Member Reviews

I think this book was interesting and was well-written, but a lot of minor things bothered me. For one, I feel like the chapters were randomly ordered and could be better structured under major headings (a clothing/sewing section, a food section, etc). I also didn't enjoy the random links in the middle of paragraphs and the fact that the pictures were at the very end of the book. This could just be an advanced copy thing and might be fixed in the official release. We get a very good overview of women's work, but I think having more case-study stories (for lack of a better term) would be nice. It was a decent book, just maybe not for me.

Thank you Janet Few, Pen & Sword, and NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

informative with a nice writing style to keep one engaged. it covers an important historical topic in a way that is accessible to most audience, Focusing mostly on British women's work history, with exceptions in a couple chapters that expand a bit further. Kept me curious about each next chapter and I'm glad i was lucky enough to read this early.

Was this review helpful?

I’m pretty torn about this book. I definitely could see myself having used it as a source for a paper in college, and it’s easily digestible, but especially in the first half a lot of smaller things were bothering me.
I did like that we got such a broad overview of so many kinds of women from such a range of time periods. That being said I think I may have more negatives than positives.
I think it’s within the first couple pages that the author refers to ‘ancestresses’ and then (mostly) continues that through the book. I get that it’s about women’s history, but ancestor isn’t a gendered word so ancestress was giving me the same vibes as girl boss where in creating a distinction to focus attention where there’s been a lack of it the attention isn’t equal.
The organization also bothered me. Not just directly having the websites typed out, but also things like having the chapter on glove making between the food and dairy ones, and the health related ones so far apart. It felt very jumpy, and the lack of conclusion sadly didn’t help.

Was this review helpful?