This was a perfectly acceptable mystery story that was let down by some basic errors and frustrations. The repetition disappoints. It may be aimed at younger people, but whole conversations, thoughts and information do not need to be repeated a few pages apart.

There are also some very basic errors that a proof reader should have picked up on - Ashley is the name of the red head who originally is the only one in her class, and yet a few chapters later, it becomes a mysterious Lily for a chapter, then jumps back to being Ashley. Important information is skipped over, ignored and the reader is left to fend for themselves. The group visit Johnson island for the first time and then a chapter later... visit Johnson island for the first time.

The whole mystery starts because they are following clues left by a ghost. I was very confused, thinking I had missed a chapter and then nearly halfway through the ghost is introduced for the first time. And then again, for the first time.

It's a shame, because under the desperate need for proofing, is an entertaining story about the civil war in America, the slave railway and a really good attempt to inspire children to be more interested in history. The fact that the confederate soldiers are presented sympathetically, pushing the reader to think more deeply about the people, not just the overarching view makes it a more nuanced look. There are characters that are interesting, entertaining villains and good old fashioned heroes. It just needs someone to take a good look and edit it. There is so much potential here.

The little bonus prequel at the end was fun, a couple of chapters that promised a better read.

The general idea of this story is very interesting and intriguing. It has the potential to offer a sweet, wholesome tale. Unfortunately, the lack of proper editing impacts the text negatively. I found myself going back and forth between chapters, confused by repeated scenes, mix-up of characters' names, and the overall progression of events.

Miss Understood and the Case of the Missing Locket by Melissa G. Wilson is a fun, clever, and heartfelt mystery that’s perfect for young readers and anyone who enjoys a charming, light-hearted whodunit. The story follows the spirited and intelligent Missy “Miss Understood” as she finds herself tangled in the mystery of a missing family heirloom—and uncovers much more than just a locket along the way.

Missy is a fantastic protagonist—curious, observant, and full of personality. Her voice is both relatable and empowering, making her an inspiring character for young readers, especially girls who love puzzles and aren't afraid to ask questions. The mystery itself is well-paced with just the right amount of suspense, clues, and red herrings to keep things interesting without becoming too complex.

One of the highlights of this book is how it blends mystery with important themes like friendship, self-confidence, and standing up for what’s right. The writing is accessible and engaging, making it a great pick for middle-grade readers. My only small critique is that a few moments could have been fleshed out a bit more for deeper character development—but overall, it’s a delightful and meaningful read.

A solid 4 out of 5 stars! Perfect for fans of Nancy Drew, Harriet the Spy, or any young sleuth ready to solve their next mystery.