this book was powerful and beautiful. sad and horrible but wonderful and hopeful all at once.
i was emotional both from reading the words on the page and also to later thoughts that followed me around even when the book wasnt in my hand. it makes you feel so much for our gay fellow humans. what they had to face. STILL sadly face. and in certain communities this can be made ever harder. but certainly in the 1980s this life for them must often have seemed impossible and worse horrific to get through.
our two characters are very different but ultimately the same. because they both want and feel love. and both arent allowed it from the very people around them.
working together and then living together in the shop above they find their sanctuary both in place and each other. when the world threatens this is where they seek refuge, hope and healing.
this book felt like i was reading a poem. it flowed and gracefully floated me over the words,relationship and pages.
i had every emotion going through. surprisingly alot of rage found its place in my heart. the injustice of it all didnt sit well with me. for those suffering then and also how lots still do to this day.
how so many things have moved on but achingly how much hasnt. and even worse where in todays world a new darker set of thinking and behaviors seem to be at play.
to think people had to hide themselves and or their love in dark places feel terrible. sometimes not living it at all. and what this does to ones character,sense of self and even their ability to survive just feels awful for all involved.
i thoroughly enjoyed this tender book.

A Room Above a Shop by Anthony Shapland
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4.25 stars
Publication date: 13th March 2025

Thank you to Granta and Netgalley for providing me with an e-copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

When two quiet men form a tentative connection neither knows where it might lead. M has inherited his family's ironmongery business and B is younger by eleven years and can see no future in the place where he has grown up, but when M offers him a job and lodgings, he accepts.

This was so beautiful; Shapland’s writing is very poetic and evocative, and this was such an intimate and quiet love story. I loved seeing the progression of B and M’s relationship through little slices of their lives together, from the awkwardness of their first interaction to their familiar, mundane intimacies in the small, quiet space they created for themselves in the room above M’s shop. This is not a story without its heartbreak, though, taking place in a time of deep societal prejudices against gay men, and the real danger they could be in if discovered, and the looming threat of the AIDS epidemic.
And, without giving spoilers, this is also a story that went exactly in the direction I expected it to, and fervently hoped it wouldn't.

Rating: 3.0/5, good
Publication Date: 25/03/2025
Thank you, Anthony Shapland and Granta Publications, for the digital copy via NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion.

A Room Above a Shop is an intimate, poignant, and atmospheric short novel from a new poetic voice. With quiet intensity and a lyrical style, this slim volume carries the weight of yearning and repression lived by many queer individuals. Anthony Shapland's writing oozes lyricism, and every word is carefully crafted and woven into an exploration—almost voyeuristical—of a sense of longing, identity, and societal prejudices set against the backdrop of Section 28, the age of consent debate, and the AIDS crisis in Wales.

The story follows B, a young adult struggling with his sexual identity, future, religion, and a newfound desire for M, an older—by eleven years—divorced shopkeeper grappling with the reciprocity of his feelings. Through snippets, Shapland recounts the internalized shame and secrecy that both men must endure. M has inherited his family's ironmongery business and soon offers B a job and a room. B accepts. With time, the room above the shop becomes a sanctuary, a place where they can escape the judgmental eyes of the village. "The first. It's a world only they know. The place they have for each other. A refuge, a hide." Inevitably, this refuge is not entirely safe, and societal prejudices eventually seep in. "Men like that are a menace. Buggers. Keep children safe, boys away." The author skillfully portrays the delicate balance between their love and the ever-present dread of discovery by the suspicious, prejudiced, and quietly violent small-town inhabitants.

B is a sensitive and artistic soul, yearning for acceptance but struggling to reconcile his desires with his religious upbringing. M, on the other hand, carries the weight of a past marriage, an 'absent' daughter and a quiet acceptance of his place in the community, finding unexpected happiness in B. Shapland's prose is poetic and evocative—and often convoluted—which detracted from my overall enjoyment. The description of the landscape as "lowland left to sour. Compacted new-build clay, a brownfield slicked in frost" creates a sense of both beauty and decay. While I enjoyed the lyrical prose and the exploration of themes, the pacing felt somewhat slow at times due to its occasionally convoluted prose, which might not appeal to many.

A Room Above a Shop is a tender and resonant love story told in a beautiful, poetic narrative. It is a powerful debut to be read, re-read, and savoured. However, the ever-present lyricism and occasionally convoluted prose may not work to many. Readers who appreciate lyrical writing and are drawn to character-driven stories exploring themes of love, identity, and social prejudice will likely find this book rewarding.

Set in a small Welsh town in the late 1980s, *A Room Above a Shop* follows the relationship between M and B, two men living in a world where their love must remain hidden. M, older and rooted in his family's ironmongery business, offers B both a job and a place to stay, leading them to share a quiet life in a single room above the shop. But in a time of deep societal prejudice, their relationship is built on careful concealment—stolen glances, fleeting touches, and unspoken words. The outside world is kept at bay, their universe shrinking to the shop, their room, and the nearby hill they visit together.

This is a beautiful yet heartbreaking novel. It captures the weight of secrecy and the quiet tragedies of a love that can never fully exist in the open. The writing is deeply lyrical, almost dreamlike, often obscuring details in a way that mirrors the characters' own hidden existence. At times, I found it a little too abstract, losing track of which character’s perspective I was following. But overall, it was an emotional, contemplative read. A poignant, poetic novel—4 stars.

Set in the late 1980s, M & B, two men in a small Welsh town are courting. It is secretive and cautious. Both men understand the societal rules and so if discovered, will face a response from their families and the township, likely to consist of prejudice, fear, religious backlash and scorn. It is a world that doesn't understand them. But long before the relationship starts, they need to break down each others barriers and apprehension.

The story carefully follows their relationship, skirting with the challenges faced with a secret relationship: how do you integrate family, what does discovery mean and the deep anxiety of the looming AIDs crisis.

The slowly unfurling and beautiful prose in this book is magical. Every sentence is poignant. Hope, sorrow, and love are draped over each page. I felt so much reading this book, pulled into the joys of possible love and that amazing connection when you find a soulmate, to the terror of being discovered and having everything that has been so carefully constructed, fall like a pack of cards.

A beautiful work, raw and compelling, but also loving and tender. A book to immerse yourself in. I thoroughly loved it.

Thank you so much to #NetGalley and to Granta Books for allowing me to read an advanced copy. I will be keeping an eye out for anything by this amazing author!

(Note: I will add another social link closer to the publish date)

Beautiful, intimate and demonstrating deep emotion through the detail of tiny events, A Room Above a Shop is a superb debut novel. It’s admirably short, and paints its picture of small village / town Welsh life in the 80s with limited context but with more than enough to bring M & B’s closeted existence to life. I read in a single sitting, pausing only to reflect on some of the beautiful phrasing. Best debut I’ve read in a while

This book is really something special The prose is so beautiful and there were many moments where a sentence or paragraph would stop me in my tracks and demand to be reread. This book really captures so many of the small intimacies that make up a relationship while also wrestling with the cost of hiding and shame.

I would recommend finishing this in one or two sittings to really feel the full impact of what Shapland is doing here. It is possible that I spent too long dipping in and out and because of this, at times, I found it difficult to fully land in time and place due to the vignette style storytelling used throughout.

A really beautiful story and one I suspect will stay with me for a while.

Anthony Shapland's *A Room Above a Shop* is a poignant and intimate novel set in a small Welsh town during the late 1980s. It follows a secret love affair between two men, unfolding against the backdrop of societal prejudice and the looming AIDS crisis. Shapland’s writing is lyrical and atmospheric, capturing the quiet moments of desire, fear, and longing with great sensitivity. The novel offers a raw yet beautifully crafted glimpse into working-class queer life, making it both a powerful reflection on a difficult era and a deeply personal story of love and survival.

The writing was very dreamlike throughout, I felt as if I was reading someones inner thoughts. While I enjoyed this at the start, it made it difficult to connect with the characters and what was happening. We got a glimpse into their lives, one that was full of sadness and pain, and I wish there was a little more focus on the plot and characters rather than the prose. Beautiful writing but lacking a little elsewhere.

Who doesn't love picking up a book and immediately recognizing it as something special? I read this short, powerful book in a single sitting and will undoubtedly read it again. It's the story of two men and their furtive relationship, told over several years and set in a village in South Wales. The writing is just so beautiful - a uniquely sparse, dense and quiet prose that felt cinematic and completely captivating. This was a lovely, heartbreaking, all-consuming reading experience about love and grief and the rifts between our inner and outer worlds.

A Room Above A Shop is a literary fiction novel set to be published by Granta on 13th March 2025.

Anthony Shapland’s A Room Above A Shop follows two queer men, B and M, in 1980s Wales. Despite never mentioning her by name, this heartbreaking novel is backdropped by Thatcher's horrific tenure as Prime Minister (particularly the queerphobic Section 28), and deals with themes of alienation, ignorance, shame, love, expectation.

When M, an ironmonger taking on the family hardware store, hires B as a new employee and lodger, sparks fly in secret, away from bigoted residents, despite an 11-year age gap.

The novel has chapters that are more like vignettes, there's something vital and fleeting about them, with poetic descriptions almost listed like observations but still maintaining an air of beauty. The language and descriptions are so vivid and sibilant that there were times when I couldn't help but read aloud, as the words felt like they needed to be spoken, the sounds knitting together a further layer to the description. Often these remind me of some of the very visceral poetry I enjoy and have written myself in the past.

A raw look at the state of being gay in a deeply homophobic era, Shapland exemplifies how far we've come, and just how far we have to go. The deep personal shame B and M feel really resonates even with a distance of forty years.

My initial reaction on finishing A Room Above A Shop was ‘wow’, words failing, and I just know this story will stay with me for a long time.

Alt text/Image description: the cover of the novel, a pale background with a green mountain shape rising from the bottom (containing the author's name) and a black mountain shape looming down from the top (with the title).

A poignant short read with some beautiful prose. I enjoyed how poetic it felt. It's a very atmospheric book and beautifully crafted. It took me just over an hour to read - I hadn't been expecting it to be as short as it was when I picked it up initially, but this little story made a big impact on me. I appreciated the character study driven nature it had, as opposed to being a primarily plot driven read. I think it's particularly suited to queer readers and I'd definitely recommend this.

Thank you to Netgalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.

The book gives us a glimpse into small village life in Wales in the late ‘80s. Two gay men navigating a world in which HIV has just reared it’s ugly head and where being gay feels impossible.
The writing feels very poetic and dreamlike. It feels very dreamlike in how it is written, more snippets than a continuous story. At times it feels very atmospheric and at times it feels like more is needed to fully comprehend.

A short sharp novel that fills your heart with such a sweet and uplifting feeling in your stomach, don’t get me wrong there are moments scattered throughout this book where it does deal with grief and loneliness, but through all that, we have a gorgeously crafted Novel following our two protagonists known as B and M who’s paths cross in such a touching way and the relationship that flourishes between these two gentlemen… and a room above a shop which is a significant part of the story too,

A poetic, polished and experimental novella that depicts a three year romantic relationship between two men set in Wales, during the Aids crisis.

I didn't find it an enjoyable read. Driven by the beautiful prose, rather than plot or being character driven, A Room Above a Shop has quite an off-beat rythym making it feel a little stilted.

It is not a book I would easily recommend, but I do think it is very well-written.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.

Anthony Shapland's novella A Room Above A Shop tells the love story of two men in late 1980s' Wales, and it broke my heart.

What mesmerized me most about Shapland’s writing is his extraordinary ability to craft atmosphere – you can smell the damp grass and moss, feel the weight of the overcast sky, and see the buzzards circling above a landscape that is as vivid as it is lonely.

Then there’s his way of capturing awkward, fleeting moments – those encounters where bodies speak. Hands reach, fingers shred bottle labels, breaths meet in a drifting vapour. These details turn physical reactions into tiny protagonists of their own, shaping the emotional landscape as much as the Welsh hills.

And, of course, at its heart, a love story as intimate as the title suggests – tender und unforgettable.

A big thank you to Granta for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

A Room Above a Shop is a novel about two men in south Wales who find a love they must keep secret from the world. Known only as B and M, two men meet and see something in one another. After an awkward New Year's excursion, they find a way to be together: B helps M with his ironmonger's shop, living above the shop together as if hew as an apprentice. Around them, the news talks about AIDS and Section 28, and they must keep their public performance up so they don't lose what they have.

This is a story told in vignettes, charting a love story in a poetic way through the small moments in the two men's lives. The ending is sudden, bringing with it the shock of how life can go, and I was pleased that it didn't take perhaps the other, more obvious, narrative turn. It's a literary portrayal of gay working-class life in South Wales in that time, focused on tenderness and emotion rather than a more dramatic narrative, so is going to be one for fans of books that are in that kind of style. Personally, I enjoyed it, but its sparseness left me feeling removed from it, so that didn't quite work for me.

This book featured in the 2025 version of the influential and frequently literary-prize-prescient annual Observer Best Debut Novelist feature (last year included Colin Barrett and Kaliane Bradley, 2023
Tom Crewe. Michael Magee and Jacqueline Crooks – and earlier years have featured Natasha Brown, Caleb Azumah Nelson, Douglas Stuart, Sally Rooney, Rebecca Watson, Yara Rodrigues Fowler, JR Thorp Bonnie Garmus, Gail Honeyman among many others).

The author Anthony Shapland is an artist writer and curator from South Wales – and from the Literature Wales website his bio says “He grew up in an era that was only just starting to shift its social, legal and moral attitudes toward gay men, and the desire to ‘not stand out’, even after ‘coming out’, has had a lasting impact on all of his work. He is currently working with fiction, in short form and novella”.

And that serves as a perfect introduction to this book – as it is a novella (145 or so generously spaced pages) describing in sparse but tender prose a burgeoning but hidden love story between two quiet men (both who have developed over the years strategies precisely to not stand out)

The novel begins in very late 1987 (the year of the 1987 election where ant-homosexuality was part of the Tories attack campaign on Neil Kinnock’s attempts to rebuild Michael Foot’s Labour leading to the Section 28 legislation the next year and the year of the AIDS: Don’t Die of Ignorance leaflet campaign) in a South Wales village suffering from the aftermath of the 1984-85 Miners Strike both in terms of de-industrialisation and in the bitter personal disputes left behind.

The two men are known to us only as M and B.

M – who we can date from the Aberfan disaster the year he turned 9 as 30 at the novel’s beginning, has inherited his father’s ironmongery business (and his quiet position and status in the town). He has a child from a one-off encounter when he was 16, the child living with her mother and stepfather, his only real company int the flat above his shop a cat Tigr (his mother having predeceased his father)

B is around 10 years younger – his father (separated from his mother) has recently died and he currently is living in the council housing, but faces eviction as he has fallen off the Council list. At school – youngest of four siblings – he was something of a rebel using rebellion and music as a shield from the thing that really separated him from his schoolmates and family (his sexuality) and now he yearns to leave the Valleys.

At the book’s opening the two having forged a connection in the pub, agree to meet on the part hill, part slagheap outside the town on New Year’s Eve (something of a tradition for M) and form a tentative connection there – immediately we understand the life of careful concealment of their unfulfilled longings both have lived.

How often has [B] stared into the mirror at this hidden him? An understudy, carefully learning lines and behaviours; waiting in the wings to take the stage. Trying to understand how it is to be in this small town, a boy in this world.

[M] looks inward to something he can’t speak aloud. Something he rolls toward in countless night grunts. An imagined climax, forbidden, hidden behind locked toilet doors, under heavy blankets that pin down the deed. The hunger for another body, for a person to know, to see what he knows, to share. He’s filled with guilt. What is he doing up here? He feels caught out, seen doing something he ought not. Sadness sinks through him in an obscure confusion of fear and shame. The heavy impossibility of the shop, of the valley below—

Shortly after M advertises for an assistant and B picking up the hint applies; shortly after he is taken in as a lodger and then the two become lovers – albeit lovers whose very connection is meticulously hidden from the village and friends/family – leading to some tensions at Christmas and when M is asked to give away his daughter ….. the dear of discovery hanging over them, particularly as national events occasionally reveal the stark prejudices of the villagers to homosexuality.

Although set in a post-industrial town – there is some beautiful nature writing, at its strongest when it resonates with M and B’s lives and thoughts – the short chapter “Brimstone” is a particular highlight.

And this beautiful and quiet book has a painful yet poignant ending.

Recommended.

In a small Welsh village in the late 1980s, B is swept up in village bonhomie when M buys a Christmas round for everyone in the pub. M has taken over his late father’s hardware shop where the hard times of the miners’ strike and the ensuing unemployment were acknowledged with credit. He and B exchange a look and a chat, arranging to meet on New Year’s Eve. They carefully find their way to a relationship that becomes love, B working in M's shop and living in the makeshift bedsitter above next to M’s room. Downstairs they continue their performance of staff and shopkeeper, stifling their horror at the screaming ‘gay plague’ tabloid headlines announcing HIV/AIDS, quoted in tones of disgust by customers. Upstairs they’ve discovered a passion and love which feels like home.
Shapland’s novella is delivered in a series of short chapters arranged in brief paragraphs, full of evocative images vividly summoning up the Welsh landscape. The relationship between B and M is beautifully drawn, each of them terrified of exposure, careful to conceal a love that has taken them both by surprise, a happiness that can’t be shared with family. Their public days together are hedged around with self-restraint and a performance of straightness lest anyone guess their true relationship. Shapland captures how exhausting that must be, and how infuriating. It’s a striking piece of writing, beautiful and moving, brief but extraordinarily powerful.