From the introduction I could already tell how important this book would be, first within the realm of Homeric scholarship, and secondly within the realm of feminist history and women’s studies.

This book highlights how important it is to continually revise our study of ancient history - particularly the ancient epics - to reflect the world around us.

Emily highlights that, in recent years, there has been a small but concerning movement to rewrite and reinterpret the ancient epics for a misogynistic and racist audience. Therefore, the reinterpretation of the ancient epics by women and minority groups is more important than ever. Whether this reinterpretation be in scholarship or modern retellings, Emily highlights the importance of both to our modern society in order to fight back against the single-minded and harmful use of ancient history by these groups.

As for the content of the book, I am stunned! Without revealing too much, because you should experience this book for yourself, this book is a brilliant intersection of everything that makes ancient history so brilliant to study in the modern day. Both entertaining and informative - the perfect balance of analysis and letting the ancient evidence speak for itself!

I particularly enjoyed the focus on female historians and archaeologists - it really drove home Emily’s message of writing women back into the foreground of history.

Moreover, it was a lovely touch to have each chapter open with a beautiful reimagined snippet from a mythological woman, reflecting Emily’s earlier mythological novels and her brilliant prose, whilst acting as a perfect summary of the feminist message within each chapter.

100/10 - I hope this books inspires scholarship for decades to come 🏺✨

I was incredibly excited for this book, and it did not disappoint. Mythica explores the Iliad and Odyssey through the women- Briseias, Helen, Circe, and, of course, Penelope just to name a few.

@emilyhauserauthor has such a talent for combining stories with research. Each chapter opens with a scene that ties Mythica back to the original text with and gives the perspective of the figure it follows. The remainder of the chapter then examines the archaeology and scholarship surrounding that figure in order to show what the actual women living in the bronze age may have experienced.

This is one of my favorite nonfiction books now. 10000/10, you should definitely read it!

Thank you @netgalley and @doubledayukbooks for the opportunity to read and review this book early!

4.5 stars

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for sending me an e-ARC to review!

This is a book I wish I’d been able to read when I was a student. Emily Hauser pulls us into the world of Greek mythology and combines literary analysis of Homer’s epics with cutting edge archaeological research to challenge the Western idea that the Iliad and Odyssey were only about the actions of powerful white men. As a longtime fan of Hauser’s feminist myth retellings, it was fantastic to see some of the things that clearly inspired her when writing those books. Going character by character, Hauser explores a vast range of aspects of ancient life, from weaving to rearing animals to ancient law to how the Dark Ages were eventually brought about. She even connects these topics with modern-day issues, from climate change to modern slavery in the fast fashion industry to right-wing parties co-opting Classical iconography for their own purposes. I would have loved some images in the ARC to properly visualise everything that Hauser was describing, but after seeing pages from the finished book that do contain lots of images, I’m just even more certain that I’ll end up buying a physical copy anyway! This is a brilliant, important book that taught me a lot, and I would absolutely recommend it to anyone with an interest in ancient and/or feminist history.

"The gleaming epic of heroes like Achilles is, when you flip the coin to its grittier side, powered by the oppression of women"

I was given an advance copy in exchange for a review.

I've had the privilege of hearing Dr Hauser teach, and this book perfectly encapsulated her ability to bring ancient myths to life. While I'm not usually much of a non-fiction reader, Mythica touches on questions that are sure to appeal to any fan of the ancient world, and draws storytelling, history, and archaeology into one narrative.

The key thing that struck me was how much this book expands upon ancient societies. Rather than just focusing on the Greeks themselves (an approach which has long-since been used to whitewash this period), this draws in a range of civilizations, showcasing the interconnectivity and cultural trade found in antiquity. One thing I would note is that it is not quite introductory material, and would probably appeal more to those with some experience with Classics!

Bringing in her perspective as an academic, Dr Hauser offers a fresh outlook on seemingly innocuous moments from Homeric epic. For anyone with a passion for the classical civilizations, Mythica is an eye-opening exploration into a world of gods, heroes, and forgotten women.

Books with similar vibes - Divine Might by Natalie Haynes, The Penelopiad by Margaret Atwood, and Pandora's Jar by Natalie Haynes.

I've been waiting for ages to read this book. Marvellous to have an in depth look at the women completely sidelined in Homer's Odyssey. It was a weighty read, and I found the pace a bit slow at times, but it added so much more to my understanding of the role of women in ancient Greece. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in return for an honest review of the book.

Mythica notes how women have often been written out of history in the place of men. Thus book uses archeological evidence and new DNA testing to unearth the lives of the women who inspired Homers epics of The Iliad and The Odyssey, thus presenting a new history of Bronze Age Aegean societies. This book brilliantly portrays how hard and unfair life was for women in this period, yet also how some of them were not just docile housewives as we believe but had agency and their own aspirations, for example the chapters on the Amazonian women. This book was very informative and throughly researched, yet it’s important to note it is a work of nonfiction and history, despite comments recommending it to lovers of Greek myth retelling such as Circe(Madeline Miller)and A Thousand Shops (Natalie Haynes). It is definitely worth a read, however be wary that it is not a work of fiction.
The book was very enjoyable however it was hard work to get through at times, mostly due to the amount of concentration needed to really take in the points Hauser was making, it was not relaxing but definitely worthwhile. However it was so interesting to read about the women behind the myths and how modern advances in DNA science and archaeological evidence is evolving, for example to reimagine what Helen could have looked like. It has also allowed us to understand how many female remains were almost always attributed to men due to the presence of weapons and other traditionally viewed ‘male’ objects in ancient burials.
Over all this book has left a very good impression and has given me, and hopefully other readers, a lot to think and mull over regarding the Homer epics and the real life women behind such epics in the past.

Wow, this is going to be a difficult one to review. Hold on to your wooden horses, because I predict a rocky road upcoming.

I can totally see the promise Mythica has, or does have, for some people. I can see all the time and effort and research that has gone into this book; a book that I do think has its place within the sphere of Homeric thought and disentanglement and the wonders of modern-day science. It's just that unfortunately, for me, I had troubles with it.

I know… it saddens me too. I was so desperate to love it. But it missed the mark for me, and once I started to get a little bored, soon came all these little grievances. I’ll try not to make it too nitpicky, because these deliberations are so personal, but I do think they need to be addressed. Just to reiterate, this isn’t a bad book. Just, quite frankly, missing the mark at times. Did I not enjoy it? At times, I did, sure.

You see, sometimes I’m apprehensive about reading non-fiction books about Greek Mythology. I'm all for the more psychoanalytical approaches (Edward Teach’s Watch What You Hear) or the more analytical, like Roberto Calasso's The Marriage of Cadmus and Harmony, which really homes in on the structure of myth, and nuances of it. But I’m less inclined to read about the links of Greek mythology with ancient Greece itself, and I was hoping that Mythica could change that. I don’t really like supporting history with the foundation of mythology. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy explorations of real women within antiquity. (Shoutout to Sarah B. Pomeroy’s Goddesses, Whores, Wives, & Slaves). But I like it when it’s substantial. Emily Hauser has a somewhat dogmatic approach.

Each chapter begins with a tale from the point of view of a character. These little introductions may work for some people, but I found the prose a little purple-ly. Hauser then introduces the “historical” side of things, and how these female characters and humans reflect one another. I think the way this sets the book up was tricky. Sure, it seemed smart to attribute a topic to a woman, but at times these link ups seemed strenuous at best.

Archaeology was all over this book, but it felt like sometimes we focused a little too much on the archaeologists (at least for my liking) and the how-to science of the remains than what the information can actually definitively tell us. It was also a slow paced read for me with just how much filler occurred, rather than getting down to the nitty gritty. Some people may prefer that type of treasure hunting approach, but I really could’ve done without the (not to be too cynical) pages of the wonders of the British Library building. I just think too much time was given to setting the scene, rather than what the scene can offer. That's why I enjoyed Calypso's chapter probably more so than any other, because it actually talked less about hypotheticals or tangibles, and more so about actuality in regard to the historical side of things. Despite the tenuous link to Calypso's character herself (Calypso's chapter was about weaving) it still introduced a concept that I did think applied to both myth and reality. Weaving wasn't this simple past time hobby, but for ancient women, Helen and Penelope, and women even today, it was a substantial part of their lives. The trauma found within the bones of unearthed skeletons, and how this was an actual reflection, was really interesting. I also really enjoyed the connection to the more contemporary concerns. (Evolution of clothing within the industrial revolution, fast fashion, and the plight of workers within sweatshops).

Hauser was also great with exploring the development of the Homeric works themselves throughout time. I wish we had more of that. Learning about how the idea of Achilles heel appears over eight hundred years after the Iliad, or how Penthesilea and the Amazons were a little footnote and have managed to survive, really grounded these works of being a tale of humanity, by humanity, across all generations. Also of language itself, and the powerful influence we can have over translation and interpretation. I could’ve done with 500 pages more of this semi-silencing and degradation of women over the centuries. (E.g. Fagles mistranslation of Penelope’s slaves as being “whores”). It made me actively question what I have subconsciously gathered about these characters and how I see them.

Again, I really loved the little titbits of language facts, like how Cu for Copper comes to us from Cypriot Bronze, or how the word mentor also comes to us from Telemachus’ advisor, Mentor.

What I wasn’t all too keen on was the constant name dropping of contemporary retellings. It all felt very self-congratulatory, and grated me a little, as I believe some of these books have their injustices too with regards to characterisation and so to use them as examples questioned my trust. Retellings are based more so on interpretation than actual source material, and more of the reflection of modern day perspectives. What can they tell me about the silenced women of antiquity? These books have their place (and I have enjoyed most of the ones she drops), but with trying to give an historical account of women, I think it just displaces them to modern day attitudes.

It's totally important to home in on the "silenced" women of Greek Mythology. Ignorantly, naively, or with my own privilege, I never really questioned the approach female characters were delivered to me. I've always had this belief, and a sort of romanticism in the way I approached these stories. I never questioned the way a 20th century male author translated his works; I never questioned the way the Classics are tied to classism, and that the way I saw the story was perhaps the way I hoped the story was, rather than it actually was. But that's the thing about literature. It was always for my interpretation. That's what makes literature so radical as well, because it is free from certain restraints. Retellings aplenty are rarely discouraged or acted as a slight upon the original work. I'm getting off topic a little here, but what I'm trying to say, is that I never questioned the place women have within the realm of mythology until I was told to. Historically, yes. Of course, that goes without saying that women have been stomped on throughout time. But the women of myth always had this protection over them for me, because I wanted to see what I wanted to take. I never thought to see what these ancient poets were trying to achieve by creating the stories they did. I wish we delved more into that side of things, and how the one influenced the other.

I take inspiration from all the women Hauser has chosen to frame in Mythica. But I don’t think women were always at the forefront of this novel. I think as we read further and further into the book, we lose sight a little. We spend hefty time on geography and the musings of cities, which isn’t something I find all too interesting, nor did it offer much up despite “maybes”.

My review seems negative. But again, I don't think the book is a bad book, by any stretch of the imagination. I think certain people will like the structure and will find the science more interesting than I did. I think the book will suit those who have a more introductory background to Greek Mythology. Perhaps the crisscrossing of cultures (like Mesopotamian) or the buried skeletons of Amazon-like women may have been better received by those who are a little more unknown to it. In fact, this coalition of knowledge would really serve those who are new to the world of classics. It is a trove of knowledge, but maybe too ambitious in nature.

Hauser leaves us with some contemplation. We should ultimately separate the narrative of fiction with the facts of fiction. We have to separate our own agenda, and realise history not through Homer, but around Homer, with evidence from science and archaeology. I agree with her, but the way the book has been laid out, seems to suggest otherwise.

Wow wow wow what a beautiful book, inside and out!! This book is brutal, but exactly what is needed to get the real truth out there, for these forgotten women of Homer. I learnt so much reading about the science behind archaeology, what we can learn from TEETH?! The harsh realities of what women went through, especially at such a young age had me on the verge of tears. There were a couple of chapters that I did find a bit of a struggle and I do think this book would be less suited to people who only read fiction/mythology retellings personally. However I found Emily Hauser very knowledgeable and I really enjoyed it!

Mythica by Emily Hauser is a must-read for anyone with an interest in ancient history, Greek mythology, or the women who have often been sidelined in the stories of epic warriors and gods. In this groundbreaking work, Hauser—an award-winning classicist and historian—shifts the focus to the remarkable and largely untold stories of the women who lived in the shadow of Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. Rather than rehashing the myths themselves, Hauser delves deep into the real historical, archaeological, and scientific evidence to reveal the lives of women like Helen of Troy, Penelope, Circe, Athena, and many others.

What sets Mythica apart is its unflinching and honest examination of these women not as modern-day symbols or "girl bosses," but as real figures living in a brutal and unforgiving world. Hauser does not attempt to make them superheroes or contemporary figures who fit today’s narratives of empowerment; instead, she places them firmly within their time and context, showing how they navigated a patriarchal and often violent society. This approach is refreshing and thought-provoking, offering readers an authentic look at how these women might have lived, what roles they truly played in the epic tales, and how history has treated them—or failed to do so.

The chapters on Aphrodite and Hera stand out as particularly impactful, delving into the complexities of their identities within both the mythological and historical frameworks. The chapters on figures such as Thetis, Briseis, and Circe are equally engrossing, each one offering new insights into their roles and the cultural significance of their stories.

What makes Mythica even more intriguing is its incorporation of recent scientific discoveries, including DNA evidence, that shed light on the lives of these ancient figures. These facts linger long after reading, giving the book a unique and haunting quality that stays with you. The text itself is beautifully written, offering a seamless blend of historical scholarship and storytelling. It also promises to be richly illustrated when fully published, with detailed maps and art that will further enhance the reader’s understanding of the ancient world.

For lovers of Greek mythology, history, and archaeology, Mythica is a revelation. It not only gives voice to the forgotten women of the Trojan War and the surrounding epics but also provides a fresh perspective on the more famous male characters like Achilles, Hector, Odysseus, and Paris. Whether you're a seasoned fan of Greek myths or new to the subject, this book is a must-have for its historical depth, intellectual rigour, and emotional resonance.

Read more at The Secret Book Review.

The age-old saying that women should be seen and not heard has never sat right with me—not in my nearly fifty years of drawing breath. But, of course, three and a half thousand years ago (and more), that was the norm in places like Troy, the Roman Empire, Egypt, Greece, and beyond. That’s why it’s refreshing to read a book that gives voice to the women of that time, restoring their stories and challenging long-held assumptions.

Mythica is a vital and eye-opening read. It offers a surprising and thought-provoking look at historical opinions that have been shaped over centuries, if not millennia. Dr. Emily Hauser has clearly poured an immense amount of research into this work, and the result is nothing short of brilliant. It’s one of the best books I’ve had the privilege to read before publication, and I will proudly add it to my growing library. Without hesitation, I give it a five-star rating.

One of my favorite aspects of this book is how each chapter begins—with a short story that feels like a mini-novel in its own right. Just as you get drawn in, you’re hit with a powerful wave of historical and scientific insights that challenge dogmatic views of women in the Late Bronze Age. Hauser employs science, advanced archaeology (both on land and under the sea), radioactive isotopes, and more to dismantle outdated narratives. Each chapter seamlessly transitions into the next, making for an engaging and immersive read.

I found it difficult to put this book down—it’s beautifully written, accessible, and utterly captivating. It will appeal to anyone with an interest in Greek history, mythology, or the Homeric epics (The Iliad and The Odyssey—the former of which I’m currently reading alongside Mythica). The writing never overwhelms with dense academic jargon, making it accessible to all readers, regardless of background.

This book makes it abundantly clear that the women of the Late Bronze Age—across the Mediterranean, Africa, Egypt, and beyond—were far more than just domestic servants, slaves, goddesses, or muses. Dr. Emily Hauser has given them a voice and, in doing so, has crafted an epic story that finally places them alongside the men of their time.

Mythica is a brilliantly researched and beautifully told work, and it has been my privilege to read it. My deepest thanks to Dr. Emily Hauser, Doubleday, and NetGalley for the opportunity to experience this book in advance.

I loved this book! Extremely informative and beautifully written at the same time. I was especially impressed by all the scientific evidence used. The analysis of mythology was great, of course, but it was all the information from archeology and other fields that felt most fascinating. The amount of knowledge in this one book is staggering and so many topics are covered in surprising depth. A really excellent read.

In a field that is getting ever fuller this book by Hauser offers something very different to the reworkings of Greek myths.

Hauser takes some of the best known women from antiquity, as well as some of the lesser known ones but that are vital to the story of the Iliad, and using archaeological sources finds evidence of their actual existence or their matches through other literature from the time. It was great being able to map the times the Iliad/Odyssey are set with actual people and evidence across the Mediterranean area.
It was also fascinating to see how the traditional tales/history had been reworked/written by subsequent male dominated societies which completely subvert history.
I also very much liked the framing of the story to match Homer's famous works and the final chapter on finally finding Ithaca and Odysseus's home.

Easily one of my top five non-fiction books on the Aegean myths, the women in Homer's work and the ancient world of Greece.
I admit I enjoyed this more than the many fictional books about the women in mythology, which have become a subgenre in their own right, because of its balanced, no-nonsense, engaging and thrilling prose.
In Mythica, Emily Hauser, who has every right to speak about the above topics as a competent expert. She knows how to tell a great story using her expertise.
For readers who like detailed explorations, scientific research crosses storytelling,
It is everything what some lacklustre, sensation-oriented, weak fictional books are not. (This comes from my disappointment in many of the women-led mythology inspired fictional books starting off well and then turning into illogical messes - yet, there are many great examples which were excellent reads. More disappointment than awe and praise in my experience, though).

A non-fiction look at the female characters in Homer's works and the world in which they inhabit.

This was an enthralling, engaging look at the Late Bronze Age world, through the lens of women and the many different facets in which they offered the world. We cover archaeological evidence from a shipwreck to a baby's grave, to a waste pit of pig bones, and so much more.

By the time I had finished the first section on Helen (the face) I was already considering it a five star read, and it never let me down. Even chapters which might, at first glance be redundant - there is a chapter on Andromache (the wife) and much later, on Nausicaa (the bride) - are anything but, showing us the many different stages of life a woman could experience.

I loved the sheer range of knowledge on offer here, little nuggets offered up, especially the asides about where certain words and meanings come from. We range from where English gets the word 'mentor' to why copper has the chemical name on the periodic table of 'cu' and everything in-between.

A tour de force of truly epic proportions and well researched, witty writing.

Each section could have been a book in of itself.

I cannot wait to buy a physical copy of this book.

~thanks to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review of this book~