Member Reviews

A huge thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and Nachi Aono for providing me with an ARC of I Want to Love You Till Your Dying Day 1 in exchange for my honest review.

Whilst I appreciated the art style, I found it challenging to engage with the story due to its central focus on a romantic narrative involving children. This subject matter felt inappropriate to me and detracted significantly from my overall enjoyment of the work. Although I can acknowledge the skill and effort put into the artwork, the themes explored in the story were not to my taste and ultimately made this book a difficult read for me.

Was this review helpful?

I love the art style of this manga. it is so beautiful.

I also really enjoyed the concept of this type of magical girl. I think it's an interesting twist on the genre.

That being said, I think I'm too old to really enjoy this. the characters are far too young. I know a high schoolers who enjoy manga would absolutely enjoy this.

Was this review helpful?

I thought the art of I Want to Love You Till Your Dying Day vol. 1 was beautiful, though I wished we were taught a little bit more about the world Sheena and Mimi inhabit. For know, all we know is that they use magic to fight in a war, with this volume mostly focusing on their school lessons and conflict between the main characters. The little bit we saw of them going into war seemed really interested and I'd like to see more!

I was a little confused on their ages. I think they said Mimi was ten but I thought Sheena was older? But then, I also remember her saying they were around the same age. I feel like it would have made more sense to make them both older, like the secondary couple. Also, the nurse character was a little off; while I loved her design, I think it's weird that she seems to enjoy kissing underage girls (that's how they utilize healing magic, through kisses). I know a flirtatious, older school nurse is a popular trope in manga but it didn't really fit the dark setting.

Was this review helpful?

The art style of this manga was really cute and the concept was very interesting to me. I think this was a really compelling start to a series and made me excited to read the next volume. I thought some of the concepts were a bit generic, but overall I liked it.

Was this review helpful?

[Thanks to Netgalley and Kodansha for an ARC of this manga in exchange for an unbiased review.]

It’s been a bit since we’ve had a darker magical girl manga come out, or at least since I’ve read one. And now this one has yuri baked into it. You’d think it would be a match made in heaven, but a couple of poor decisions make this a hard recommend.

I’m put to mind of the equally awkward <i>Magical Girl Spec-Ops Asuka</i>, which conflated ‘grim and gritty’ with ‘torture porn and unlikable’. This is less on the action, and more interesting, but still makes significant missteps.

Before we get there, the good bits. I like the contrast between our leads. Sheena is moody and has no love for the vague war that she and her classmates are being trained for (yes, it’s magical girls as combat weapons time again).

Mimi, on the other hand, is a cheerful and chipper, yet also happens to be a murder machine hiding secrets behind her smile. The two of them have an interesting dynamic - Sheena doesn’t like Mimi a whole lot at first, but she won’t be rude about it, which is a nice touch.

Sheena is either hopeless at magic or a pacifist, or both, as well, but she takes care of Mimi when she joins their class and she treats her normally. That’s something that Mimi doesn’t typically experience given her celebrity status and it’s not hard to see why she gets attached.

The quiet school life versus the ongoing horrors of war is also a strong contrast too. When we open, Sheena’s roommate has just been killed and she seems to be the only one who cares. Everybody else takes this sort of tragedy in stride, including Mimi, who is introduced dripping in blood that isn’t actually hers.

There’s a lot to like in the way this presents itself and, even with minimal action, the character drama is more than enough to hold the reader’s attention. Sheena’s friends, Seiran and Ari, who are polar opposites, yet hiding their deep love for one another from everybody, are especially excellent and I may read more of this just for them (even if I wouldn’t give long odds to both of them surviving).

When we get into trouble comes from two places. Firstly, Mimi is ten. Although the story does manage to account for this and she’s almost certainly older than that, it does seem real weird that she’s kissing Sheena this volume. The yuri here is better when it’s less overt.

And that kissing thing conveniently turns out to be a way for people to ‘share mana’, which is a narrative turn that I don’t think serves any good purpose except one instance towards the end involving a missing arm.

Otherwise it seems to be an excuse for the girls to kiss, although we see that some of them are really into sharing mana. It also makes the whole thing with the school nurse, who happens to be a trans character (or at least a cross-dresser) very unfortunate.

It’s bad enough to have said person kissing underage girls, big massive yikes to every aspect of that, but mixing in transphobic behaviour on top of it is really awful. Nothing about that character is well done and it’s a super bummer.

It’s very readable, I really devoured this, but recommending it has serious caveats. Not for everybody. I’m going to give it a middling rating of 2.5 stars while noting that I’ll probably read more, but it’s got some serious issues.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Kodansha and NetGalley for this arc!

It’s magical girl school yuri with a twist of horror. Lots of WLW representation here…with a sinister kick. None of the characters or storyline really grabbed me so I most likely won’t check out volume 2.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful artwork, and I like the main character. Absolutely hated that the trans woman (or drag queen? Not clear) is depicted as a pedophile who is an adult kissing children to heal them.

Was this review helpful?

The world was intriguing! I'm not hooked for the next installment due to the slow pace, but I am curious.

Was this review helpful?

I forgot how grim the introduction to this world is and how genuinely terrified Sheena is. From the cover art and Mimi’s personality, you really can’t guess just how dark things are but Sheena’s fear really drives it home. This is a strong introductory volume, setting the scene as well as introducing our two main characters as well as the two side characters they’ll be close with in the future (yes okay I’ve been keeping up with the serialized chapters so I know where this is going BUT it has been a while since I read the beginning).

I will say the healing magic does do a lot to kind of cut off some of the looming threat of death, but our resident pessimist Sheena doesn’t let that stop her

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited to see a dark GL magical girl manga on netgalley!

It’s been years since I’ve read anything from the magical girl genre but I love it so much, especially the subversion of the cuteness with overlaid horror (see: Madoka Magica), so the blurb of this made me jump at the chance to read it because magical girls being used as child soldiers fully encompasses this!

The cover art was also intrinsic in my choice to read because it’s so pretty so I was really hoping that the internal art was also beautiful and IT WAS!

It was tagged as GL so I’m really hoping that it’s not just queer baiting an stuff actually becomes canon eventually but it’s only volume 1 so the romance not really happening yet is okay with me.

That said, I was NOT happy with the portrayal of drag queens/ trans feminine people as “perverts”/“paedophiles” because the transmisogyny is real and I hate it.

Aside from this, I enjoyed this volume and will definitely be continuing the series as it is released in the hope that this problematic element improves.

Was this review helpful?

This war time sapphic story was cute but also a little confusing at times. The main characters go through a lot at the young age that they are.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley & the Publisher for providing me with an E-Arc in exchange for an honest review


CW: Blood, Death, War, Heavy Injury, Implied Adult + Child Kissing


2.5 / 5 Stars

Im not sure if I'll be checking out other issues of this Manga. On the one hand, I find the world interesting and the buildup did hook me in. As did the side characters and MC. But...there's a few things that bothered me.

There is no romance between the main couple in this one yet. They just got to meet and hang out for about 4 days or so. And yet they already kissed because we establish that mana can be shared between kissing parties. And that... is kinda a big uff. Especially when other authors and Manga have shown that you dont have to. And twice especially when we loki make a big deal out of the kiss both in spoken text as well as in multible panels of art. We also learn that the adult - way over 18+ - nurse usually kisses her underage students and Im sorry that's just....no. Yes, we deal with a world that has no problem sending 10-17 year old kids into battle to die and yet THIS is were I draw the line. Especially when you had the choice to not make mana transfer happen through kissing and decided to do it nontheless. Why else would the main leads kiss each other twice in this issue after all?

There are few interesting things that one can explore here and the manga seemed like it was interested in doing so but still. Might check out a second volume or might not.

Let me talk about the MC real quick cause I actually like her a lot. The rest of her school seems almost numb to the death, blood and murder and I love how she is not. Loss still affects her, she still mourns, still doesnt want to take a life and I like that. It's clear the rest of the cast sees all that as a weakness but for 1. The other students are full of shit who were never on the battlefield either but who got taught to ne numb killers although they are just kids.
And 2. I wont listen to an adult who has no issue watching children get ducking killed.
I hope her character arc is not learning to be ruthless. #Ruthlessness Is Mercy Upon Ourselves.
Because that would be sad.


Final Thoughts:
Like I said. Has potential. If only it didnt feautre that icky stuff.

Was this review helpful?

"I Want to Love You Till Your Dying Day 1" it's about a school where orphaned children are trained in magic to fight in an ongoing war. The artwork is really cool and detailed, and the story is fast paced and very easy to follow and is set in a challenging, high-stakes environment.
I found the concept intriguing and I get that the concept is more shocking with them being so young but I couldn’t help but feel that the story would have benefited from making the characters a bit older, especially for the romance.
Thank you Netgalley for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

I went into this a bit hesitantly, but was thoroughly impressed. A boot camp of orphans, a war, and teenagers make for one complicated life. While this does have some darker elements the plot isn't going for gore and counteracts the weight of themes with some cheerful personalities. My one negative is the romance plot is coming on a bit thick, too soon for me, but not unexpected given the title!

Was this review helpful?

i couldn't not request this manga from that tagline and the comps (i would argue that madoka would more than fit this category well, and um, evangelion, iykyk). and if you're still looking for confirmation: this is the doomed yuri (my beloved) that you've been waiting for.

for a first volume, it does a well enough job of introducing us to the characters and endearing us to them - their cute depictions and relatable personalities even made me forget about the absolutely depressing environment around themsometimes (let's hope nothing bad happens, ha ha). besides that, there's not much "magical girl" stuff happening, in fact, there's almost no worldbuilding at all (we do know that you can transmit mana via kissing and that's really imporant for the plot i swear!! - the plot: my girls kissing) -- but i do have high hopes that the followups would remedy that.

sheena and mimi balance each other out so well. they're the depressed x sunshine pairing of my dream. i'm also a sucker for an overpowered being (?) who is obsessed with one fragile human and would do anything to protect/get back to them.

that cute art style and these lovable magical girls are going to be the death of me, i just know it. not looking forward to the pain, but i guess i'll have no choice except to follow these girls until the end of the line. please join me in this journey if that synopsis interests you, we may regret it but at least we'll regret it together.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this one. Orphanage boot camp for magical students. Good way to start the series and build the story. Unique magic system and interesting storyline with these magical women warriors. Looking forward to more!

Thanks to Net Galley and Kodansha comics for this ARC!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars
Thank you, Kodansha comics and NetGalley, for access to this title. And the chance to give my honest review!

Magical orphanage that trains children to be magical soldiers.

Not only does this story show the horror and cost of war on these children, but any normalisation/ cuteness of any kind is still tarnished by dread because of the whole situation. They are cattle raised for slaughter.

While I understand why the cast is so young (to show the terror of war on children), I feel like having them older would have been good, too.
(Listen, I'm just scared from other manga, so I'm scared they are gonna do something unnecessary.)

Was this review helpful?