Alexander Masters' A Life Discarded is an intriguing blend of biography and detective story, centered on 148 anonymously discarded diaries. With his characteristic wit and self-awareness, Masters draws readers into his investigation, raising questions about anonymity and the value of personal narratives.

While the book’s unconventional structure and playful storytelling are engaging, the mystery’s resolution may feel underwhelming. At times, Masters’ focus on his own journey overshadows the diarist, making the book as much about the author as his subject. Though uneven, it remains a thought-provoking exploration of storytelling and forgotten lives.