Member Reviews

There are a number of collections of Holmes-inspired stories out there, but the diversity of the material in this book makes it stand out among that genre. Because these writers work in a variety of genres, their approaches to Holmes are original and, at time, surprising.

Was this review helpful?

This is an entertaining collection of short stories, each taking inspiration from the Sherlock Holmes canon. Some are true to the original Victorian setting, others are simply sprinkled with nods to the original stories. While I liked some of the offerings much better than others, I appreciated the range -- no matter what manner of Holmes is your favorite, you'll likely find an enjoyable story or two in this volume.

Was this review helpful?

Love stories of Sherlock Holmes, it bought me back to a bye gone era. Loved to historical aspects of each story.

Was this review helpful?

***This book was reviewed via Netgalley***

Echoes of Sherlock Holmes is a collection of short stories inspired by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's most enduring character, written by a variety of authors. Some stories are set in modern times, others in Holmes’ own time. Some feature versions of Holmes and Watson themselves, others are faint echoes, but echoes nonetheless. Some stories focus more on versions of other characters, or their own faint echoes. No matter how faint the echo, there's no mistaking the inspiration underneath.

I love Sherlock in just about any incarnation, from Doyle's original stories, to the most recent BBC adaptation, so I was quite excited to add this to my prodigious collection of Sherlock books. I enjoyed all of the stories within. Some of my favourites include:

'Holmes on the Range’ by John Connolly- the concept of belief bringing characters to true life, oh I love it! The Caxton Lending Library and Book Depository reminds me of Warehouse 13, but with only books and the living magic they've wrought. I'd love to be the caretaker there and get to interact with literary greats like Sherlock and Watson!

'Before a Bohemian Scandal’ by Tasha Alexander- this is a little story behind why Irene Adler had a compromising photo of the King of Bohemia, and a chance to show she's more than a match for Sherlock. She spent some time with the then Prince of Bohemia, and managed to solve a troubling problem for him. I felt kinda sad at the end though.

'The Spiritualist’ by David Morrell- a story that brings Doyle’s beliefs in the supernatural face to face with the cold logic of Sherlock, quite literally!

'The Adventure of the Empty Grave’ by Jonathan Maberry- probably my most favourite of them all, this take centres around Watson, after Sherlock's ‘death’ at the Falls. He's visiting Sherlock's grave when he is met by Auguste Dupin, of EA Poe fame. Dupin engages Watson in a most Sherlock fashion, before leaving him with a final mystery to solve.

🎻🎻🎻🎻🎻 Highly recommended! Perfect for any fan of Sherlock Holmes.

Was this review helpful?