traces Beatrice Donovan who takes on the role of her identical twin Delilah and runs a fading boutique hotel. What was a straightforward scheme very soon becomes unruly when Beatrice finds herself at odds with Jonah, owner of the brooding ex-rockstar hotel. As Beatrice attempts to fly low and remain professional, she uncovers the actual man behind Jonah's grouchy exterior, which results in unforeseen sparks and a possible romance.

Christy McKellen is great at developing likable and lovable characters. Beatrice is a feisty and clever heroine who will do anything for her sister. Jonah is a grumpy but lovable former rockstar with a chip on his shoulder. Both characters change a lot throughout the book, with Beatrice discovering her purpose in life and Jonah learning to trust and open up again.

Christy McKellen's writing is clear and readable, so the book is a fast and pleasant read. The dialogue is crisp and realistic, and the chemistry between the characters is enhanced by it. The setting of the boutique hotel and the eccentric festival is seamlessly woven into the story by the author, making the atmosphere of the book feel festive and quaint.

The novella deals with issues of love, self-discovery, and the value of family. It shows how at times the greatest errors can result in unintended happiness and development. The narrative also points to the significance of taking risks and embracing new ventures.

Christy McKellen uses several literary devices to heighten the story, such as using dual POV narration, whereby readers are able to learn more about both Beatrice and Jonah. The trope of mistaken identity and the grumpy-meets-sunshine dynamic provide an entertaining and amusing twist to the narrative.

The novella's pacing is well-timed, with an increasing development of romance and emotional complexity. The organization is strong, with an evident progression towards a conclusive resolution. The readability is strong, which is an easy and entertaining read for readers of holiday and contemporary romance.

"Best Mistake Ever" is a charming and humorous romance novel that provides an entire and fulfilling story. Its engaging characters, smart dialogue, and festive cheer are ideal for a cold winter's night. Though the novella has a few weaknesses, such as a bit of hurried endings, these issues are dwarfed by the strengths of the work. I would suggest this novel to anyone searching for an amusing and playful romance with a bit of holiday enchantment.

Although it was a bit rough in beginning, the story progressed very well. I would’ve liked less dialogue and more “showing” of actions, it was an okay book. It’s dual pov and sometimes it can be hard to pull that off, this book does an okay job at it,

~3.5~

A fun, quick read with a little spice and a lot of tension!

It's twin swap with forced proximity and grumpy/sunshine characters. Plus double-POV!

Thank you for the ARC!!

Also, I NEED to know what happened on that trip to Greece...just saying.

(Free ARC from NetGalley and Boldwood Books that I chose to review after reading - Cross-posted on Goodreads on February 13th)

Signing off,
B.

This book was alright. It didn't sweep me away, but it did make me smile, and leave me with a good feeling.

I've read the "Rockstar & normal person" trope many times, and this is so similar. If that's your jam, definitely read this book.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

In this funny and spicy new romance novel, readers meet Beatrice Donovan whose love and loyalty to her identical twin sister gets her in over her head. Taking on Delilah’s hotel management job when her sister is out injured -- and impersonating her to her boss Jonah -- Bea has to keep a low profile, not get fired, and not make a move on the ex-rock star boss. However, Bea and Jonah’s time working together and Delilah’s schedule changes might just keep the two of them on the job for too long. With a charming English countryside setting and a lot of tropes to get Bea and Jonah interacting with each other, readers will love the spice, charm, and romance present throughout this novel, especially with its funny catalyst. The characters are the star of the novel, and Bea and Jonah alternate narrating the chapters so readers get a chance to see what they are thinking as the story and mutual attraction unfolds. With its funny plot and excellent character chemistry, this is a great summer or holiday read that romance fans will love, and McKellan has once again created a fascinating new story populated with brilliant characters and circumstances that readers will love.

ARC review - all views are my own and I have not been compensated for this review. Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for providing the e-Arc in exchange for this review.

“Beatrice Donovan would do anything for her identical twin sister. Including stepping into her hotel management job temporarily and pretending to be her - she’s desperate. What could go wrong?”

I want to start my review by acknowledging that I may not be the target audience for this story; I tend to like my characters more on the morally-grey side than cinnamon-sweet and the enemies-to-lovers trope has me in a chokehold (at least for the foreseeable!).

That being said, I am so glad I read this book! My first foray into Christy McKellen’s work was enjoyable - sweet but not saccharine, with the right amount of “believability” in the plot for the reader to see how this could actually happen, without it being predictable. There are a couple of things which, if they happened in reality, would be found out straight away, such as Bea Dee’s story about a student hairdresser messing her hair up so needing a wig. However this doesn’t detract from the plot or the readers’ enjoyment.

I will preface the rest of my review with this: if you are expecting a high-stakes, intense romance with tonnes of yearning and toe-curling spice, this won’t be the book for you. That’s not what this book is for, in my opinion, but I think this story - a beach-read romance to thumb through for a fun time - is still worth a read. With that, here is what I did and didn’t enjoy about the book.

What I enjoyed:

The story being set in the UK was an unexpected and very pleasant surprise.

I was invested in Bea’s story, possibly because I related to her quite a lot: she was the academic to Dee’s creative, the responsible to Dee’s carefree, and as an older sister who was labelled the “mature” one, she resonated with me. Through this perspective, seeing her thrive in - and eventually take over - Dee’s job was interesting because to everybody else she would be changing her life not for the better but to her detriment, despite having more fun there than in her safe, but boring, startup. Seeing her accept this and still choose her happiness was awesome.

There was a “third act breakup” (which I hate) BUT it was short, the reasons behind it made sense and the characters discussed their feelings afterwards which I think isn’t seen enough in these kinds of stories and I appreciated. I also don’t think there would have been a way to avoid it in this story given Bea’s deception over Jonah as to her identity.

The relationship between Dee and Jem, Bea’s best friend and start-up partner, was explained rather than explored and then they had their own adventures off-page. I would be interested in their story, particularly as the tidbits indicate an enemies-to-lovers, forced proximity situation (which I will eat up for sure). Could a sequel be in the works?

I wouldn’t say I “disliked” any of this story, however there were some things I would change if I had to think about it. For me, the instant love trope isn’t exciting and even though the romance between Bea and Jonah isn’t instantaneous (mostly because he believes she is Dee), it’s hard for me to believe they could fall in love so deeply with each other after a week.

I made one other note during my reading during one of Jonah’s chapters: “Jonah says “I won’t have it, this obsession with appearance” but a page ago he was ogling her and fancied how she looked? Just admit she is peng!”. I still stand by this note but this is a minor and likely very personal thought so may bother nobody else!

Overall, I enjoyed this book more than I thought I would and, whilst it was my first experience with Christy’s work, it won’t be my last.