Member Reviews

Seers and Sibyls, edited by MJ Pankey, is an intriguing collection that explores prophecy, fate, and the mysterious figures who bridge the gap between the mortal and the divine. The anthology presents a diverse range of voices and interpretations, weaving together myth, historical fiction, and fantasy to examine the power—and burden—of foresight.

The strongest stories in the collection are immersive and thought-provoking, offering fresh perspectives on well-known legends as well as original takes on the seer’s role in different cultures and settings. Some entries shine with poetic prose and deeply compelling characters, while others feel slightly underdeveloped, relying more on concept than execution. However, even the weaker stories contribute to the overarching theme, making for a cohesive and enjoyable read.

While Seers and Sibyls doesn’t always hit the highest notes in every entry, it is a well-curated anthology that will appeal to readers fascinated by mysticism, mythology, and the tantalizing question of whether the future is truly set in stone.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this wasn’t for me. I did appreciate how well researched this was. I just felt that it was disjointed and a bit of a slog to get in to.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! It was a fairly quick read, but it was so deep. I keep thinking about some of these stories, even days later. I will definitely be reading this book again in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this collection of short stories and poems. I smiled, cried, and thought about these characters well after I finished reading.

Was this review helpful?

Seers and Sibyls by M.J. Pankey is that girl of a book. It was so good it was an experience reading it. I totally recommend everyone to read this book as fast as they can because it's really good and the characters are fantastic.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you MJ Pankey, Netgalley and Brigids Gate Press for this free ARC in exchange for a review.

This short-story & poetry anthology is hit, miss and ok.

Hits:
The Oracle of Plum Harbor (A Tale from North America), by David Marino
Tiresia’s Life (A Tale of Ancient Greece), by Beth O’Brien
The Ghost of Summer Suns (A Tale from Italy), by N. R. Lambert
Cassandra’s Accounting (A Tale from Ancient Greece), by Jennifer Bushroe
78 (A Tale from the World), by Ivy L. James
Juniel and the Moon (A Tale from Ancient Egypt), by Jay McKenzie

I enjoyed the last one above the most.

Was this review helpful?