This is quite an interesting take on the Bronte family and their relationships. The author uses psychological research, her own experiences and other sources to present her case, mainly that Charlotte was domineering and overshadowed the rest, particularly Anne, who she feels is under appreciated as a person in her own right, and underrated as an author. The argument stands up, but I have issues with the presentation of the book. It reads like an essay or a college dissertation; the author's voice is too strong and it feels like a personal attack on Charlotte (although possibly justified). It is repetitive and a bit too long. She brings modern day thinking and attitudes to bear on her analysis, which is not always relevant. However, it is always good to read more about the enigma that is the Bronte family.

This is a terrific companion piece for anyone interested in the people who produced such wonderful books and poems. The analysis is careful, measured, informed and respectful but does not shy away from offering opinions which some may consider confronting or controversial. The analysis of birth order and childhood experiences is fascinating and gives scope for further consideration of their influence on the works of the Brontes. I particularly enjoyed the analysis of Anne Brontë as the youngest child.