Member Reviews

I was thrilled to receive an early copy of this as Leila Mottley's debut was one of my favourite books that year. This is set in Florida and is about teenage/youth mothers who don't receive support from their family. The Girls have built a community where they support each other through pregnancy and with their young children. It's a strong bond and this novel takes us through the ups and downs the girls/women have. It's a good read but I found that it wasn't overly gripping and took me much longer to get through than normal. It's good but not as good as I expected.

Was this review helpful?

Awesome Novel, well writen very emotionally challenging at times. A real eye opener it's a gritty tale from the view point of 3 women ones expecting the other 2 are already Mothers

Adela is aren't to get Gandma's to hide away simply because of her parents respond to her getting pregnant. So hidden away in Florida she meets a group of mothers all ostracised simple for being pregnant outside of marriage.

Simone was the first to be pregnant and although had a partner was alone with the twins she had and found herself helping others in similar situations including the births, she has an interesting time but I will let you read it. This terms the story from a very different angle to the normal mother and baby clubs and well it's a a take that needs to be told. It m us a work of fiction but the attitudes of others and their stories will echo with far more Young Mums than any of us truly know.

So it's a week thought out researched tale or novel to be more respectful to Liela who wrote it. I highly recommend this read its not my normal read but I was hooked by the whole storyline and the way it's told excellent to our it mildly, I'm so glad I came upon it.

Was this review helpful?

4+
Padua Beach, Florida is definitely not on the tourist trail as it’s a forgotten wasteland. Here is where we meet the girls who grew big – Adela, Emory and Simone. Teenage mothers who the town believes to have well and truly lost their way and they judge them accordingly. However, although they do sometimes lose their way, they are far from lost as they navigate the challenges of motherhood and the pitfalls and problems that life throws at them. Adela arrives in Padua Beach to live with her grandmother as her parents cannot handle her pregnancy, Simone, who already has twins, Luck and Lion, is pregnant again and clever Emory wants to combine motherhood with continuing her education. Each one tells their stories as they interact and Leila Mottley gives them their own unique voice.

Leila Mottley is quite the talent. She writes with meaning and feeling, it’s powerful, often raw and painful, frequently heartbreaking and it has an authentic tone throughout the storytelling. Her novels are different, they’re creative, they shine a spotlight on certain groups to challenge thinking, just as she does in her first novel, ‘Nightcrawling’. The characterisation is exemplary with the individual personalities and circumstances they’re in being easy to see. All of them are resourceful and courageous, they’re resilient because they have no other option. They obviously have many worries, especially concerning their children but they have each other. There’s a strong bond, they’re united by their pregnancies, by motherhood by hardship and the need to survive throughout all the difficulties, some of which they have with each other, but they figure it out and find their way. In the face of the obstacles, the ultimate mood is optimistic. All three are a lesson in not judging a book by its cover.

The setting of Nowheresville, Florida is inspired and well chosen. Living in this part of the USA (eg. alligators, hurricanes ) presents yet more challenges, these are yet more obstacles to overcome and it further demonstrate their mettle.

Overall, this novel is hard hitting but written with warmth and empathy towards the characters, reinforcing the idea of resisting the rush to judgement and to stereotype. It’s beautifully written and I find myself rooting for each of them because the author makes me care.

With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Penguin General UK for the much appreciated EPub in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a really moving read. The book challenges the concerns, myths and judgements around young motherhood and does it in a tender way. The book follows Adela who is sent away when she falls pregnant by her parents who judge the circumstances and want Adela to go far away, stay with her grandmother and then give the baby away. The book follows Adela’s pregnancy concentrating on how she is feeling and the people she meets and how the new life growing inside her gives her anew perspective on life and on who she is. This is a book that covers quite a short period in time but does it beautifully.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this - especially after all the really positive early reviews. Instead, I struggled through. Between about 30% and 70% it really seemed to lag as it moved between the various girls' perspectives, without much happening.

The premise was interesting. I enjoy novels that show us a different experience of society and teach empathy but I thought the characterisation was mediocre, the plot a bit flat and the writing unimpressive.

I feel there are better books out there exploring young motherhood in impoverished conditions - I think here of 'No Small Thing'.

2.5* rounded up to 3 for the inclusion of important themes.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

What an absolutely *stunning* novel. I was gripped from the off, and drawn quickly and deeply into the lives of these young women. All failed by their families, their men, and themselves to some degree, they look to each other for strength, hope, and love amid their desperation.

Barely done with being children themselves these girls face motherhood, asking themselves constantly “who do I need to be, who CAN I be, to make a life for myself and my child?”

Mottley’s characterisations are so empathetic and compelling that I simply couldn’t look away. These girls grab you by the ears, look you full in the face and make you attend.

I cannot imagine anyone making a better fist of helping an old man like me *feel* the emotional and physical impact of pregnancy and birth, the vacillation and dread felt by a young life knowing it is going to be changed forever by the choice to keep the baby or otherwise. It is remarkable how she delivers bruisingly vivid, raw humanity with such incredible panache and elegance.

This morning I woke at 3am and thought I’d read this for a while. I soon got sleepy again, but simply couldn’t stop reading until it was time to get up.

When did a book last do that to you?

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin UK for providing me with an ARC.

The Girls Who Grew Big is an explosive, heartwarming, and emotional novel about those on the fringes of society, cast out and alienated by others, and how they come together to find family and love with each other. The novel centers around 'The Girls' - a group of young mother's trying to find their place in the Panhandle of Florida, a coastal town called Padua Beach.

There are multiple 'Girls', but the novel concerns itself with the perspectives of three of them - Adela, Simone, and Emory. Their lives entwine and tangle up with each other in friendship, love, heartbreak and betrayal.

I truly loved this novel and the way it explores young motherhood with such love and respect, calling out the way society has mistreated and shamed young mother's, and also acknowledging the hardships these mother's face. The novel ruminates on race, sexuality and gender roles, as well as generational gaps, religion, and the education system.

I would very much recommend this novel, and this has made me really want to read Leila Mottley's debut novel 'Nightcrawling'.

Was this review helpful?

A book with a dated storyline for the girls. A group of young girls find themselves pregnant and are disowned by the majority of their families in a beach area of Florida. Living in a truck and a garage with newly born babies. Quite a lot of graphic talk at the start of the book but it seemed to settle down as you got into the book.

Story a little sparse on some details, ie as to where did they their money to live on, how did they find the things they needed for a new-born?

It did bring into play the hope of some of the girls that all is not lost for their future.

Thank you Netgalley for letting me read this book.

Was this review helpful?

The stories of a group of outcast young women, in a little town called Padua Beach, Florida, either pregnant or just given birth, and how they intertwine with each other and how their lives develop along the way.

The blurb for this book really sold it to me and I was pleased to receive the arc. However it wasn’t quite as expected and anticipated. Slow and laboured (sorry 😬), at times it dragged along. I don’t think I am the right demographic for this book, as the writing style is good, just the subject matter I lost interest in. I’m sure it will be a winner with the majority of readers, just not my thing.

As with Nightcrawling, Mottley is not afraid to show true emotion and get to the heart of modern day issues.

Realistic and unadorned, the book starts with a birth and ends with one.

The views of the Girls are, to me, a little dated, in that they ‘think’ a man is the answer to their problem, actually they are strong women in themselves. As they ‘grow’ they realise the error of that way of thinking.


2.5*

Thank you NetGalley and Penguin General UK.

Was this review helpful?

i genuinely cannot believe that leila mottley is only 23 as of right now. she writes characters with such depth, such complexity and nuance to every single one of their choices; in many ways, i feel as though she does exactly what other much older authors have always strived to do in a near-perfect way. i really liked her first novel <i>nightcrawl</i>, but this one was just something else. i adored the three main characters with all my heart — they all made really questionable choices, but mottley made them come across as so endlessly likeable that i could not help but root for all three of them, emory with her dreams of majoring in biology, simone and her fierce love for her two children, and adela, who went from being a sheltered, somewhat annoying upper-middle-class kid to immersing herself in the group. and of course, the budding relationship between emory and adela was absolutely lovely. i don't want to give away any details, but i loved the way mottley inserted it into the story.

besides that, i really liked the snippets we got from the rest of the group, as well as the way mottley describes the florida panhandle with such beauty. i could feel the heat and humidity and the sweat all through the girls' school year, and i really have to commend her for describing such an apparently awful place with such warmth and appeal.

overall, this was a brilliant read. i cannot wait to see what mottley comes up with next; although this is only her second novel, i can already tell that i'm going to dutifully follow the rest of her career. please make sure to check this one out when it gets released on june 24th!

Was this review helpful?

This is an interesting story about teenage pregnancies. The girls form a friendship group centered on an old truck for some reason. This seems a bit dated in attitudes and the girls are still very reliant on men, and are looking for a man to love them and support their children, although they do find their strength in the end. However, there is far too much detail about childbirth and breastfeeding for my liking.

Was this review helpful?

Wasn't sure at first about the book as it was about teenage pregnancies and thought it might be the same as the others. but something about the title and blurb intrigued me so i read on. it's a very different novel to the rest on the subject and delves into all matter of things really well. the title of the book is very direct and lends itself well to the themes within

Was this review helpful?

What an emotional story. How these girls go from taking an unideal situation and not only making the best of it but discovering themselves along the way. I hope it will bring awareness to teen pregnancy and al that it entails.

Was this review helpful?