Member Reviews

Age gap office romance. Takanashi, 40, is the star of the sales team and the office hottie, lusted after by all women and hated by his peers who malign him behind his back and say he’s slept his way up. But that’s not possible, because he’s impotent.

Hiwatari, 26, is in Takanashi’s team. The older man has been his mentor since Hiwatari was a child, something Takanashi doesn’t seem to recall. At least it’s never brought up. Hiwatari is cold and efficient, demanding perfection, so much so that there’s a complaint against him for bullying. But inside, he’s dreaming of Takanashi.

Work and private life keeps throwing the men together. Hiwatari confesses his feelings and Takanashi finds himself thinking of the younger man more and more. Takanashi is straight though, so when nearness to Hiwatari gives him an erection, he dismisses it as a fluke. The first volume ends before Takanashi has even begun to entertain the possibility he might be into men.

This was a good start for a series. It wasn’t much of a romance yet and comedy was about awkward situations about erectile dysfunction. I don’t know if the men are actually suited for each other, and since Hiwatari has worshipped Takanashi since he was a child, it’s probably not grown-up love on his part, but perhaps the men will learn together. Art was good. I’d read more.

Was this review helpful?

a light-hearted age gap office romance between a superior and subordinate. this was a very chill and relaxing read, as well as funny in moments. i think this will develop nicely! i hope as the series progresses, ren is able to convey his affection and they become closer. i do wonder if the author will directly address them having met when ren was younger though. i think that would be a fun scene to see.

thank you to netgalley and kodansha for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

😂 The name says it all, this is about a dashing ZADDY and his junior team member who’s seen as a stick in the mud but is actually a massive simp for zaddy. Add in that Zaddy has ED and ice prince is so obsessed and adorkable and I’m hooked.


Next please!

Was this review helpful?

This was an absolutely hilarious first volume with hit lines such as "the image of a man roaring in joy from the cellular level." The art and storyboarding made great use of perspectives, expressions, and flow from each panel to the next to add to this hilarity. I always love a good BL of a middle-aged man, and the younger character is an endearing fan boy who I'm cheering on. I can't wait to read the next volume!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, NetGalley for an advanced ARC of this manga

This book was not one for me and I couldn't enjoy it a lot but we have an M&M situation and a character saying his impotent and about his journey.

The story I didn't care about but I do see others enjoying this

Was this review helpful?

This was so hilarious and cute!
It is typical romcom vibes where the characters manage to find themselves in so many awkward and hilarious situations that will have you as the reader kicking your feet and giggling like a maniac.
I also really appreciate that this isn't a standalone! I love when BL is a series so that the characters get the slow burn, more realistic development they deserve and enough time to progress their relationship.
Additionally, we finally see an age gap that isn’t creepy! yay!
I'm so excited to continue the series.

Thank you so much to Netgalley for providing me with an ARC.

Was this review helpful?

It was a fun fast read that made me smile the whole time. The characters are charming, the story was really fun and the artwork was truly incredible.

I'll definitely be reading the next volume!!

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the arc!

Was this review helpful?

This month, Kodansha kicked off their publication of a unique BL series. And in this one, neither guy is as he seems! Young go-getter Hiwatari is physically hot, but ice-cold personality-wise. His overseer, 40-year-old Takanashi, is the whole package in terms of looks, personality, and achievement. But the frigid Hiwatari is actually a sweetheart, and the dashing Takanashi suffers from ED. Or, well, he did. When Hiwatari gets close, it’s all systems go. But why? Takanashi can’t figure it out, but the reader almost certainly can.

This series is packed with cute and charming art, with a healthy dose of humor. The localization stays as lighthearted as the unsubtle visuals. If you prefer your BL humorous and upbeat, pick this one up at once.

Was this review helpful?

Characters: 5/5
I loved how different they were and how they both had very distinct personalities.

Art: 5/5
Art was great. I really liked all the expressions & the colors in the first few pages were beautiful (this is not full color).

Story/Plot: 4/5
This was a simple, lighthearted, and fast-paced manga—perfect for age gap romance fans looking for something silly and fun. If you read the blurb and thought it sounded like your kind of thing, chances are you’ll enjoy it.

Writing/Dialogue: 4/5
No complaints. While some parts were a bit cringe, the translation was really well done. I did find some of the sound effects/onomatopoeia pretty funny & bizarre—I posted a few examples below under minor spoilers.

Giggles: 4/5
Pretty funny. I dunno, I think that stupid silly stuff mixed with a bit of dry humor is just totally my kind of humor. That’s probably why I’ve been so into manga lately—it just lines up with what I find funny.

Spice level: 1/5
I thought this was going to be a lot more explicit with how the first chapter went but it was actually much more on the wholesome side. Which is what I prefer so yay! That being said it looks the ‘cure’ for being impotent will be implemented in the next volume so it’ll probably be a lot more spicy.

tldr:
Cute, very silly, not too deep—a perfect light read, especially if you’re into older men.

Was this review helpful?

The Dashing Zaddy and His Icy Protégé is a cheeky age-gap workplace BL manga, featuring Takanashi, a handsome and charismatic 40-year-old team leader (who secretly has ED), and Hiwatari, his cold and ruthless 26-year-old subordinate (who secretly has a massive crush on him). Volume 1 includes four chapters that introduce our main characters, their circumstances, and the blossoming feelings between them.

As the outrageous premise suggests, the manga is filled with hilarity—with Takanashi’s condition being front and center—but it’s also surprisingly sweet. There’s something so endearing about Hiwatari trying to contain his crush, and Takanashi gradually discovering new, unexpected sides of his aloof colleague.

And of course, you can’t talk about a manga without mentioning the art. Fumito’s art style is gorgeous, and both of our leads are so, so handsome. What I especially appreciate is that Takanashi actually looks 40—like, he has visible signs of aging—and not a generic youthful face we’re supposed to believe is “older”. Fumito is a real old men lover, y’all.

Was this review helpful?

Very cute idiots in love. This felt very short but maybe that is because I had fun while reading it. Very interesting and fun plot with hilarious problems.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Kodansha for the ARC

I absolutely loved this one. It had all the things I love in a good romance and more. With an enjoyable art style and endearing characters it adds a fun new element of your typical office romance with one of the men suffering from ED that he has hidden from the world. It allows for a more personal relationship to develop while also leaving room for Takanashi to explore his own sexuality and ED. All this while Hiwatari can gain a sense of belonging and comfort in having Takanashi confide in him. I will definitely be picking up a physical volume of this one and cannot wait to read the rest of the series as it comes out. Genuinely one of my new favourite non-toxic BL stories thus far.

If you're a fan of the Cherry Magic series I highly recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

Who doesn’t love a zaddy? This was a cute, enjoyable beginning to a love story. Lots of funny moments. I cannot wait to pick up the next volume to see how their romance develops.

Was this review helpful?

thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the e-arc!!

old man bl but one of them is young and they're colleagues!! is it unethical for me to like this?? because oh my god. this is very funny even with Takanashi having erectile dysfunction and i genuinely laughed when his browser history on it popped up during his presentation. Hiwatari taking the fall for it though.....

okay i admit it is a bit weird that they met at 26 and 11 but why are they so cute, help??? Hiwatari is just 100% gone for him and i am all for it. please let the young man cure his erectile dysfunction while the old man gets to know him as someone other than his icy protege at work!!

adding the rest of the series to the tbr because that was such a cliffhanger and i need to know what happens next!!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this! The characters are so loveable and funny, I was gripped from the first page. I love reading age gap romances so a 26yr old pining over a 40yr old in a work setting is right up my alley.

The art style is gorgeous and the balance of character and plot progression was perfect. Excited for Vol 2!!

Was this review helpful?

In spite of being a romcom BL, the first volume of The Dashing Zaddy and His Icy Protégé is surprisingly slow burn—and I quite like it! The art style is exactly my taste, and the two protagonists are both incredibly handsome and genuinely funny together. Fumito strikes a great balance between serious moments and completely unhinged hilarity, making the story all the more engaging. I’m especially glad the zaddy seems to have realized his feelings by the end. I can’t wait for the next volume and to see their relationship finally take that next step!

Was this review helpful?

3.5
This was a pretty cute adult romantic comedy! It's an age gap romance, but they're both full adults, so no worries there. There is a backstory that is briefly touched on where they met when the one character was a child, and that's where the attraction stemmed from, which is...an odd choice. I also find it hilarious that Hiwatari appears to be very cold and intimidating, meanwhile his mental dialogue is him freaking out because his crush looked at him. It's very "gap moe", which is honestly super cute. I was also extremely confused why people keep referring to Takanashi as a "zaddy" since I had never heard of the term before. Apparently, "Zaddy is a slang term for an attractive, stylish, and confident man, often used to describe someone who has a certain charm or swagger. It is a modern twist on the word "daddy" and gained popularity through social media and music." Literally never heard someone use that slang before, but alright, I guess.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

** I WAS GIVEN THIS BOOK FOR MY READING PLEASURE **
Copy received through Netgalley

~

The Dashing Zaddy and His Icy Protégé 1 (Kindle Edition)
by Fumito
★★★★★


This was such a fun story! There's age-gap romance, a case of erectile dysfunction, and a work place romance that all comes together to make the cutest opposites attracts story.

Ren Hiwatari is twenty-six and known as an ice king in the office. He's stern, strict and very professional in all aspects of his life – and he has a super secret man crush on Makoto. Everything Makoto does is brilliant, perfection and adorable to Ren. Which in itself is absolutely adorable!

Makoto Takanashi is forty and known for being the pretty boy, perfectionist in the office. He excels at work, life and is so handsome that people not only stop and stare on the street, but random people take photos of him even when sitting in a cafe. He's just got one little problem – it's been one year since Makokto tower fell and there's been no hope of a resurrection since.

Together, they make the most adorable unlikely couple. Ren is such a fan-boy for Makoto, while Makoto is shocked to discover during one accidental moment – an accident where he ends up wet and has to change in front of Ren – that Makoto tower decides to rise! He's shocked and relieved, but it turns out that the tower only reacts to Ren.

What follows is the cutest, funniest start to the series. I loved that Ren and Makoto don't instantly fall in love due to the situation, but that it ends with a bit of hope and uncertainty. There's great chemistry, brilliant one liners, and a really strong plot with plenty of back story. I absolutely loved the progression from distant work mates to supporting and confiding in each other. The humour was right up my alley; from Ren trying to save Makoto's reputation, the tablet fiasco and the witty one-liners kept me interested right from start to finish.

I'll definitely be getting Volume 2 when it comes out.

Was this review helpful?

Cringe is my least favorite genre but this skirted the line between outrageous and cringe quite well. It was a quick and easy read that basically set the stage for future volumes which is why I only gave it 3 stars. While the storyline makes sense, I do hope that they don’t drag the ED storyline out more, and just admit that Takanashi is big gay.

If they’re able to shift the plot more towards him discovering himself, I’d be really excited to read the next few books. Worth reading if you like LGBTQIA+ content or boisterous commentary.


°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:• Thanks to NetGalley and Kodansha for providing this arc in exchange for my honest feedback. °❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:•

Was this review helpful?

What a cute start to the series! 40 year-old Takanashi and 26 year-old Hiwatari work together and both have personality stereotypes thrust upon them by their co-workers and others. After a night out, they both learn something about the other that starts to change each other's perception.

I immediately like how Takanashi and Hiwatari's don't let the opinions of others influence how they perceive one another and that their relationship starts off with mutual respect. I'm excited to see how their relationship develops, especially after Hiwatari's proclamation at the end 🤭

Thank you to Kodansha and Netgalley for the free read!

Was this review helpful?