Member Reviews

Libby is a talented ice skater who is invited to Bavaria to train with a former Olympic champion, Lukas Wolff, known for his daring signature routine, The Grim Reaper. Libby’s fellow skaters start to die in mysterious circumstances and she realises she has to fight for survival. This was an excellent thriller, really fast paced and compulsive reading. I didn’t know anything about ice skating and enjoyed reading about it. Libby was a great lead character, a strong and determined young woman used to facing adversity. The snowy mountain setting was very atmospheric and added to the tension.
Thanks to NetGalley and Headline for this review access.

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful setting in the Bavarian Forest where a group of Ice Skaters end up fighting for survival.
Interesting storyline with a huge host of characters.
Overall i enjoyed this read apart from the end which i felt was a little rushed.
My thanks to netgalley and the publisher for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

Nine skaters. One ice-cold killer. When Libby receives an invitation to train with an elite group of figure skaters, deep in the Bavarian Forest, it seems almost too good to be true! Great read!! Definitely too good to be true!! This book had great suspense, murder, mystery, intriguing, action, a fantastic who done it and some crazy twists and turns! The story was very interesting! I highly recommend reading this book! Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for sharing this book with me!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this thriller by CL Pattison but also found it frustrating, because it's very much a game of two halves. First to Fall follows an aspiring figure skater, Libby, who is invited to train in the Bavarian Forest with skating legend Lukas along with eight other hopefuls. But when one skater dies in mysterious circumstances, the others start to wonder if they are in danger. The first half of First To Fall is great - Pattison's writing here is a notch up from most commercial thrillers I've read, reminding me of early Ruth Ware, and it really makes a difference. I immediately sympathised with Libby and loved the material on professional ice skating, as well as the atmosphere of the isolated schloss where the skaters are staying. Indeed, I was enjoying the skating competition so much that I felt the book derailed when it hit more traditional thriller territory. The two halves of the story feel quite disconnected from each other, as the unfolding of the threat in the second half is just not prefigured at all in anything that happens in the first half. While there's a good, if very brief, set-piece when our characters skate for their lives along the frozen Danube, after the midpoint this novel becomes yet another 'group of people isolated in the snow' thriller and the fact they are skaters is almost immaterial. The final twist is also dazzlingly pointless and the newspaper interview format to explain the motives of the killer incredibly clunky. I'd definitely read more by Pattison, because I (mostly) liked her writing, but it's a shame that everything that made this thriller unusual and original at the start is abandoned at the end. 3.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Lukas Wolff, an ex-Olympic figure skater, invites a group of young skaters to his house for training/competition. None of them knew others would be there, or that they could be sent home if he doesn't like them. All of a sudden, bad things start happening, and people start drying. Can they get out of the castle in the middle of a blizzard to get help? I thought the book was pretty good; it held my attention. I just feel the ending was rushed and not thoroughly developed. Not so much as the explanation, but they were skating and boom here is the killer. But a good book for sure!

Was this review helpful?